TL;DR
This paper investigates a severe outbreak of multi-drug resistant (MDR) enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) in a neonatal ward in Southwest China. The study identified bottle milk feeding as a significant risk factor and highlighted the challenges in diagnosing and controlling ETEC infections, especially when they present with unusual resistance patterns.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Diarrheal diseases remain a major cause of mortality in developing countries, with enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) being a significant culprit. The rapid spread of multi-drug resistant (MDR) pathogens complicates treatment and public health responses. This paper addresses the challenge of identifying the source and transmission routes of an ETEC outbreak in a neonatal ward, where infants are particularly vulnerable. The authors highlight that common gastrointestinal pathogens were initially ruled out, and the unusual resistance patterns of the ETEC strain made diagnosis and effective treatment difficult, underscoring the need to consider ETEC even in atypical presentations.
Methods
The investigation employed a multi-pronged approach:
- Initial Investigation and Case Definition: A retrospective review of medical records in all neonatal wards in Zigong City was conducted from April to July 2012. A suspected case was defined by specific stool characteristics and frequency, while a confirmed case required laboratory confirmation of E. coli O128:H45.
- Environmental and Epidemiological Investigation: This involved reviewing supply records for milk powder and water, collecting samples for microbial testing, and observing the milk preparation process, bottle feeding practices, and hand hygiene of nurses in the neonatal ward.
- Case-Control Study: A matched case-control study was performed using medical records from Hospital B. Cases were defined as patients with diarrhea, and controls were patients without diarrhea hospitalized during the same period. Variables such as gender, age, birth weight, and volume of bottle milk feeding were collected.
- Microbiological Testing: Clinical samples (stool, diaper swabs) from patients, nurses, and doctors, as well as environmental samples from neonatal wards and milk powder, were tested for various pathogenic bacteria. Advanced techniques like CHROMagar ECC medium, API 20E biochemical identification, serotyping, and PCR for virulence genes were used. Antibiotic resistance was assessed using the Etest method.
- Data Analysis: Statistical analysis was performed using Epi Info 7, employing Fisher's exact test and matched logistic regression.
Datasets
The study utilized medical records from four hospitals in Zigong City for the period of April 1 to July 30, 2012. This included records of 532 admitted neonates, with 60 suspected and 13 confirmed cases of ETEC infection. Environmental samples and clinical samples from patients, nurses, and doctors were also collected and analyzed. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bottle milk feeding as a significant transmission vehicle: The case-control study strongly implicated bottle milk feeding, with a 4.6-fold increased risk of infection per liter of milk consumed. This suggests that the preparation or handling of milk was a critical point of contamination.
- MDR ETEC poses a diagnostic challenge: The ETEC strain identified was multi-drug resistant, exhibiting resistance to common antibiotics. This resistance pattern initially misled the investigation, as empirical antibiotic treatments were ineffective, leading to consideration of viral infections.
- Importance of considering ETEC in neonatal diarrhea: The outbreak underscores that ETEC should be a differential diagnosis for severe, cholera-like diarrhea in neonates, especially when standard pathogens are not identified.
- Hygiene and infrastructure vulnerabilities: The investigation revealed bacterial contamination exceeding standards in the neonatal ward and identified potential vulnerabilities in the milk preparation room's proximity to the bathroom and shared water supply, as well as nurses' hand hygiene practices.
- Transmission beyond the primary hospital: The identification of confirmed cases in Hospitals A and C, even after Hospital B stopped admitting new diarrhea patients, indicated that transmission extended beyond the initial outbreak site.
Key Results
- A total of 532 patients were admitted during the study period, with 60 suspected and 13 confirmed cases of ETEC infection.
- Hospital B had a significantly higher attack rate (15.4%) compared to other hospitals.
- The case-control study found a 4.6-fold increased risk of infection associated with each liter of bottle milk feeding (OR = 4.6, 95% CI = 1.50-14.70).
- The identified ETEC strain was serotype O128:H45, carrying the virulence gene stIb.
- This ETEC clone exhibited full resistance to amoxicillin, piperacillin, cefalotin, cefotaxime, and sulfamethoxazole, and intermediate resistance to ceftazidime.
- Bacterial contamination was found to be over-standard in certain areas of the neonatal ward in Hospital B.
Limitations and Future Work
- Identification of the clone's origin: While the MDR nature of the ETEC clone suggested it evolved in an antimicrobial-rich environment, the investigation could not definitively identify whether it originated in Hospital B or was brought in by a patient.
- Direct evidence of milk contamination: The investigation team did not find direct evidence of milk contamination, as disinfection and instrument changes had already been implemented in Hospital B prior to their investigation.
- Case and exposure period definition: The authors note that identifying cases and exposed hospitals for neonates, who frequently experience physiological diarrhea, was a significant challenge. They highlight the successful experience of consulting pediatricians for defining these periods.
- Future Work: The paper emphasizes the need for establishing access to ETEC identification methods in hospitals with neonatal wards to facilitate timely diagnosis and laboratory testing. It also suggests that isolation of not only patients but also nurses caring for them might be a practical measure to prevent E. coli transmission. The authors also mention that high doses of new-generation antimicrobials might be a substitutive option for treating diarrhea in children with cholera-like symptoms when ETEC testing is not readily available.
Summary updated