An Interview with Professor Adel Sedra [Interview]

Fan ChenIEEE Circuits and Systems Magazine 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This interview profiles Professor Adel Sedra, a titan of microelectronics and the primary author of the world-renowned textbook Microelectronic Circuits. It traces his journey from 1950s Egypt to the upper echelons of Canadian academia, highlighting his invention of the "current conveyor" and his philosophy that teaching and research are inseparable components of a single "learning" process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While not a traditional research paper, this interview addresses the evolution of electrical engineering education and the challenge of balancing high-impact research with academic leadership.

In the late 1960s, a significant gap existed in engineering pedagogy: textbooks still treated transistors as mere replacements for vacuum tubes, focusing heavily on physical operation rather than circuit design. Sedra sought to bridge this gap by developing a methodology for designing multi-transistor circuits based on terminal characteristics—an approach that eventually revolutionized how the subject is taught globally.

Methods

The "methods" discussed are pedagogical and administrative rather than experimental:

  • Pedagogical Shift: Sedra moved away from the "physics-first" approach to transistors. Instead, he focused on current-voltage terminal characteristics to provide an intuitive framework for designing complex, multi-transistor systems.
  • The Current Conveyor: During his PhD, Sedra developed the "current conveyor," a versatile three-terminal building block intended to compete with the operational amplifier (op-amp) by using current rather than voltage as the controlling variable.
  • Academic Planning: As a leader (Provost and Dean), Sedra implemented a framework for academic planning that combined budget planning with private fundraising to insulate universities from public funding cuts.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. (As an interview, it focuses on career milestones and qualitative insights rather than quantitative datasets).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Learning Institution": Borrowing from Fred Terman (the "Father of Silicon Valley"), Sedra argues that a university is neither strictly a teaching nor a research institution, but a learning institution where both activities reinforce each other.
  • The Op-Amp Race: Sedra’s "current conveyor" was a technically superior competitor to early op-amps in many ways, but it lost the "budding race" for market dominance when the Fairchild μA 709 integrated circuit op-amp debuted in 1968.
  • Textbook Longevity: The first edition of Microelectronic Circuits took twelve years to write. Sedra attributes its success to filling a vacuum in the 1980s for a design-oriented (rather than physics-oriented) electronics text.
  • Leadership with Purpose: Sedra emphasizes that academic leadership should not be pursued for prestige, but for a "higher purpose"—requiring a formal academic plan developed in consultation with all stakeholders.

Key Results

  • Global Impact: Microelectronic Circuits is currently in its eighth edition, has been translated into ten languages, and has sold millions of copies. Sedra notes that almost any electrical engineer trained in the last 40 years likely learned from his work.
  • Institutional Transformation: During his tenure as Provost at the University of Toronto, Sedra’s planning helped the university maintain its status as a top-tier global institution despite severe public funding reductions in Ontario during the 1990s.
  • Mentorship: Over his career, Sedra supervised 65 graduate students and helped build one of the world's premier analog circuits groups at the University of Toronto.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The Leadership Trade-off: Sedra acknowledges that moving into senior administration (Provost/Dean) made it impossible to maintain a substantial research program or supervise graduate students at his previous scale.
  • The Future of the "Bible": Sedra is currently working on the ninth edition of Microelectronic Circuits. To ensure the book’s longevity, he has brought on new co-authors (Tony Chan Carusone and Vincent Gaudet) to represent the "future of the book."
  • Career Advice: He cautions early-career faculty that while planning is essential, most "important turning points" in a career are unplanned, and success often comes from simply working on what one loves.

Summary updated

Abstract

<fig orientation="portrait" position="float"> <graphic orientation="portrait" position="float" xlink:href="adel-3239651.tif" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"/> </fig>Adel Sedra received the B.Sc. degree from Cairo University, Egypt, in 1964, and the M.A.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees from the University of Toronto, Canada, in 1968 and 1969, respectively, all in electrical engineering.
BibTeX
@article{chen2023interview,
  author = {Fan Chen},
  title = {{An Interview with Professor Adel Sedra [Interview]}},
  journal = {IEEE Circuits and Systems Magazine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/mcas.2023.3239651},
}
Figure