An Optimization Model for Ship Speed Based on Maneuvering Control

Xin Li, Yiqing Gu, Xiang Fan, Kang Zou, Xian-Rui HouJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel optimization model for ship speed that integrates maneuvering control to minimize energy consumption. By combining trajectory tracking with sliding mode control and employing a Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm, the model determines optimal speed strategies for various sea conditions, demonstrating significant potential for fuel savings in the shipping industry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The shipping industry faces increasing pressure to reduce its significant environmental impact and high operational costs, largely driven by fuel consumption. The International Maritime Organization (IMO) has identified ship speed optimization as a key area with substantial potential for energy savings. However, determining the optimal speed is a complex challenge, influenced by numerous factors including ship hydrodynamics, voyage time constraints, and dynamic marine environments (wind, waves, currents). Existing speed optimization models often lack the ability to be directly implemented in real-time maneuvering commands. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an integrated model that optimizes ship speed while considering the ship's maneuvering capabilities and environmental conditions.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a two-pronged approach:

  1. Maneuvering Control Model: The authors developed a ship motion model with three degrees of freedom (surge, sway, yaw) in the horizontal plane. This model incorporates the effects of currents, wind, and waves. To simulate the ship's response and control inputs, they applied:
  2. Trajectory Tracking Theory: This allows the ship to follow a desired path.
  3. Sliding Mode Control (SMC): A robust nonlinear control technique known for its ability to handle uncertainties and disturbances, making it suitable for complex marine environments. The SMC is designed to control the propeller thrust and rudder angle to achieve the desired trajectory.
  4. Speed Optimization: Once the maneuvering control model was established and validated, a Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm was employed. PSO is a metaheuristic optimization technique that searches for the best solution by mimicking the social behavior of bird flocking or fish schooling. In this context, PSO was used to:
  5. Explore various speed combinations across different legs of a ship's route.
  6. Minimize the total energy consumption for the entire voyage, subject to a given sailing time.
  7. The model calculates the energy consumption for each speed combination using propeller and rudder models, considering the outputs from the maneuvering control simulation.

The model was validated in two scenarios: still water and a level 5 sea state, to assess its accuracy and robustness.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention using pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it utilizes:

  • Ship Parameters: Main parameters of a large merchant ship (hull dimensions, propeller specifications, rudder characteristics) are provided in Table 1. These parameters are crucial for the ship motion and control models.
  • Route Parameters: A specific route with five legs and six waypoints is defined for simulation purposes.
  • Environmental Conditions: Simulated conditions for still water and a level 5 sea state (including wind speed, wave height, and current velocity) are used to test the model's performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integration is Key: The paper highlights that effective energy saving requires integrating speed optimization with the ship's actual maneuvering capabilities. Simply optimizing speed in isolation might not be practical or lead to the best overall outcome.
  • Environmental Adaptability: The findings strongly suggest that a "one-size-fits-all" speed strategy is suboptimal. Ships should adapt their speed based on sea conditions: faster in calm seas to meet time constraints and slower in rough seas to mitigate increased energy consumption due to environmental resistance.
  • Real-World Consistency: The optimized speed strategies align with the practical experience of seasoned captains, lending credibility to the model's findings.
  • Potential for Automation: The authors note that their model's ability to synchronize propeller speed and rudder commands could be particularly beneficial for future unmanned ships, further enhancing energy efficiency.

Key Results

  • Still Water: In a still water scenario, the model found that maintaining a constant speed of approximately 12.1 knots is the most energy-saving strategy. This result is consistent with common captain practices.
  • Rough Seas (Level 5): Under the influence of wind, waves, and currents, the optimal speed strategy becomes dynamic. The best speed combination identified was V = (14.8, 11.1, 11.1, 11.1, 13.8) knots across the five legs. This demonstrates the need to adjust speed based on environmental resistance.
  • Energy Savings: The optimized speed strategy in rough seas resulted in 1% lower energy consumption compared to maintaining a constant speed. While seemingly small, this translates to significant financial savings for large shipping companies.
  • Model Accuracy: The maneuvering control model demonstrated high accuracy, with a maximum distance error of less than 0.07 nautical miles and a speed error of less than 0.006 knots in the level 5 sea state scenario.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Indirect Fuel Consumption Measurement: The authors acknowledge that their work focused on optimizing energy consumption rather than directly measuring total fuel consumption. This is identified as a focus for future research.
  • Further Algorithm Exploration: They plan to introduce non-parametric static tools to study the optimization effects of different algorithms and analyze the parameter sensitivity of their model.
  • Real-World Validation: While the model's results align with captain experience, direct validation with actual ship operations would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

The increasing frequency of serious environmental issues and high fuel costs have necessitated better energy efficiency in the shipping industry. According to a report by the International Maritime Organization (IMO), ship speed optimization has huge potential. This paper introduces an optimization model of ship speed based on maneuvering control. The trajectory tracking theory and sliding mode control method are applied to simulate the control load of a ship. The propeller mode and rudder mode are used to calculate the corresponding rotating speed of the propeller, the rudder angle and the energy consumption. The accuracy and robustness of the maneuvering control model are validated in a still water scenario and a level 5 sea state scenario. On this basis, a particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm is applied to determine the best speed combination. The result shows that sailing at a constant speed is the most energy-saving strategy in still water. Moreover, due to the effects of wind, waves and currents, ships should sail faster when the sea is calm and slower when the sea is rough. These results are consistent with the actual experiences of a captain.
BibTeX
@article{li2022optimization,
  author = {Xin Li and Yiqing Gu and Xiang Fan and Kang Zou and Xian-Rui Hou},
  title = {{An Optimization Model for Ship Speed Based on Maneuvering Control}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11010049},
}
Figure