An Interval-Valued Time Series Forecasting Scheme With Probability Distribution Features for Electric Power Generation Prediction

Ting-Jen Chang, Samantha Lee, Jonathan Lee, Chi-Jie LuIEEE Access 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel interval-valued time series (ITS) forecasting scheme that looks "inside" data intervals to extract probability distribution features like skewness and kurtosis. By combining these features with machine learning models, the authors significantly improved the accuracy of electric power generation predictions compared to traditional methods that only consider basic min/max bounds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we transition to green energy, power grids face a massive stability challenge: renewables like solar and wind are notoriously volatile. To manage this, energy operators don't just need a single "point" estimate of how much power will be generated; they need a predicted range (an interval) to account for uncertainty.

Traditional Interval-Valued Time Series (ITS) forecasting usually treats these intervals as simple boxes defined by a minimum and maximum (or a center and a radius). However, this ignores a wealth of information: how is the data distributed within that day? Is it skewed toward the morning? Is it tightly clustered or wildly spread out? The authors argue that by ignoring the "shape" of the data within the interval, we are leaving valuable predictive power on the table.

Methods

The researchers introduced a framework called the Integrated Feature Set (IFS). Instead of just feeding a model the previous day's high and low values, they calculated several "Probability Distribution Features" (PF) from high-frequency intraday data:

  • Central Tendency: Mean and Median.
  • Dispersion: Standard deviation and Interquartile Range (IQR).
  • Shape: Skewness (asymmetry) and Kurtosis (peakedness).

They then combined these distribution features with Basic Features (BF)—either Upper/Lower bounds or Center/Radius—to create the IFS. To process these features, they tested three different machine learning algorithms:

  1. Support Vector Regression (SVR): A standard for non-linear mapping.
  2. Extreme Learning Machine (ELM): A fast-training feedforward neural network.
  3. Multivariate Adaptive Regression Splines (MARS): A non-parametric technique that excels at capturing complex, piecewise relationships.

Datasets

The study utilized real-world data from the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO).

  • Scope: Metered power generation data from February 2017 to October 2019.
  • Granularity: The raw data was collected every 30 minutes (48 points per day).
  • Processing: These 48 points were used to calculate the daily intervals and the associated probability distribution features, resulting in 943 daily data points.
  • Evaluation: The models were trained on the first 80% of the data and tested on the remaining 20%.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Hidden" Information: The core "aha" moment is that two days can have the exact same high and low power generation values but look completely different internally. One might have a steady output (low kurtosis), while another might have a massive, short-lived spike (high kurtosis). Capturing this "intra-interval" behavior allows the model to better understand the underlying dynamics of the power grid.
  • Symmetry is a Myth: Traditional models often assume data is symmetrically distributed around a center point. The authors show that power generation is frequently asymmetrical (skewed). By including skewness as a feature, the model learns to predict when the actual generation is likely to hug the upper or lower bound of the interval.
  • MARS is the MVP: Among the algorithms tested, MARS performed the best. Its ability to break complex data into "pieces" (splines) makes it particularly effective at handling the non-linear, fluctuating nature of energy data.

Key Results

The authors compared their IFS-based models against eight benchmark models (including standard ARIMA and Random Walk models).

  • Best Performer: The CR-PF-MARS model (Center-Radius scheme using Probability Features and MARS) was the clear winner.
  • Accuracy Gains: Using the probability features (IFS) improved the MARS model's performance by approximately 13% in terms of Mean Squared Error of Interval (MSEI) and 7.5% in Mean Relative Interval Error (MRIE) compared to using basic features alone.
  • Robustness: The proposed scheme remained the top performer even when the ratio of training to testing data was varied (from 70% to 85%), proving it isn't just "overfitting" to a specific slice of time.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are promising, the paper notes a few areas for further exploration:

  • Univariate Focus: The current model relies primarily on historical generation data. Future iterations could integrate exogenous variables like weather forecasts (cloud cover, wind speed) directly into the feature set.
  • Data Requirements: This method requires high-frequency intraday data to calculate the distribution features. It may not be applicable in regions where only daily aggregate data is available.
  • Generalization: The authors suggest testing this "distribution-aware" forecasting on other volatile interval data, such as stock market prices or exchange rates, to see if the benefits translate to other fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Developing an effective interval-valued time series (ITS) forecasting scheme for electric power generation is an important issue for energy operators and governments when making energy strategic decisions. The existing studies for ITS forecasting only consider basic descriptive information such as center, radius, upper and lower bounds, and overlooks the distribution information within the data interval. In this study, an interval-valued time series forecasting scheme based on probability distribution information features of interval-valued data with machine learning algorithms is proposed to enhance electric power generation forecasting. In the proposed scheme, the central tendency features and dispersion features from the interval-valued data are designed as integrated features sets (IFS) and used as predictor variables. Three methods including supper vector regression and extreme learning machine and multivariate adaptive regression splines based on the IFS are utilized to develop ITS forecasting models. The daily time series of the metered generation from the Australian Energy Market Operator is used to illustrate the proposed scheme. Empirical results show that the proposed ITS forecasting schemes with IFS outperform the eight benchmark models and thus validate that the proposed scheme is an effective alternative for interval-valued electric power generation forecasting.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chang2022interval,
  author = {Ting-Jen Chang and Samantha Lee and Jonathan Lee and Chi-Jie Lu},
  title = {{An Interval-Valued Time Series Forecasting Scheme With Probability Distribution Features for Electric Power Generation Prediction}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2022.3142083},
}
Figure