TL;DR
French forests, once a significant carbon sink, are experiencing a rapid decline in their capacity to absorb CO2, primarily driven by increased tree mortality due to climate change. This study analyzes national forest inventory data from 1990-2022, revealing a concerning trend that jeopardizes France's climate neutrality goals and highlights the urgent need for improved, high-resolution monitoring techniques.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Forests play a crucial role in mitigating climate change by sequestering atmospheric carbon dioxide. France, in particular, has historically relied on its forests as a substantial carbon sink. However, recent observations suggest a worrying trend: the rate at which French forests absorb CO2 has been declining. This paper investigates the causes and implications of this decline, aiming to understand the changes in carbon storage over the past three decades and to identify areas for improvement in how we monitor these vital ecosystems. The challenge lies in accurately quantifying these changes, especially given the increasing frequency of climate-related disturbances like droughts and pest outbreaks, which traditional monitoring methods may not fully capture.
Methods
The study primarily utilizes data from the French National Forest Inventory (NFI), which provides systematic measurements of forest growing stock, gains, and losses. This data is processed by CITEPA, the national carbon inventory agency, to estimate carbon accounting. The researchers analyze these statistics from 1990 to 2022, looking at national and regional trends. They also explore the potential of advanced techniques, such as remote sensing (RS) and LiDAR, to complement traditional ground-based NFI data for more detailed and frequent monitoring, particularly for tracking disturbances and mortality.
Datasets
- CITEPA statistics on forest carbon accounting: This forms the primary dataset, derived from the French National Forest Inventory (NFI) and other sources.
- National Forest Inventory (NFI) data: Collected from systematic samples of forest plots across Metropolitan France.
- Remote Sensing (RS) data: Including Sentinel-2 (optical imagery) and Sentinel-1 (SAR imagery) for vegetation and canopy structure analysis.
- LiDAR data: From missions like NASA's GEDI and airborne LiDAR campaigns for 3D forest structure analysis.
- High-resolution satellite imagery: From private constellations like Maxar and Planet Labs for detailed tree-level analysis.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The French forest carbon sink is shrinking: The most striking finding is the significant decline in the net carbon sink of French forests, from a peak in 2008 to a much lower level in recent years. This is a critical issue for national climate targets.
- Mortality is the new driver of decline: While growth has remained relatively stable, increased tree mortality, particularly due to climate-induced stressors like droughts and pest outbreaks, is now the primary factor driving the reduction in carbon sequestration.
- Regional disparities are significant: The decline is not uniform across France. Some regions are becoming net emitters of CO2, while others maintain a stable or even increasing carbon sink, highlighting the complex interplay of climate, management, and forest type.
- Traditional NFI has limitations for rapid change detection: While valuable for long-term trends, the semi-permanent plot design of the NFI, with its 5-year revisit interval, struggles to capture the immediate impacts of sudden disturbance events, leading to a lag in reporting.
- Remote sensing offers a promising future: Advanced technologies like satellite imagery and LiDAR, combined with AI and machine learning, hold the key to more frequent, high-resolution monitoring of forest health and carbon dynamics, enabling better detection and attribution of disturbances.
Key Results
- The net carbon removal by French forests decreased from 49.3 MtCO2·yr⁻¹ in 1990 to 37.8 MtCO2·yr⁻¹ in 2022.
- A peak in carbon removal was observed in 2008 (74.1 MtCO2·yr⁻¹), followed by a sharp decline from 2013 to 2017.
- Natural mortality has increased dramatically, especially since 2013, contributing significantly to the decline in the carbon sink.
- Two northern regions (Hauts-de-France and Grand Est) have become net emitters of CO2.
- Other regions like Normandy, Corsica, and Bourgogne-Franche-Comté have seen their carbon sinks decline to near zero.
- Intensively managed plantations in Les Landes continue to show an increasing carbon sink, contrasting with declines elsewhere.
Limitations and Future Work
- Lag in traditional monitoring: The 5-year revisit interval of the NFI means that the full impact of recent climate shocks (e.g., 2022 and 2023 droughts) is not yet precisely captured. Delayed tree mortality can also manifest years after an event.
- Data continuity challenges: Changes in NFI sampling protocols over time limit the ability to establish a perfectly harmonized long-term view of forest carbon fluxes.
- Harvest data pre-2010: Harvest statistics before 2010 are less reliable due to the use of external and indirect data sources, affecting the continuity of the analysis.
- Deadwood carbon not fully accounted for: While deadwood is increasing due to higher mortality, its carbon impact is not consistently measured or reported in national inventories, representing a significant data gap.
- Future work recommendations:
- Develop more robust methods for reconstituting historical harvest data.
- Enhance the temporal resolution of forest attribute time series.
- Integrate deadwood carbon stock changes into carbon accounting.
- Amplify scientific dialogue between remote sensing and forest inventory experts.
- Develop AI and data integration methods for monitoring forest carbon gains and losses using satellite and airborne imagery.
- Improve the accuracy of wood density quantification for biomass estimation.
- Strengthen the tracking of natural tree mortality, especially in light of recent increases.
Summary updated