An OpenFlow Testbed for the Evaluation of Vertical Handover Decision Algorithms in Heterogeneous Wireless Networks

Ryan Izard, Adam Hodges, Jianwei Liu, Jim Martin, Kuang-Ching Wang, Ke XuTRIDENTCOM 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an OpenFlow-based testbed designed to evaluate vertical handover decision algorithms in heterogeneous wireless networks. By leveraging Software-Defined Networking (SDN) and existing infrastructure, it offers a practical and deployable solution for researchers to test mobility solutions without the complexities of traditional network setups.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mobile devices increasingly connect to a variety of wireless networks (e.g., Wi-Fi, WiMAX), forming heterogeneous wireless networks. When a device switches between these networks (a "vertical handover"), it can cause temporary interruptions in connectivity and disrupt ongoing network applications. Traditional IP mobility solutions like Mobile IPv4 often introduce a "triangle routing problem," adding latency and consuming extra resources. While newer solutions exist, testing vertical handover decision algorithms is challenging due to the cost and complexity of setting up real-world heterogeneous wireless networks. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a readily deployable testbed for evaluating these algorithms.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of an OpenFlow (OF)-based testbed that enables application-transparent vertical handovers for IPv4 heterogeneous wireless networks. The framework is designed to be an extension of the Global Environment for Network Innovations (GENI) testbed but is also applicable to any OF-enabled network.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Software-Defined Networking (SDN) with OpenFlow: OpenFlow is used to control the forwarding plane of network devices, allowing for dynamic management of network traffic and mobility.
  • Elimination of Triangle Routing: The testbed's architecture, utilizing a root OF switch and a tree hierarchy, is designed to avoid the Mobile IP triangle routing problem.
  • Client-Level Virtual Network Interface (VNI): A VNI is implemented on the mobile client to abstract network changes from applications, ensuring persistent socket connections during handovers.
  • Open vSwitch (OVS): OVS is used extensively for both network-level and client-level components to create virtual network bridges and manage traffic flows.
  • Floodlight Controller: A Floodlight OF controller acts as a central point for managing IP addresses, detecting migrations, and updating network flows. It includes a custom DHCP server module that associates IP leases with multiple MAC addresses.
  • MAC Rewriting: To address issues with the VNI and link-layer communication, the client-level OVS performs MAC rewriting for both egress and ingress packets, ensuring seamless communication. ARP packets are handled by a custom module within the client's controller.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the design and implementation of a testbed for evaluating handover algorithms, rather than training or evaluating on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SDN as a Mobility Enabler: The paper demonstrates how SDN, specifically OpenFlow, can be a powerful tool for managing complex mobility scenarios like vertical handovers, offering a more flexible and dynamic approach than traditional methods.
  • Practicality over Simulation: By building a testbed using real-world wireless resources (GENI WiMAX, Wi-Fi), the authors provide a valuable platform for evaluating algorithms in realistic conditions, moving beyond purely simulation-based research.
  • Client-Side Abstraction is Crucial: The VNI and MAC rewriting techniques on the client side are key to achieving application transparency, ensuring that applications remain unaware of the underlying network changes.
  • Unified Framework for Heterogeneity: The testbed's design aims to provide a standardized interface for various Radio Access Technologies (RATs), simplifying the development and testing of media-independent handover algorithms.

Key Results

The paper details the design and implementation of a functional testbed. While specific quantitative results from evaluating handover algorithms are not presented (as the paper focuses on the testbed itself), the key outcome is the successful creation of an IPv4-compatible, OpenFlow-enabled testbed for heterogeneous wireless networks. This testbed allows for seamless vertical handovers without the triangle routing problem, enabling researchers to evaluate their algorithms using real-world wireless resources.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • ARP Packet Handling: Due to OpenFlow limitations, ARP packets require out-of-band processing by the controller, which is noted as less efficient than in-band processing, though acceptable due to the infrequent nature of ARP.
  • Integration Complexity: The paper acknowledges that integrating the testbed with existing campus network infrastructure can be a challenge.

Future Work:

  • Deeper GENI Integration: Further integration with GENI wireless efforts, including assisting other campuses in deploying the framework and using OMF for mobile node management.
  • Android Client Component: Investigating the installation of Open vSwitch on GENI Android devices and deploying the client component as an Android application to enable testing on Android mobile devices. This will allow researchers to test handover decision algorithms in real-world heterogeneous wireless networks using common mobile devices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{izard2014openflow,
  author = {Ryan Izard and Adam Hodges and Jianwei Liu and Jim Martin and Kuang-Ching Wang and Ke Xu},
  title = {{An OpenFlow Testbed for the Evaluation of Vertical Handover Decision Algorithms in Heterogeneous Wireless Networks}},
  booktitle = {TRIDENTCOM},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-13326-3\_17},
}
Figure