An Iterative Algorithm for Synthesizing Invariants

AAAI 2000

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel iterative algorithm for automatically synthesizing state invariants in automated planning. By framing invariant synthesis as a fixpoint computation, the algorithm can discover more complex invariants than previous methods and is not restricted to specific syntactic forms, making it a more general and powerful tool for planning and reasoning about change.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Automated planning systems often rely on "invariants" – facts that are true in the initial state and remain true after any valid action. These invariants are crucial for speeding up planning by pruning unreachable states or subgoals. However, existing methods for automatically generating these invariants often have limitations: they might be restricted to specific syntactic forms (like 2-literal clauses), require operators to be fully grounded, or fail to capture interdependencies between invariants. This paper addresses the challenge of developing a more general and powerful algorithm for synthesizing invariants that can handle schematic operator representations and discover more complex relationships.

Methods

The core of the paper is an iterative algorithm that synthesizes invariants by treating the process as a fixpoint computation. The algorithm starts with a set of candidate invariants derived from the initial state and iteratively refines this set. In each iteration, it considers operators and checks if they preserve the current set of candidate invariants. If an operator falsifies a candidate invariant, that invariant is "weakened" into a set of potentially weaker invariants. This process continues until no more changes occur (a fixpoint is reached).

Key novelties include:

  • Fixpoint Computation: Framing invariant synthesis as a fixpoint computation allows the algorithm to handle interdependencies between invariants, which is crucial for discovering complex ones.
  • Schematic Representation: The algorithm operates on schematic representations of operators (with variables) rather than requiring fully grounded instances, making it more scalable.
  • General Invariant Form: It's not restricted to specific syntactic forms of invariants, allowing for more expressive discoveries.
  • Auxiliary Functions: The algorithm relies on several key auxiliary functions:
  • extend(p, Σ): Infers additional facts that hold given a precondition p and a set of known invariants Σ.
  • update(p, e): Computes an incomplete description of the successor state after applying an operator with precondition p and postcondition e.
  • preserves(e, u, σ): Checks if a candidate invariant σ is preserved when transitioning to a state described by u (derived from p and e).
  • weaken(σ): Generates a set of weaker candidate invariants from a falsified invariant σ.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their algorithm on well-known planning benchmarks: the blocks world, logistics, and towers of Hanoi domains. They do not introduce new benchmarks but rather use these standard domains to demonstrate the effectiveness of their invariant synthesis approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Invariants as a Fixpoint: The most significant insight is recognizing that synthesizing invariants is inherently a fixpoint computation. This allows for capturing complex interdependencies where one invariant might be needed to prove another, a limitation of prior work.
  • Schematic Operators are Key: Working with schematic operators (instead of fully grounded ones) is essential for scalability, especially in domains with many objects.
  • Weakening is Crucial: The weaken function is vital for exploring the space of possible invariants. When a candidate invariant is falsified, weakening it allows the algorithm to continue searching for related, true invariants.
  • 2-Literal Invariants are Often Sufficient: While the algorithm is general, the experiments suggest that for many common domains, 2-literal invariants are highly effective and often sufficient for planning.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the algorithm's effectiveness on several planning domains. Table 1 shows runtimes for generating 2-literal and 3-literal invariants. For instance, in the bw-large.a/p domain, generating 2-literal invariants took 0.43 seconds (2 iterations), while 3-literal invariants took 44.19 seconds (3 iterations). The algorithm successfully inferred known invariants for these domains, including those that were difficult for previous methods to derive. For the blocks world, it found invariants stating the acyclicity of the on relation. For the logistics domain, it inferred invariants related to object locations and transport.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the algorithm is shown to run in polynomial time for a fixed invariant length, generating many candidate invariants and checking for redundancies can be computationally intensive, especially for longer invariants (n-literal for n > 2). The weaken function can generate a large number of candidates.
  • Incomplete Search: The algorithm is intentionally incomplete for efficiency reasons, meaning it might not find all possible invariants.
  • Future Work:
    • Improved Implementation: More sophisticated implementation techniques could significantly reduce overhead, particularly for n-literal invariants.
  • Symbolic Model-Checking: Integrating with symbolic model-checking techniques (like Binary Decision Diagrams) could allow for exact reachability analysis and extraction of ground invariants, though this might face scalability issues.
  • Existential Variables and Types: The authors note that extending the algorithm to handle existential variables and typed variables is straightforward by modifying the auxiliary functions. This would allow for inferring more expressive invariants.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{2000iterative,
  title = {{An Iterative Algorithm for Synthesizing Invariants}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2000},
}
Figure