Analysis and Measurement of Barriers to Green Transformation Behavior of Resource Industries

Cunfang Li, Tao Song, Wenfu Wang, Xinyi Gu, Zhan Li, Yongzeng LaiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the barriers hindering the green transformation of China's resource industries. By analyzing panel data from 29 provinces using DEA-SBM and Tobit models, it identifies key obstacles and their varying impacts across regions, offering crucial insights for policy development to promote sustainable resource development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Resource industries, vital for economic development, often come with significant environmental downsides like pollution, land degradation, and resource depletion. To ensure sustainable growth, these industries need to undergo a "green transformation," shifting towards more efficient, low-emission, and environmentally friendly practices. However, this transformation is not happening uniformly or effectively across China. This paper aims to pinpoint and quantify the specific barriers that impede this crucial green transformation behavior in resource industries, understanding that these barriers might differ in their intensity and regional prevalence.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Green Transformation Efficiency Measurement: The researchers used the Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) Slack-Based Model (SBM) with non-expected outputs. This method is suitable for evaluating efficiency when there are multiple inputs and outputs, including undesirable ones (like pollution), and accounts for variable returns to scale.
  • Barrier Factor Analysis: A Tobit model was used to analyze the factors hindering green transformation. This model is appropriate for situations where the dependent variable (green transformation efficiency) is censored (bounded between 0 and 1).
  • Systematic Analysis: A GEM (Groundings, Enterprises, Markets) analysis model, adapted from existing literature, was used to categorize and understand the interplay of various barrier factors.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data from 29 Chinese provinces for the mining industry from 2012 to 2019. Data sources included:

  • China Industrial Statistical Yearbook
  • China Taxation Yearbook
  • China Science and Technology Statistical Yearbook
  • China Environmental Statistical Yearbook
  • China Sub-Provincial Marketization Index Report
  • Provincial statistical yearbooks and bulletins
  • CNRDS database for green invention patent applications

Monetary data was deflated to a 2012 base year.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Barriers are Real and Significant: The study confirms that barriers to green transformation are not just theoretical but have a tangible, inhibiting effect on the efficiency of these industries.
  • Talent is King (or Queen): "Poor talent" emerged as the most significant barrier, highlighting the critical need for skilled personnel in driving green innovation and implementation.
  • Location Matters, But Not Always How You Think: While "poor location" was initially hypothesized as a barrier, the study found it to be a positive driver in some contexts, suggesting that policy or market pressures associated with location can sometimes push industries towards greener practices.
  • Regional Disparities are Stark: The impact of barriers varies considerably across China's regions, with the Northeast facing unique challenges related to market mechanisms and the Central/Western regions grappling more with management innovation and supply-demand linkages.
  • "Declining Minerals" Aren't the Primary Problem (Nationwide): Surprisingly, "declining minerals" and "weak market mechanism" were found to be not significant barriers at the national level, suggesting that other factors are currently more pressing.

Key Results

The study identified several key findings:

  • Significant Barriers: The most impactful barriers to green transformation efficiency were found to be:
  • Poor talent
    • Weak supply-demand linkage
    • High sunk cost
    • Insufficient capital
    • Weak management innovation
  • Intensity of Barriers: The intensity of these barriers, in descending order of constraint, is: poor talent, weak supply-demand linkage, high sunk cost, insufficient capital, and weak management innovation.
  • Regional Heterogeneity:
    • Northeast: Weak market mechanism is the strongest barrier.
  • Eastern: Poor talent is the strongest barrier, followed by high sunk cost and insufficient capital.
  • Central and Western: Weak management innovation and weak supply-demand linkage are the primary barriers.
  • Robustness: The findings were robust across different model specifications (Tobit vs. Clad) and when using environmental efficiency as a proxy for green transformation efficiency.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • In-depth Analysis of Individual Barriers: The study provided a broad overview but did not delve deeply into the specific mechanisms of each individual barrier, particularly how a barrier might transform into a driver under certain conditions.
  • Timeliness of Data: The use of data from 2012-2019, while chosen to avoid the immediate impact of events like the COVID-19 pandemic, might slightly weaken the timeliness of the findings.

Future research could focus on:

  • More detailed investigations into the dynamics of individual barrier factors.
  • Exploring how barriers might shift to become drivers at specific thresholds.
  • Incorporating more recent data to capture the latest trends and policy impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

To effectively guide and stimulate the green transformation behavior of resource industries and promote the sustainable and high-quality development of the region, it is necessary to deeply analyze and clarify the barrier factors of the green transformation behavior of resource industries. This study measures the green transformation efficiency of the resource industries by selecting the panel data of the mining industry from 29 Chinese provinces, based on the DEA-SBM model, and employing the ideas and methods of system engineering, for the years 2012-2019. Hence, the study employs the Tobit model to verify the factors that hinder the green transformation behavior of the resource industries. The results show that the (1) resource industries' barriers against the green transformation behavior form a significant barrier effect by inhibiting the efficiency of green transformation; (2) there is a difference in the intensity of the effect of the resource industries' barriers to the green transformation behavior; (3) regional heterogeneity exists in the effects of the barriers to the green transformation behavior of the resource industries. The findings of the study can provide a scientific basis for further improving the effectiveness of policies related to the green transformation behavior of resource industries.
BibTeX
@article{li2022analysis,
  author = {Cunfang Li and Tao Song and Wenfu Wang and Xinyi Gu and Zhan Li and Yongzeng Lai},
  title = {{Analysis and Measurement of Barriers to Green Transformation Behavior of Resource Industries}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192113821},
}
Figure