An understanding of the literacy levels of students, who are deaf/hard-of-hearing in the United States, China, and South Korea.

Ye Wang, Chongmin Lee, Peter V. PaulL1 2009 · DOI

Abstract

This paper presents a synthesis of research findings regarding the literacy levels and difficulties of deaf and hard-of-hearing (DHH) children and adolescents in the United States, China, and South Korea. By examining the achievement levels across three distinct writing systems—English, Chinese, and Korean—we establish an explanatory framework for the current status of DHH literacy. We assert that writing systems are designed to fit the phonological structures of their respective languages and that a reciprocal, facilitative relationship exists between lower-level decoding and higher-level comprehension. For DHH students to achieve literacy, they must develop competence in phonology and general language components, often requiring specialized instruction to bridge the gap between visual print and linguistic meaning.

The Problem: The Universal Literacy Plateau

For over a century, researchers have documented a persistent "literacy plateau" among DHH students. In the United States, historical data dating back to 1916, alongside modern statistics from the Gallaudet Research Institute, show that the average DHH student leaves high school with reading skills at a third- or fourth-grade level.

This struggle appears to be universal, transcending specific languages and writing systems. Similar patterns of stagnation are observed in China and South Korea. This paper investigates whether these difficulties are tied to specific orthographies (writing systems) or if they stem from a fundamental challenge in accessing the underlying linguistic structures necessary for reading.

Comparative Orthographic Analysis

A central question in DHH literacy research is whether certain writing systems are more accessible to visual learners.

  • English (Alphabetic/Opaque): English is an alphabetic system where the relationship between letters and sounds is often inconsistent (e.g., the different sounds of "a" in "rain" vs. "plaid").
  • Korean (Alphabetic/Transparent): Hangul is a highly logical and transparent alphabetic system with consistent letter-sound correspondence.
  • Chinese (Morphosyllabic): Often mistaken as purely pictographic, 81% of modern Chinese characters are actually "semantic-phonetic compounds." This means they contain a component that provides a clue to the word's pronunciation.

Despite these differences, DHH students in all three countries consistently struggle to progress beyond a primary-school literacy level. The "Korean Paradox" is particularly telling: even with a highly transparent and logical script, South Korean DHH students graduate at a 4th- or 5th-grade level. This suggests that the primary barrier to literacy is not the complexity of the script, but the difficulty in accessing the phonological code of the spoken language.

The Reciprocal Model of Literacy

Literacy development is not a one-way street from decoding to understanding. Instead, it relies on a reciprocal relationship between lower-level skills (decoding) and higher-level skills (comprehension and composition).

  1. Decoding to Comprehension: Efficient decoding frees up cognitive resources, allowing the reader to focus on meaning.
  2. Comprehension to Decoding: A strong grasp of vocabulary, syntax, and semantics allows a reader to "guess" or learn new words through context.

DHH students often lack the phonological "glue"—the mental representation of language sounds—needed to connect these two levels. Without this bridge, they remain stuck in a cycle of rote visual recognition that does not scale to complex texts.

Key Findings and Instructional Deficits

  • Phonological Necessity: The research indicates that phonology is a cognitive representation, not just an auditory one. DHH students can develop phonological awareness through visual modes like Cued Speech or Visual Phonics, which use hand signals to represent phonemes.
  • Instructional Gaps: In China, reading instruction for DHH students has historically relied on "whole-word" visual recognition. By ignoring the phonetic elements of characters, this approach may contribute to the observed literacy gap.
  • Universal Stagnation: Across all three linguistic regions, DHH students typically graduate high school with a 3rd- to 5th-grade reading level, reinforcing the idea that hearing loss creates a significant barrier to the phonological structures required for advanced reading.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge a significant "dearth of research" and a lack of reliable, up-to-date statistics on DHH literacy in China compared to the U.S. Furthermore, there is a critical need for intervention research in South Korea and China to test the efficacy of phonics-based or visual-phonological instruction.

Future studies must determine if phonological awareness acquired through visual modes (like Cued Speech) is cognitively equivalent to that acquired through hearing and if it can lead to the same level of reading fluency and automaticity. To break the literacy plateau, global educational strategies must focus on providing DHH learners with a robust, accessible phonological framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a synthesis of the research findings of the literacy levels and difficulties of deaf/hard of hearing children and adolescents in the United States, China, and South Korea. After discussing general achievement levels, we provide a brief introduction to the nature of the three writing systems (English, Chinese, and Korean) to establish an explanatory framework that accounts for the status of the current literacy levels. We assert that the three writing systems are designed, at the least, to fit the phonological structures of the languages for which they represent. We also argue that there is a reciprocal, facilitative relationship between lower-level (e.g., decoding) and higher-level (e.g., comprehension, composing) skills. To establish this reciprocity, children need to develop competence in phonology, specifically, and in other general language components (e.g., morphology, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics) of the language of print. Many children may also need to learn how to comprehend or compose (e.g., develop higher level metacognitive, inferencing skills).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2009understanding,
  author = {Ye Wang and Chongmin Lee and Peter V. Paul},
  title = {{An understanding of the literacy levels of students, who are deaf/hard-of-hearing in the United States, China, and South Korea.}},
  booktitle = {L1},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.17239/l1esll-2010.10.01.06},
}
Figure