Análisis de la viabilidad y aplicación de un coagulante combinado a base de semillas de moringa oleífera en el tratamiento de aguas

Daniel Fernando Erazo, A. Vargas, Diego A. NunezInvestigación 2024 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the technical viability of a biocoagulant derived from Moringa oleifera (MO) seeds as a sustainable alternative to traditional inorganic salts in water treatment. By employing a 4x2 factorial design, researchers investigated the combined effect of MO biocoagulants and aluminum sulfate across various saline concentrations (0.25M, 0.5M, and 0.75M NaCl). Results demonstrate that a 50/50 combination of aluminum sulfate and MO biocoagulant (extracted in 0.5M NaCl) achieves up to 98% removal of turbidity and color. While the hybrid approach significantly reduces chemical requirements, limitations in the biocoagulant's shelf life highlight the need for further research into preservation methods.

Introduction

Conventional water treatment processes rely heavily on inorganic coagulants, most notably aluminum sulfate. Despite their effectiveness in removing suspended solids, these chemicals present significant environmental and health challenges. Their use generates large volumes of toxic, metal-rich sludge that is difficult to manage. Furthermore, residual aluminum concentrations in treated drinking water have been tentatively linked to neurological health risks.

Natural biocoagulants, such as those extracted from Moringa oleifera seeds, offer a biodegradable, non-toxic, and locally available alternative. However, standalone biocoagulants often struggle with lower efficiency or require prohibitively high dosages. This research explores a hybrid strategy—a combined coagulant system—designed to leverage the strengths of both inorganic and organic agents to minimize chemical use while maintaining rigorous water quality standards.

Methodology

The study focused on optimizing the extraction of active cationic proteins from MO seeds and testing their performance in a hybrid system.

Biocoagulant Preparation and Extraction

MO seeds were processed by shelling, oil extraction via cold pressing, grinding, and sieving. To extract the active proteins, the resulting powder was dissolved in saline solutions of varying concentrations (0.25M, 0.5M, and 0.75M NaCl). This "salting-in" technique is crucial for increasing the solubility of the globulin proteins responsible for coagulation.

Experimental Design

A 4x2 factorial design was implemented using jar tests on synthetic water samples (a mixture of bentonite and humus with an initial turbidity of ~100 NTU). The researchers tested different volumetric ratios of aluminum sulfate (AS) to MO biocoagulant, ranging from 100% AS to 100% MO, across the three saline extraction levels.

Characterization and Stability

The team utilized Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) to identify key functional groups (amides and hydroxyls) and measured the hydrodynamic diameter of particles to assess the impact of salt concentration on solubility. Additionally, the stability of the biocoagulant was monitored over 110 days to evaluate protein degradation and microbial growth.

Results and Discussion

The "Salting-In" Effect

The study confirmed that ionic strength significantly impacts the biocoagulant's physical properties. Increasing the NaCl concentration from 0M to 0.75M resulted in a 75% reduction in particle size (from ~801 nm to ~202 nm), indicating superior protein dispersion and solubility at higher salt levels.

Synergistic Coagulation Mechanisms

The MO biocoagulant operates through multiple mechanisms: charge neutralization, adsorption, and inter-particle bridging. When combined with aluminum sulfate, these mechanisms act synergistically. The MO proteins facilitate the formation of complex "nets" that trap suspended solids, leading to faster and more robust floc formation than either component could achieve alone.

Optimal Performance

The most effective results were observed with a 50/50 volumetric ratio of aluminum sulfate and MO biocoagulant extracted in 0.5M NaCl. This configuration achieved a 98% removal rate for both turbidity and color, meeting the standards set by Colombian water quality regulations (Resolution 2115 of 2007). Crucially, this hybrid approach allowed for a 50% reduction in the required dosage of inorganic aluminum sulfate.

Conclusion

The integration of Moringa oleifera biocoagulants with traditional aluminum sulfate presents a viable path toward more sustainable water treatment. By optimizing the saline extraction process, it is possible to significantly reduce the environmental footprint of water purification without sacrificing efficiency.

However, the practical application of this technology faces a significant hurdle: shelf life. The study observed substantial protein degradation after 60 days, and the saline environment was found to encourage the growth of halophilic bacteria. Future research must prioritize the development of stabilization techniques, such as freeze-drying or the use of natural preservatives, to ensure the long-term viability of MO-based biocoagulants for industrial-scale use.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objetivo: Hacer un análisis de viabilidad técnica de un biocoagulante derivado de semillas de Moringa oleífera, como una alternativa para reducir el consumo de sales inorgánicas, aprovechando el efecto combinado de coagulantes inorgánicos y biocoagulantes. Metodología: Para llevar a cabo este estudio, se empleó un diseño factorial 4x2 en el cual se disolvió el biocoagulante combinado en diferentes concentraciones de cloruro de sodio (0.25M, 0.5M y, 0.75M) con el objetivo de determinar la eficiencia en la eliminación de turbiedad, color y potencial Z en distintos niveles de combinación de biocoagulante y sulfato de aluminio. Resultados: Los resultados señalaron que el polvo de Moringa (MO), al interactuar con otros compuestos mediante adsorción, puentes y complejos, facilita la coagulación, promoviendo la formación de flocs. Además, se observó que al diluir el polvo en solución salina de 0.75 M se obtiene un biocoagulante que conserva parte de los componentes activos, pese a la degradación parcial de algunas proteínas. En contraste, con una concentración de sal de 0.5 M y una combinación de sulfato de aluminio y Moringa oleífera de 50/50, se lograron remociones de hasta un 98% de turbiedad y color. Conclusión: Se evidenció el alto potencial del coagulante combinado para reducir la turbiedad y el color en el agua con un menor requerimiento de sales inorgánicas. Sin embargo, se observó una limitación en la vida útil del biocoagulante, lo que sugiere la necesidad de investigar métodos para prolongar su conservación.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{erazo2024analisis,
  author = {Daniel Fernando Erazo and A. Vargas and Diego A. Nunez},
  title = {{Análisis de la viabilidad y aplicación de un coagulante combinado a base de semillas de moringa oleífera en el tratamiento de aguas}},
  booktitle = {Investigación},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.17081/invinno.12.2.7069},
}
Figure