An Optogenetic Demonstration of Motor Modularity in the Mammalian Spinal Cord

Vittorio Caggiano, Vincent C. K. Cheung, Emilio BizziScientific 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses optogenetics to selectively activate neurons in the mouse spinal cord, revealing that the complex, modular building blocks of movement (motor modules) originate from excitatory spinal interneurons, not just motor neurons. This work provides a crucial step in understanding the neural circuitry underlying movement and demonstrates the power of optogenetics for dissecting these complex systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The central nervous system generates complex movements by coordinating hundreds of muscles. A leading hypothesis suggests this is achieved by flexibly combining a smaller set of "motor modules," which are thought to be neural entities underpinned by spinal interneurons. However, the precise neural circuits that give rise to and implement these motor modules have remained largely unknown. Previous research using electrical microstimulation provided evidence for modularity and linear summation of motor outputs, but lacked the specificity to pinpoint the exact neuronal populations involved. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using optogenetics to selectively activate different types of neurons in the spinal cord and observe the resulting motor outputs, thereby dissecting the contribution of specific neuronal populations to motor module structure.

Methods

The core of this study relies on optogenetics, a technique that uses light to control genetically modified neurons. The researchers used two strains of transgenic mice:

  • Chat mice: These mice express channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) in cholinergic neurons, which are primarily motoneurons in the spinal cord. This allowed them to selectively activate motoneurons.
  • Thy1 mice: These mice express ChR2 in putatively excitatory neurons, including many spinal interneurons, particularly in the intermediate zone. This allowed them to activate a broader population that includes pre-motor interneurons.

By applying light pulses to the lumbosacral spinal cord of anesthetized mice, the researchers evoked isometric ankle forces. These forces were measured using a force transducer. The motor output was represented as spatial force fields, where the ankle was moved to different positions in a workspace, and the resulting force vector at each position was recorded.

To analyze the structure of these force fields, they employed:

  • Force onset analysis: Measuring the delay between light stimulation and force generation to infer the directness of neuronal activation.
  • Force field clustering: Using k-means algorithms to group similar force fields based on their vector patterns and spatial topography.
  • Linear combination analysis: Testing if force fields evoked by stimulating two separate spinal loci could be linearly summed to predict the force field evoked by co-stimulating both loci. This is a key test for modularity.
  • Equilibrium point (EP) analysis: Identifying points in the workspace where no net force is generated, which can reveal underlying motor control strategies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses data collected from experiments on mice.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interneurons are the architects of motor module complexity: The most striking finding is the difference in force field complexity between the two mouse strains. Thy1 mice (activating interneurons) produced more diverse and non-parallel force fields, suggesting that spinal interneurons are responsible for the intricate structure of motor modules. Chat mice (activating motoneurons) produced simpler, parallel force fields.
  • Optogenetics offers unprecedented specificity: This study highlights how optogenetics, by allowing precise control over specific neuronal populations, is a powerful tool for dissecting neural circuits underlying complex behaviors, a feat difficult with older stimulation techniques.
  • Motor modules are indeed linear: The study confirms that optogenetically evoked motor modules, like those previously studied with electrical stimulation, can be linearly combined. This supports the idea that the nervous system uses a flexible, additive approach to generate a wide range of movements from a limited set of building blocks.
  • Topographic organization of modules: The research demonstrates that different types of force fields (representing motor modules) are topographically organized within the spinal cord, suggesting a spatial mapping of these functional units.

Key Results

  • Force field structure: Thy1 force fields were characterized by mostly non-parallel, often convergent vectors, while Chat force fields were mostly parallel. This difference was statistically significant.
  • Force onset delay: Chat mice showed a faster force onset (~6 ms) compared to Thy1 mice (~9 ms), suggesting that Thy1 activation involves more synaptic relays (interneurons).
  • Linear combination: In both Chat and Thy1 mice, force fields evoked by co-stimulation of two spinal loci were well explained by the linear combination of fields evoked by single-locus stimulation (similarity of ~0.919 for Chat and ~0.86 for Thy1 in representative examples).
  • Equilibrium points: Thy1 mice showed a higher percentage of force fields with equilibrium points (EPs) or virtual EPs, and these EPs were more widely distributed in the workspace compared to Chat mice.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Winner-take-all vs. Linear Summation: While linear summation was generally supported, a subset of Thy1 cases (~20%) were better explained by a "winner-take-all" model, where one of the evoked fields dominated. In some of these cases, neither model perfectly explained the co-stimulation field, suggesting complex interactions that might require nonlinear models.
  • Specificity of Thy1 expression: While Thy1 expression is enriched in excitatory interneurons, it's not exclusively limited to them, and some motoneuron activation might occur. However, the distinct force field structures strongly suggest interneuron involvement.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that combining optogenetics with other techniques like spike recordings and advanced statistical algorithms will be crucial for a deeper understanding of neuromotor module representation and their underlying circuitry. Investigating the conditions under which linear combination breaks down is also highlighted as a future research avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motor modules are neural entities hypothesized to be building blocks of movement construction. How motor modules are underpinned by neural circuits has remained obscured. As a first step towards dissecting these circuits, we optogenetically evoked motor outputs from the lumbosacral spinal cord of two strains of transgenic mice - the Chat, with channelrhodopsin (ChR2) expressed in motoneurons, and the Thy1, expressed in putatively excitatory neurons. Motor output was represented as a spatial field of isometric ankle force. We found that Thy1 force fields were more complex and diverse in structure than Chat fields: the Thy1 fields comprised mostly non-parallel vectors while the Chat fields, mostly parallel vectors. In both, most fields elicited by co-stimulation of two laser beams were well explained by linear combination of the separately-evoked fields. We interpreted the Thy1 force fields as representations of spinal motor modules. Our comparison of the Chat and Thy1 fields allowed us to conclude, with reasonable certainty, that the structure of neuromotor modules originates from excitatory spinal interneurons. Our results not only demonstrate, for the first time using optogenetics, how the spinal modules follow linearity in their combinations, but also provide a reference against which future optogenetic studies of modularity can be compared.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{caggiano2016optogenetic,
  author = {Vittorio Caggiano and Vincent C. K. Cheung and Emilio Bizzi},
  title = {{An Optogenetic Demonstration of Motor Modularity in the Mammalian Spinal Cord}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/srep35185},
}
Figure