An intrinsically disordered proteins community for ELIXIR

Norman E. Davey, M. Madan Babu, Martin Blackledge, Alan Bridge, Salvador Capella-Gutiérrez, Zsuzsanna Dosztányi, Rachel Drysdale, Richard J. Edwards, Arne Elofsson, Isabella C. Felli, Toby J. Gibson, Aleksandras Gutmanas, John M. Hancock, Jennifer Harrow, Desmond G. Higgins, Cy M. Jeffries, Philippe Le Mercier, Bálint Mészáros, Marco Necci, Cédric Notredame, Sandra Orchard, Christos Ouzounis, Rita Pancsa, Elena Papaleo, Roberta Pierattelli, Damiano Piovesan, Vasilis J. Promponas, Patrick Ruch, Gabriella Rustici, Pedro Romero, Sirarat Sarntivijai, Gary Saunders, Benjamin Schuler, Malvika Sharan, Denis C. Shields, Joel L. Sussman, Jonathan Tedds, Péter Tompa, Michael Turewicz, Jiřı́ Vondrášek, Wim Vranken, B.a. Wallace, Kanin Wichapong, Silvio C. E. TosattoF1000Research 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper outlines a roadmap for building a dedicated community and e-infrastructure within ELIXIR to advance research on intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). It addresses the need for standardized tools, data resources, and collaborative efforts to better understand these crucial but challenging-to-study proteins, which play vital roles in cellular regulation and disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and their regions (IDRs) are fundamental to cellular regulation, contributing to processes like signal transduction and protein-protein interactions. Unlike well-folded proteins, IDPs lack stable 3D structures, making them difficult to study using traditional methods. This structural ambiguity, coupled with their dynamic nature and context-dependent interactions, presents significant challenges for identification, analysis, and functional characterization. Consequently, the field of IDP research faces a fragmented landscape of tools and resources, hindering progress and data integration. This paper addresses the urgent need for a coordinated e-infrastructure and community effort to overcome these hurdles, leveraging the ELIXIR framework to foster collaboration and develop standardized resources.

Methods

The paper doesn't describe novel experimental or computational methods in the traditional sense. Instead, it proposes a strategic roadmap for developing and integrating existing and new e-infrastructure components. The core "methodology" involves:

  • Community Engagement: A workshop and subsequent consultations with IDP researchers to identify key challenges and priorities.
  • Roadmap Development: Defining priority areas for e-infrastructure development, including:
  • Standards and Exchange Formats: Establishing guidelines for data annotation, storage, and dissemination (e.g., MIADE standard).
  • Automated and Community-Driven Curation: Leveraging crowd-sourcing and text-mining for efficient data annotation.
  • Integration with ELIXIR Core Data Resources (CDRs): Incorporating IDP data and services into existing ELIXIR infrastructure.
  • Standardization, Benchmarking, and Indexing of Computational Tools: Developing reusable workflows, benchmarking platforms (like OpenEBench), and promoting open-source development (e.g., on GitHub).
  • Centralized Knowledge Base: Creating a consolidated portal (DisProtCentral) for IDP resources and tools.
  • Alignment with ELIXIR Platforms: Integrating the proposed IDP community activities with ELIXIR's Data, Tools, Interoperability, and Compute Platforms.

Datasets

The paper discusses the use of existing IDP-related databases and resources, rather than introducing new datasets for training or evaluation. Key resources mentioned include:

  • DisProt: A curated database of experimentally validated intrinsically disordered regions.
  • MobiDB: A database of predicted intrinsically disordered regions.
  • ELM (Eukaryotic Linear Motif): A database of binding regions residing in IDPs.
  • SASBDB and PCDDB: Repositories for Small-angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS) and Circular Dichroism (CD) data, respectively.
  • PED³: A database of conformational ensembles from NMR and SAXS data.

