Abstract
Substandard and falsified medicines present a serious threat to public health. Simple, low-cost screening tools are important in the identification of such products in low- and middle-income countries. In the present study, a smartphone-based imaging software was developed for the quantification of thin-layer chromatographic (TLC) analyses. A performance evaluation of this tool in the TLC analysis of 14 active pharmaceutical ingredients according to the procedures of the Global Pharma Health Fund (GPHF) Minilab was carried out, following international guidelines and assessing accuracy, repeatability, intermediate precision, specificity, linearity, range and robustness of the method. Relative standard deviations of 2.79% and 4.46% between individual measurements were observed in the assessments of repeatability and intermediate precision, respectively. Small deliberate variations of the conditions hardly affected the results. A locally producible wooden box was designed which ensures TLC photography under standardized conditions and shielding from ambient light. Photography and image analysis were carried out with a low-cost Android-based smartphone. The app allows to share TLC photos and quantification results using messaging apps, e-mail, cable or Bluetooth connections, or to upload them to a cloud. The app is available free of charge as General Public License (GPL) open-source software, and interested individuals or organizations are welcome to use and/or to further improve this software.
Introduction
Substandard and falsified (SF) medicines represent a silent pandemic, particularly in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The World Health Organization estimates that roughly 10.5% of medicines in these regions are SF, leading to treatment failure, increased antimicrobial resistance, and preventable deaths.
While tools like the GPHF Minilab are widely used for field screening, they rely on Thin-Layer Chromatography (TLC)—a technique where a sample is "spotted" on a plate and separated into components. Currently, the "gold standard" for field evaluation is simple visual inspection. While a human eye can easily tell if a drug is missing entirely, it struggles to distinguish between a pill that has 100% of its active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) and one that only has 80% (a common "substandard" threshold). This research introduces TLCyzer, a digital, objective way to quantify these results using ubiquitous smartphone hardware.
The TLCyzer System: Hardware and Software
To standardize the analytical process, the researchers developed a hardware-software duo designed for accessibility and reliability in resource-limited settings.
The Hardware
A simple, matte-black wooden box was designed to be built by local carpenters. It holds a standard battery-operated UV lamp and provides a fixed cradle for a smartphone, ensuring consistent lighting and distance for every photo. This setup eliminates the variability introduced by ambient light and handheld photography.
The Software
The TLCyzer app, built for Android, utilizes a high-performance architecture. While the user interface is written in Kotlin, the image processing "heavy lifting" is implemented in Rust to ensure speed on low-end mobile hardware. The app's pipeline includes:
- Perspective Correction: Automatically detecting the TLC plate and correcting for warping.
- Background Subtraction: To account for uneven UV illumination, the app fits a 2-dimensional quartic polynomial to the plate's background and subtracts it, isolating the API spots.
- Quantification: Users identify "reference spots" (known concentrations, e.g., 80% and 100%). The app integrates the intensity of these spots and uses linear regression to calculate the exact percentage of the unknown sample.
Performance Evaluation and Results
The system was validated using a rigorous performance evaluation following International Council for Harmonisation (ICH) guidelines across 14 essential APIs, including common antibiotics (Ciprofloxacin) and anti-malarials.
Key Results
- Precision: The app achieved a repeatability Relative Standard Deviation (RSD) of 2.79% and an intermediate precision (different days/users/phones) of 4.46%.
- Linearity: The system showed excellent linearity across the 50–120% range, with determination coefficients ($R^2$) between 0.989 and 1.00 for all 14 tested drugs.
- Field Validation: In testing substandard medicines from the DR Congo, TLCyzer’s results (e.g., 84.2% for a ciprofloxacin sample) were in remarkably close agreement with professional High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) laboratory results (83.4%).
- Cost-Effectiveness: The entire setup (box + low-end smartphone) costs roughly $300–$350 USD, a fraction of the cost of a benchtop densitometer ($20,000+).
Discussion and Future Outlook
The system's discriminative power is a major leap over visual inspection. While visual Minilab analysis often catches only ~24-43% of samples containing 80% API, TLCyzer correctly identified nearly all of them. Furthermore, the system proved robust against "deliberate variations," such as using different smartphones or UV lamps with low batteries.
By releasing the app under a General Public License (GPL) and providing blueprints for the wooden box, the researchers have created a "library-free" tool. Unlike NIR or Raman spectroscopy, which require massive proprietary databases of "fingerprints" for every brand of drug, TLCyzer only needs a pure reference standard to work.
Limitations
Despite its success, the authors note that the "wet chemistry" (preparing the TLC plate and spotting 2 µl aliquots) still requires precise manual technique and training. Additionally, the app is currently only available in English, and future work will focus on multi-language support and porting the software to iOS to increase global reach.
Summary updated