TL;DR
This paper investigates early-age cracking in wide PK-section concrete box girders, a common but complex structural element. Through full-scale testing and advanced numerical simulations, the study identifies that hydration heat-induced thermal stresses are the primary drivers of cracking in diaphragms, exacerbated by external restraint. The research proposes practical mitigation strategies, including optimized casting temperatures and fiber reinforcement, to reduce cracking risk.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Concrete structures, especially large ones like box girders, are susceptible to cracking during their early stages of development. This cracking is primarily caused by two mechanisms: the heat generated by cement hydration (hydration heat) and the shrinkage of the concrete as it dries and cools. These processes induce internal stresses that, when they exceed the concrete's tensile strength, lead to cracks. These cracks can compromise the structural integrity and long-term durability of the bridge.
While early-age cracking in massive concrete structures is well-studied, box girders present unique challenges due to their complex geometries, varying stiffness across different sections (like diaphragms, webs, and slabs), and the intricate thermal gradients that develop. Existing research often simplifies these geometries or relies on models that don't fully capture the time-dependent evolution of concrete properties (like elastic modulus and creep) or the specific boundary conditions encountered during construction. This paper aims to address this gap by providing a detailed investigation into the causes and mitigation of early-age cracking in PK-section concrete box girders, a specific type of complex structure.
Methods
The study employs a two-pronged approach:
- Full-Scale Field Testing: A 3-meter long, 1:1 scale model of a PK-section concrete box girder segment was constructed and instrumented. Temperature and strain sensors were embedded to monitor the concrete's behavior over 14 days post-casting. This provided crucial real-world data on temperature evolution, strain development, and the actual occurrence of cracks.
- Numerical Simulation (Finite Element Analysis - FEA): A sophisticated FEA model was developed using Abaqus. This model incorporated:
- Equivalent Age Method: To account for the influence of temperature on the rate of concrete property development (strength, elastic modulus, shrinkage).
- Time-Dependent Material Properties: Regression equations derived from experimental material tests (compressive strength, tensile strength, elastic modulus, and shrinkage) were used to define how these properties evolve with equivalent age.
- Creep Model: A specific model was implemented to capture the stress relaxation effect of concrete creep at early ages.
- Heat of Hydration Model: An exponential function was used to describe the heat generation from cement hydration.
- Boundary Conditions: The model simulated both direct casting onto a foundation cap (with significant restraint) and cantilever construction scenarios (with restraint from previously cast segments).
The FEA model was calibrated using the experimental data from the field tests, allowing for accurate prediction of temperature and stress distributions. The Cracking Index (CI) was used as a quantitative measure of cracking risk.
Datasets
The study utilized data from:
- Full-scale field test: Temperature and strain measurements from the instrumented 1:1 scale PK-section concrete box girder segment over 14 days.
- Laboratory material tests: Data on compressive strength, tensile strength, elastic modulus, and shrinkage of the C55 concrete mix used in the girder. These tests were conducted on standard specimens at various ages.
- Ambient temperature data: Recorded simultaneously during the field test to provide realistic environmental inputs for the simulation.
No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study generated and utilized specific datasets from its experimental setup and material testing to validate its simulation model.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Thermal Stress Dominance: The most significant finding is that early-age cracking in these PK-section diaphragms is primarily driven by thermal stresses induced by the heat of hydration, not shrinkage. This is a crucial distinction from some conventional assumptions.
- External Restraint is Critical: The study strongly highlights the role of external restraint. Direct casting on a rigid foundation cap led to substantial cracking, which was significantly reduced when this restraint was lessened. Similarly, in cantilever construction, restraint from previously cast segments plays a key role in elevating stress levels.
- Complex Geometry Amplifies Gradients: The intricate geometry of the PK-section box girder, with its varying thicknesses and intersecting elements, leads to pronounced temperature gradients and internal thermal interactions, exacerbating stress development.
- Creep's Underestimated Role: The paper emphasizes that accurately accounting for early-age creep is vital, as it significantly relaxes thermal stresses. Many existing models overlook this, leading to overestimations of stress and cracking risk.
- Equivalent Age is Essential: The study reinforces the importance of the equivalent age concept for accurately modeling concrete property development, as temperature significantly accelerates the aging process.
Key Results
- Cracking Index:
- Direct casting on a foundation cap resulted in a cracking index of approximately 1.8 in diaphragms, indicating extensive cracking.
- Under cantilever construction, the cracking index at the diaphragm bottom reached about 1.6.
- Stress Ratios: The ratio of thermal stress to shrinkage stress was found to be up to 3:1 in critical regions during direct casting and 2:1 under cantilever construction.
- Temperature Impact: Reducing the casting temperature by 1°C lowered thermal stress by approximately 0.1 MPa.
- Fiber Reinforcement: Adding 0.9 kg/m³ of polypropylene fibers increased early-age tensile strength by about 15%.
- Experimental Validation: The FEA simulations showed excellent agreement with the measured temperature and strain data from the full-scale test, with temperature deviations within 2°C.
- Mitigation Effectiveness:
- Reducing casting temperature from 28°C to 20°C reduced peak temperature-induced stress by about 0.8 MPa.
- Reducing bottom restraint significantly decreased stress and eliminated vertical cracks in test beams.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Test Segments: While the study used a 1:1 scale model for testing, it was a single segment. The FEA analysis extended to two representative segments (No. 4 and No. 7) for construction conditions, but a broader range of segments could provide more comprehensive insights.
- Subtropical Climate Focus: The study was conducted in a subtropical climate. While the principles are general, specific climate variations might influence the magnitude of temperature effects.
- Shrinkage Model Nuances: While the Tazawa model was used and adapted, the paper notes a slight discrepancy (up to 10%) in experimental shrinkage values during a specific interval, leading to a conservative overestimation of shrinkage stress.
- Future Work Suggestions:
- Further investigation into the combined effects of various mitigation measures (mix design optimization, admixtures, and construction techniques).
- Exploring the long-term performance and crack propagation behavior of these girders.
- Expanding the analysis to different types of box girders and construction methods.
- Investigating the impact of different concrete mix designs and supplementary cementitious materials on early-age behavior.
Summary updated