An organoid and multi-organ developmental cell atlas reveals multilineage fate specification in the human intestine

Qianhui Yu, Umut Kilik, Emily M. Holloway, Yu-Hwai Tsai, Angeline Wu, Joshua H. Wu, Michael Czerwinski, Charlie J. Childs, Zhisong He, Ian A. Glass, Peter Higgins, Barbara Treutlein, Jason R. Spence, J. Gray CampbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents a comprehensive single-cell atlas of human intestinal organoids (HIOs) and developing human organs, revealing how HIOs recapitulate intestinal development and identifying key regulators of cell fate. The research highlights the critical role of the transcription factor CDX2 in both epithelial and mesenchymal development, offering new insights into human intestinal development and disease modeling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding human intestinal development and disease is challenging due to the inaccessibility of early developmental stages and the complexity of primary tissues. Human intestinal organoids (HIOs) offer a promising in vitro model, but their fidelity to in vivo development, particularly regarding cellular diversity and off-target cell types, needs thorough evaluation. This paper aims to address this by creating a detailed single-cell reference atlas of HIOs and comparing it to a multi-organ developmental atlas of human tissues. This comparison allows for a quantitative assessment of HIOs' ability to recapitulate intestinal development, identify specific cell fates, and explore the molecular mechanisms driving these processes, including the role of key transcription factors like CDX2.

Methods

The study employed single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) to generate high-resolution transcriptomic data from various samples. Key techniques included:

  • scRNA-seq: Used to profile cellular heterogeneity in HIOs (in vitro and transplanted), developing human organs (esophagus, stomach, lung, liver, intestine), and adult duodenum.
  • Multi-organ Developmental Atlas: Integration of scRNA-seq data from multiple developing human organs to create a reference for benchmarking HIOs.
  • Cluster Similarity Spectrum (CSS): A computational method used to integrate and compare datasets from different samples and organs, removing technical batch effects.
  • UMAP and SPRING Embeddings: Dimensionality reduction techniques used for visualizing and exploring the high-dimensional scRNA-seq data.
  • Immunohistochemistry and RNA in situ hybridization: Used for validating protein and gene expression patterns in tissue samples.
  • Receptor-Ligand Pairing Analysis (CellPhoneDB): To infer potential cell-cell communication networks.
  • Pseudo-spatial Reconstruction (novoSpaRc): To visualize the spatial organization of cell types within tissues.
  • Transcription Factor (TF) Network Analysis: To identify regulatory relationships between genes.
  • CRISPR-Cas9 Gene Editing: Used to generate CDX2 knockout HIOs to study its functional requirement.

Datasets

  • Human Intestinal Organoids (HIOs): Generated from pluripotent stem cells, including both standard HIOs and transplanted HIOs (tHIOs).
  • Developing Human Multi-Organ Atlas: Single-cell transcriptomes from developing human esophagus, stomach, lung, liver, and intestine (duodenum, jejunum, ileum, colon) across various post-conception weeks (PCW).
  • Adult Duodenum: Single-cell transcriptomes from adult human duodenum.
  • Mouse Gastrulation Atlas: Used for annotating early HIO developmental trajectories.
  • CDX2-Control and CDX2-Knockout HIOs: Generated from hPSCs to study the role of CDX2.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HIOs as Valid Models: HIOs, especially after transplantation, remarkably recapitulate the molecular and morphological features of developing human intestine, providing a robust model for studying intestinal development and disease.
  • CDX2's Dual Role: The transcription factor CDX2 is not only crucial for intestinal epithelial fate specification but also plays a significant role in the proper development of the intestinal mesenchyme.
  • Developmental vs. Adult States: HIO stem cells and developing intestinal cells exhibit distinct molecular signatures compared to adult counterparts, offering a unique window into early developmental processes.
  • Off-Target Cell Types: While HIOs are largely specified to intestinal fates, the presence of a small proportion of non-intestinal cell types (e.g., lung-like cells) highlights the importance of single-cell resolution for accurate interpretation of HIO experiments.
  • Mesenchymal Heterogeneity: The study reveals a diverse landscape of mesenchymal cell subtypes in the developing intestine, many of which are recapitulated in HIOs, enabling detailed study of mesenchymal development.

Key Results

  • A single-cell transcriptome reference atlas of HIOs and developing human organs was generated, comprising over 155,000 cells.
  • Approximately 70% of tHIO epithelial and mesenchymal cells mapped to the developing human intestine, with a strong preference for small intestine identity.
  • HIO stem cells and developing intestinal cells were found to be more similar to developing primary tissue counterparts than to adult cells.
  • CDX2 deletion in HIOs led to a loss of intestinal identity and a gain of foregut (esophagus/stomach) features in both epithelium and mesenchyme. CDX2-KO mesenchyme also showed an increased tendency to map to developing lung tissue.
  • The study successfully reconstructed a roadmap of intestinal stem cell (ISC) maturation from early progenitor stages to mature cells, identifying key genes and pathways involved.
  • Analysis of developing human duodenum mesenchyme revealed diverse subtypes, including novel populations, many of which were recapitulated in HIOs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Underrepresented Cell Types: HIOs showed underrepresentation or absence of certain cell types found in developing intestine, such as endothelial and immune cell populations. Future work could focus on co-culture systems to incorporate these cell types.
  • Perfusable Vasculature: The need for perfusable vasculature for enhanced maturation of HIOs was suggested, pointing towards future engineering efforts.
  • Mechanical Inductive Cues: The role of mechanical cues in HIO maturation was also mentioned as an area for future investigation.
  • Disease Modeling: The authors suggest that their data provides a foundation for using patient-derived organoids and HIO models to better understand and model gastrointestinal diseases.
  • Benchmarking Engineered Tissues: The multi-organ reference atlas serves as a valuable tool for comprehensively benchmarking engineered human tissue culture systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human intestinal organoids (HIOs) generated from pluripotent stem cells provide extraordinary opportunities to explore development and disease. Here, we generate a single-cell transcriptome reference atlas from HIOs and from multiple developing human organs to quantify the specificity of HIO cell fate acquisition, and to explore alternative fates. We identify epithelium-mesenchyme interactions, transcriptional regulators involved in cell fate specification, and stem cell maturation features in the primary tissue that are recapitulated in HIOs. We use an HIO time course to reconstruct the molecular dynamics of intestinal stem cell emergence, as well as the specification of multiple mesenchyme subtypes. We find that the intestinal master regulator CDX2 correlates with distinct phases of epithelial and mesenchymal development, and CDX2 deletion perturbs the differentiation of both intestinal epithelium and mesenchyme. Collectively our data provides a comprehensive and quantitative assessment of HIO development, and illuminates the molecular machinery underlying endodermal and mesodermal cell fate specification.
BibTeX
@misc{yu2020organoid,
  author = {Qianhui Yu and Umut Kilik and Emily M. Holloway and Yu-Hwai Tsai and Angeline Wu and Joshua H. Wu and Michael Czerwinski and Charlie J. Childs and Zhisong He and Ian A. Glass and Peter Higgins and Barbara Treutlein and Jason R. Spence and J. Gray Camp},
  title = {{An organoid and multi-organ developmental cell atlas reveals multilineage fate specification in the human intestine}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.07.24.219147},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure