An Overview of Sandbox Experiment on Ground Heat Exchangers

Sihan Zhou, Lijie Zhu, Runan Wan, Tao Zhang, Yong‐Zheng Zhang, Yi Zhan, Fang Wang, Linfeng Zhang, Tian YouSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This review provides a comprehensive overview of sandbox experiments used to study ground heat exchangers (GHEs), a key component of energy-efficient ground-source heat pump systems. By categorizing and summarizing existing research on borehole and energy pile experiments, the paper highlights their importance in understanding heat transfer and validating simulation models, ultimately aiming to promote wider adoption of these sustainable technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ground-source heat pumps (GSHPs) are crucial for reducing building energy consumption and achieving carbon neutrality. However, the performance of GSHPs heavily relies on the efficiency of their ground heat exchangers (GHEs). While simulation models are useful, they often require experimental validation. Field tests are expensive and difficult to control. Sandbox experiments offer a controllable and repeatable environment to study GHEs, but a consolidated understanding of the various experimental approaches and their findings has been lacking. This paper addresses this gap by systematically reviewing and categorizing existing sandbox experiments for GHEs, providing a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners.

Methods

The paper categorizes sandbox experiments into two main types: borehole sandbox experiments and energy pile sandbox experiments.

Borehole sandbox experiments are further classified into:

  • Single borehole experiments: Focus on individual borehole heat transfer mechanisms.
  • Borehole group experiments: Investigate the thermal interference between multiple boreholes.
  • Seepage experiments: Simulate the impact of groundwater flow (vertical and horizontal) on heat transfer.
  • Multi-layer soil experiments: Examine heat transfer in soil with varying thermal properties.

Energy pile sandbox experiments are divided into:

  • Mechanical performance tests: Assess the impact of thermal cycles and loads on pile settlement and bearing capacity.
  • Thermal performance tests: Study heat transfer characteristics under various operating conditions.
  • Thermal-mechanical coupled performance tests: Investigate the interplay between thermal and mechanical behavior.

For each category, the review details the sandbox design, experimental setup, testing conditions, and analysis of results.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing experimental studies, not a presentation of new experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spiral tubes outperform U-tubes: For single boreholes, spiral tubes show superior heat exchange efficiency compared to single U-tubes, with double spiral tubes being even more effective (e.g., 80% higher efficiency than single spiral tubes).
  • Seepage significantly enhances heat transfer: Both vertical and horizontal seepage flows improve heat transfer capacity and lead to more uniform soil temperature distribution, with heat transfer being intensified in the direction of seepage.
  • Soil layering matters: The thermal conductivity of different soil layers has a significant impact on overall GHE performance, with the lower soil layers showing a particularly noteworthy influence.
  • Energy piles offer higher heat transfer rates: Compared to boreholes, energy piles, with their larger diameter and shorter length, generally achieve higher heat transfer rates.
  • Thermal cycling affects pile integrity: Repeated heating and cooling cycles in energy piles can lead to irreversible settlement and affect their bearing capacity, especially under higher loads.
  • Radial heat transfer is more dominant in energy piles: The heat transfer distance in the radial direction for energy piles is significantly greater than in the vertical direction.

Key Results

  • Borehole experiments: Demonstrated that increasing spiral pitch and tube spacing can enhance heat transfer. Seepage experiments showed that higher seepage velocities lead to reduced soil temperature variations and increased heat transmission distance in the seepage direction. Multi-layer soil experiments revealed that lower soil layers with higher thermal conductivity significantly improve heat transfer coefficients.
  • Energy pile experiments: Showed that the settlement of energy piles increases with higher head loads and thermal cycles. The W-type energy pile exhibited the highest heat exchange rate among tested configurations, while the single U-shaped pile had the lowest. Thermal cycling in energy piles can cause soil to dry and wet, impacting volumetric water content and temperature.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several challenges and limitations in current sandbox experiments:

  • Similarity issues: Establishing true similarity for practical projects with deep, narrow boreholes is difficult, potentially limiting the applicability of experimental data.
  • Measurement accuracy: The small scale of sandboxes restricts heat duty and accurate temperature measurements, affecting the direct applicability of results.
  • Boundary condition control: Precisely maintaining idealized adiabatic and isothermal boundaries is challenging.
  • Soil property testing: Low accuracy in soil thermophysical property testing, influenced by sampling and soil compactness, is a concern.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Investigating GHEs under more complex environmental conditions, such as three-dimensional seepage and multi-layered soils, and exploring seepage in shallow boreholes.
  • Studying novel composite energy geostructures (energy piles, walls, tunnels) and their integration with boreholes.
  • Exploring the use of new materials like nanofluids and phase change materials to enhance heat transfer and mitigate soil temperature variations.
  • Conducting experiments on new technologies and materials to verify their feasibility and performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an energy-efficient and low-carbon technology, ground-source heat pumps are promising to contribute to carbon neutrality in the building sector. A crucial component of these systems is the ground heat exchanger, which has been extensively studied through sandbox experiments. These experiments play a vital role in understanding heat transfer characteristics and validating simulation results. In order to facilitate the improvement of ground heat exchangers and the development of ground-source heat-pump systems, this article provides a comprehensive summary of existing sandbox experiments. The borehole sandbox experiments are classified into the single borehole experiment, borehole group experiment, seepage experiment, and multi-layer soil experiment. It was observed that the heat transfer efficiency of a single spiral tube is only 80% compared to that of a double spiral tube. Moving on to energy-pile sandbox experiments, they are further divided into mechanical performance, thermal performance, and thermal-mechanical coupled performance tests. It was revealed that the heat transfer distance of a single U-shaped energy pile in the radial direction is three times greater than in the vertical direction. For the mentioned sandbox experiments, the sandbox design, experiment conduction, testing conditions, and result analyses are summarized. To improve the sandbox experiments, there are still some difficulties in building a similarity experiment, testing the temperatures in a small error, controlling the boundary conditions accurately, and testing the thermophysical properties of soil accurately. Furthermore, the perspectives of sandbox experiments of ground heat exchangers are also proposed. The sandbox experiments under complex environment conditions or with novel composite energy geo-structures or ground heat exchangers with new materials and new technologies would be further investigated. By addressing these aspects, this review aims to provide guidelines for the design, construction, operation, and optimization of sandbox experiments for different ground heat exchangers, ultimately promoting the wider adoption of ground-source heat pumps in achieving carbon neutrality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2023overview,
  author = {Sihan Zhou and Lijie Zhu and Runan Wan and Tao Zhang and Yong‐Zheng Zhang and Yi Zhan and Fang Wang and Linfeng Zhang and Tian You},
  title = {{An Overview of Sandbox Experiment on Ground Heat Exchangers}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151411095},
}
Figure