Analysis and Correction of Measurement Error of Spherical Capacitive Sensor Caused by Assembly Error of the Inner Frame in the Aeronautical Optoelectronic Pod

Tianxiang Ma, Shengqi Yang, Yongsen Xu, Dachuan Liu, Jinghua Hou, Yunqing Liu2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of assembly errors in spherical capacitive sensors used in aeronautical optoelectronic pods. The researchers developed a mathematical model and experimental setup to analyze how these errors introduce nonlinearities and offsets, and then proposed and validated a compensation method to significantly improve measurement accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aeronautical optoelectronic pods often rely on precise angular measurement for stabilization and targeting. Spherical joints are attractive transmission mechanisms due to their compact size and multiple degrees of freedom. However, accurately measuring the two degrees of freedom (2-DOF) angular displacement of these joints is problematic. A key issue is the introduction of nonlinear errors caused by imperfections in the assembly of the sensor's inner frame, specifically electrode installation errors. These errors are difficult to decouple and compensate for, limiting the application of spherical joints in high-precision systems. While previous work has explored various sensing methods, this paper specifically addresses the impact of assembly errors on spherical capacitive sensors and proposes a method to correct for them.

Methods

The core of this work involves developing a mathematical model to describe the capacitive sensor's behavior under installation errors. This model accounts for the complex interplay between electrode placement and the resulting capacitance changes. To validate this model, the researchers employed finite element analysis (FEA) using Ansoft Maxwell software. They then designed and built a prototype spherical capacitive sensor and a two-axis experimental platform to conduct real-world measurements. The experimental setup allowed for precise control and measurement of angular displacement. A key aspect of their approach is the development of a compensation algorithm that addresses both zero offsets and slope offsets introduced by installation errors. This compensation is implemented in the signal processing stage.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from their custom-built sensor and experimental setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Assembly Errors are a Major Hurdle: The paper clearly demonstrates that even small deviations in the assembly of the spherical capacitive sensor's electrodes (on the order of micrometers) can lead to significant measurement errors, manifesting as zero offsets and slope errors.
  • Mathematical Modeling is Crucial: The development of a detailed mathematical model that explicitly incorporates installation errors was essential for understanding the root causes of these inaccuracies and for designing an effective compensation strategy.
  • FEA as a Validation Tool: Using finite element analysis provided a powerful way to verify the predictions of the mathematical model, increasing confidence in the theoretical framework before experimental validation.
  • Compensation is Effective: The proposed compensation method, which targets both zero and slope offsets, proved highly effective in reducing measurement errors, bringing the sensor's performance closer to that of an ideal, error-free sensor.
  • Robustness of Capacitive Sensing: Despite the challenges posed by installation errors, the capacitive sensor, when properly compensated, exhibits good robustness and meets the requirements for precise angle measurement in demanding applications like aeronautical pods.

Key Results

  • Resolution: The designed capacitive sensor achieved a resolution of 0.002° within the operating range of ±4°.
  • Repeatability: The repeatability error was measured at 0.86%.
  • Pulse Response Time: The sensor exhibited a pulse response time of 39 µs.
  • Error Reduction: After compensation, the slope offset in the 45° direction was reduced from 9.17% to 0.68%, and the nonlinearity error was reduced to 0.975%. Similar significant reductions were observed in the 150° direction.
  • Zero Offset Reduction: The zero offset of the compensated capacitive sensor was reduced to 0.009°.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Installation Error Magnitude: While the paper investigates errors up to 50 µm, larger installation errors might require further investigation and potentially more sophisticated compensation techniques.
  • Environmental Factors: The paper focuses on installation errors. Future work could explore the sensor's performance under varying environmental conditions (temperature, vibration) which are common in aeronautical applications.
  • Integration into Pods: While the paper suggests suitability for aeronautical photoelectric pods, actual integration and long-term performance testing in such systems would be a valuable next step.
  • Broader Application: The developed compensation method could potentially be adapted for other precision angular measurement systems facing similar assembly challenges.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ma2022analysis,
  author = {Tianxiang Ma and Shengqi Yang and Yongsen Xu and Dachuan Liu and Jinghua Hou and Yunqing Liu},
  title = {{Analysis and Correction of Measurement Error of Spherical Capacitive Sensor Caused by Assembly Error of the Inner Frame in the Aeronautical Optoelectronic Pod}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22239543},
}
Figure