The paper also highlights the need for standardized data deposition and the development of benchmarking datasets, referencing initiatives like CAID (Critical Assessment of Intrinsic Disorder) as a model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • IDPs are Crucial but Underrepresented: Despite their significant role in cellular regulation and disease, IDPs are often underrepresented in major biological databases and lack standardized research infrastructure.
  • A Coordinated Community is Essential: The fragmented nature of IDP research necessitates a unified community effort, facilitated by ELIXIR, to develop shared resources and best practices.
  • Standardization is Key to Progress: Establishing common standards for data annotation, storage, and computational tools is paramount for improving reproducibility, interoperability, and the overall advancement of IDP research.
  • Leveraging Existing Infrastructure: The proposed IDP community can significantly benefit from and contribute to ELIXIR's existing platforms (Data, Tools, Interoperability, Compute), avoiding the need to reinvent the wheel.
  • Open Science and Collaboration are Vital: Promoting open-source software development, community-driven curation, and collaboration with international initiatives (like Instruct-ERIC and the Dark Proteome Initiative) will accelerate progress.

Key Results

This paper is a white paper outlining a roadmap and proposal, not a research study with quantitative results. Its "results" are the identified priorities and proposed actions for building the ELIXIR IDP Community. The key outcomes are:

  • Identification of Five Priority Areas: Standards and exchange formats, automated/community-driven curation, integration with ELIXIR CDRs, standardization/benchmarking of computational tools, and development of a centralized knowledge base.
  • Blueprint for an IDP Community: A preliminary plan for how the IDP research community can organize and collaborate within the ELIXIR framework.
  • Call to Action: An appeal to identify and involve new stakeholders to contribute to the development of the IDP e-infrastructure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reproducibility Concerns: Reviewers highlighted a lack of focus on reproducibility issues, suggesting the need for dedicated efforts to ensure experimental and computational results are reproducible.
  • Clarity of Audience and Strategy: The paper could be clearer about its target audience (IDP vs. ELIXIR community) and the specific strategy for integrating existing resources and developing new ones.
  • Maintenance of Resources: The long-term maintenance and funding of proposed resources and tools remain a concern, with suggestions to leverage platforms like GitHub for open-source development.
  • Integration of Non-European Resources: The plan for consolidating European resources needs to address how non-European contributions will be integrated.
  • Dynamic Nature of Standards: The rapid evolution of IDP research may render some proposed data formats outdated quickly, suggesting a focus on modular software development and adaptable workflows.

Future work will involve implementing the proposed roadmap, fostering collaborations, developing standards, and building the centralized knowledge base to support the growing field of IDP research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) are now recognised as major determinants in cellular regulation. This white paper presents a roadmap for future e-infrastructure developments in the field of IDP research within the ELIXIR framework. The goal of these developments is to drive the creation of high-quality tools and resources to support the identification, analysis and functional characterisation of IDPs. The roadmap is the result of a workshop titled "An intrinsically disordered protein user community proposal for ELIXIR" held at the University of Padua. The workshop, and further consultation with the members of the wider IDP community, identified the key priority areas for the roadmap including the development of standards for data annotation, storage and dissemination; integration of IDP data into the ELIXIR Core Data Resources; and the creation of benchmarking criteria for IDP-related software. Here, we discuss these areas of priority, how they can be implemented in cooperation with the ELIXIR platforms, and their connections to existing ELIXIR Communities and international consortia. The article provides a preliminary blueprint for an IDP Community in ELIXIR and is an appeal to identify and involve new stakeholders.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{davey2019intrinsically,
  author = {Norman E. Davey and M. Madan Babu and Martin Blackledge and Alan Bridge and Salvador Capella-Gutiérrez and Zsuzsanna Dosztányi and Rachel Drysdale and Richard J. Edwards and Arne Elofsson and Isabella C. Felli and Toby J. Gibson and Aleksandras Gutmanas and John M. Hancock and Jennifer Harrow and Desmond G. Higgins and Cy M. Jeffries and Philippe Le Mercier and Bálint Mészáros and Marco Necci and Cédric Notredame and Sandra Orchard and Christos Ouzounis and Rita Pancsa and Elena Papaleo and Roberta Pierattelli and Damiano Piovesan and Vasilis J. Promponas and Patrick Ruch and Gabriella Rustici and Pedro Romero and Sirarat Sarntivijai and Gary Saunders and Benjamin Schuler and Malvika Sharan and Denis C. Shields and Joel L. Sussman and Jonathan Tedds and Péter Tompa and Michael Turewicz and Jiřı́ Vondrášek and Wim Vranken and B.A. Wallace and Kanin Wichapong and Silvio C. E. Tosatto},
  title = {{An intrinsically disordered proteins community for ELIXIR}},
  booktitle = {F1000Research},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.12688/f1000research.20136.1},
}
Figure