An outlook on the Rapid Decline of Carbon Sequestration in French Forests and associated reporting needs

Philippe Ciais, Chuanlong Zhou, Pascal Schneider, Martin Schwartz, Nikola Bešič, Cédric Vega, Jean‐Daniel BontempsarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this study, we present and discuss changes in carbon storage in the French forests from 1990 to 2022, derived from CITEPA statistics on forest carbon accounting, fed by National Forest Inventory (NFI) data collected through an extensive network of measurement sites across Metropolitan France, and other data sources as regards forest removals. The NFI is designed to provide statistical estimations of growing stock, gains and losses at the national or subnational levels but is unable, in its classical form, to provide detailed spatial outlook, such as on abrupt losses during fires, droughts and insect attacks. A continuing removal of CO2 from the atmosphere by the French forests occurred from 1990 to 2022, because harvest and mortality CO2 losses remained smaller than CO2 removals by forest growth and the increase in forest area (70,000 ha per year but insignificant in terms of increased carbon stocks at present). The CO2 removal by forests was 49.3 MtCO2 yr-1 in 1990, increased to reach a peak of 74.1 MtCO2 yr-1 in 2008 and then quickly decreased down to 37.8 Mton CO2 yr-1 in 2022. After 2017, the sink remained low and mortality rates stayed larger than during any of the previous years. This recent period is marked by climate shocks such as summer droughts and heatwaves in 2015, 2018, 2022, 2023. The full impacts of the droughts in 2022 and 2023 are not yet covered with full precision, as some of the sites measured by the national inventory before those droughts are still pending a second visit. The different regions of France show contrasted trajectories. Southern Mediterranean regions where forests have a low harvest rate have experienced a lower increase in mortality and a sustained CO2 uptake.

Introduction

To achieve national "Net Zero" targets, many countries rely on forests to act as a reliable carbon sink. However, this sequestration capacity is not a static guarantee. In France, the ability of forests to store carbon is declining at an alarming rate. This paper addresses the sequestration crisis driven by increased tree mortality and the critical reporting gap inherent in traditional inventory methods, which struggle to capture abrupt climate-induced shocks in real-time.

Methodology and Data Sources

The study synthesizes long-term statistical data from CITEPA (the French agency for greenhouse gas inventory) and the National Forest Inventory (NFI), which provides ground-truth data from approximately 7,000 plots measured annually. To overcome the limitations of ground-based sampling, the researchers highlight a transition toward "multi-source" inventories. This involves using Deep Learning (U-Net models) to fuse satellite data from ESA’s Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 missions with spaceborne LiDAR from GEDI. This approach allows for the creation of high-resolution (10m) biomass and height maps, which can detect disturbances far more rapidly than traditional 5-year inventory cycles.

The Decline of the French Forest Carbon Sink

The analysis reveals a dramatic shift in the carbon balance of French forests. After a period of growth that peaked in 2008 with a net sequestration of 74.1 MtCO2/yr, the sink capacity has plummeted. By 2022, the net removal had fallen to 37.8 MtCO2/yr—a reduction of nearly 50% in just 14 years.

Figure 1: Evolution of the French forest carbon sink (1990-2022). Panel (a) shows the components of emissions and sinks. Panel (b) illustrates the net balance versions and rolling averages. Panel (c) compares the total GHG emissions and net balance against the SNBC-2 and SNBC-3 budget targets.

As shown in Figure 1, this decline is primarily attributed to a surge in natural mortality rather than increased harvesting. While harvest rates have remained relatively stable, mortality from droughts and heatwaves (notably in 2015, 2018, and 2022) has tripled in several regions. This rapid decline poses a significant challenge to the "Stratégie Nationale Bas Carbone" (SNBC) targets, as seen in Figure 1c, where actual sequestration is increasingly falling short of previous policy expectations (SNBC-2), necessitating more conservative targets in the upcoming SNBC-3 cycle.

Regional Disparities and Species Vulnerability

The sequestration crisis is not uniform across France. Northern and Eastern regions, such as Grand Est and Hauts-de-France, have transitioned from sinks to net emitters of CO2. In the Jura and Vosges mountains, volume-based mortality surged by 10-fold and 6-fold respectively between 2015 and 2023. Species such as Norway spruce, European ash, and silver fir have proven particularly vulnerable to these climatic shifts. Conversely, Southern Mediterranean regions have shown greater resilience, maintaining a sustained CO2 uptake despite broader national trends.

Addressing the Reporting Gap

A critical issue identified is the "reporting lag" in traditional NFI methods. Because official reports often rely on 5-year running averages to maintain statistical precision, the immediate impacts of extreme events—like the massive 2022 wildfires or bark beetle outbreaks—may not be fully reflected in policy-making data for several years. The authors advocate for a "virtuous integration" of ground plots with high-frequency satellite monitoring to provide the real-time insights necessary for urgent climate interventions.

Conclusion

The rapid weakening of the French forest carbon sink underscores the fragility of nature-based solutions in a warming climate. To meet national carbon neutrality goals, it is imperative to supplement traditional inventories with high-resolution remote sensing. This will enable more agile policy responses to forest disturbances and provide a more accurate, timely picture of the nation's progress toward its climate commitments.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, we present and discuss changes in carbon storage in the French forests from 1990 to 2022, derived from CITEPA statistics on forest carbon accounting, fed by National Forest Inventory (NFI) data collected through an extensive network of measurement sites across Metropolitan France, and other data sources as regards forest removals. The NFI is designed to provide statistical estimations of growing stock, gains and losses at the national or subnational levels but is unable, in its classical form, to provide detailed spatial outlook, such as on abrupt losses during fires, droughts and insect attacks. A continuing removal of CO2 from the atmosphere by the French forests occurred from 1990 to 2022, because harvest and mortality CO2 losses remained smaller than CO2 removals by forest growth and the increase in forest area (70,000 ha per year but insignificant in terms of increased carbon stocks at present). The CO2 removal by forests was 49.3 MtCO2 yr-1 in 1990, increased to reach a peak of 74.1 MtCO2 yr-1 in 2008 and then quickly decreased down to 37.8 Mton CO2 yr-1 in 2022. After 2017, the sink remained low and mortality rates stayed larger than during any of the previous years. This recent period is marked by climate shocks such as summer droughts and heatwaves in 2015, 2018, 2022, 2023. The full impacts of the droughts in 2022 and 2023 are not yet covered with full precision, as some of the sites measured by the national inventory before those droughts are still pending a second visit. The different regions of France show contrasted trajectories. Southern Mediterranean regions where forests have a low harvest rate have experienced a lower increase in mortality and a sustained CO2 uptake.
BibTeX
@misc{ciais2025outlook,
  author = {Philippe Ciais and Chuanlong Zhou and Pascal Schneider and Martin Schwartz and Nikola Bešič and Cédric Vega and Jean‐Daniel Bontemps},
  title = {{An outlook on the Rapid Decline of Carbon Sequestration in French Forests and associated reporting needs}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2505.11512},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.11512},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure