An Interval Probability-based Inexact Two-stage Stochastic Model for Regional Electricity Supply and GHG Mitigation Management under Uncertainty

Yulei Xie, Guohe Huang, Wei Li, Ye TangEnergy 2013 · DOI

Abstract

In this study, an interval probability-based inexact two-stage stochastic (IP-ITSP) model is developed for environmental pollutants control and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction management in regional energy systems under uncertainties. The model integrates interval probability, interval-parameter programming (IPP), and two-stage stochastic programming (TSP) into an integer programming framework. This allows for the management of uncertainties expressed as both interval values and interval probability distributions. Applied to a regional electricity system case study, the model demonstrates its capability to address complex multi-uncertainty problems and help decision-makers identify optimal GHG mitigation policies under varying economic and environmental constraints.

Introduction

Planning regional energy systems involves a delicate balance between meeting growing electricity demand and achieving stringent greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction targets. However, real-world planning is fraught with uncertainty. Parameters such as future electricity demand, fuel prices, and the probabilities of specific demand scenarios are rarely known with precision.

Traditional stochastic programming often requires exact probability distributions, which may not be available. Planners frequently deal with "uncertainty about uncertainty," where probabilities themselves are expressed as ranges (e.g., a 15% to 35% chance of high demand). To address this, the IP-ITSP model was developed to handle multiple layers of uncertainty—specifically interval values and interval probability distributions—simultaneously.

Methodology

The IP-ITSP model integrates three core mathematical techniques:

  1. Interval-Parameter Programming (IPP): Manages parameters expressed as ranges (e.g., costs or capacities).
  2. Two-Stage Stochastic Programming (TSP): Employs a "plan-then-adjust" strategy. First-stage decisions (e.g., generation targets) are made before uncertainties are resolved, while second-stage "recourse" actions (e.g., purchasing surplus power) address deviations once actual demand is known.
  3. Interval Probability: The model's primary innovation, allowing scenario probabilities to be intervals. An averaging operation transforms these into deterministic values for mathematical resolution.

The model operates within an integer programming framework, enabling it to handle discrete decisions such as facility expansion.

Results and Discussion

The model was tested on a hypothetical regional power system featuring six technologies: coal (k=1), natural gas (k=2), hydro (k=3), wind (k=4), solar (k=5), and nuclear (k=6). Four scenarios were examined, representing GHG reduction levels of 0%, 20%, 40%, and 60%.

Power Generation Shifts

As GHG mitigation targets become more aggressive, the model dictates a significant shift in the energy mix. Coal-fired power targets decrease substantially, while hydropower and wind power targets increase to compensate.

Power generation patterns across four GHG-reduction scenarios (0%, 20%, 40%, and 60%) for different technologies (k) and demand levels (h).

Under the 0% reduction scenario, coal-fired power is the dominant source. However, at the 60% reduction level, coal targets drop from 42.11 to 16.85 units, while hydropower targets rise from 13.45 to 32.16 units. The model also prioritizes wind power as a primary recourse action to meet unexpected demand spikes in carbon-constrained scenarios.

Economic Implications

The transition to a cleaner energy system entails higher costs. The total system cost increases as mitigation levels rise, reflecting the replacement of cheaper coal with more expensive renewable sources.

Total system costs and per-unit GHG mitigation costs across the four examined scenarios.

The lower bound of the system cost rises from $491.84 million at 0% reduction to $523.26 million at 60% reduction. Furthermore, the marginal cost of GHG mitigation increases as the most cost-effective reduction opportunities are exhausted, reaching a range of $[1.15, 1.31] \times 10^6$ per kiloton at the highest mitigation level.

Conclusion

The IP-ITSP model provides a robust framework for regional energy planning under deep uncertainty. By accounting for interval probabilities, it offers more reliable policy recommendations than models relying on precise but potentially inaccurate assumptions. While the current study uses a hypothetical case, the model's ability to quantify the trade-offs between economic costs and environmental targets makes it a valuable tool for real-world decision-making in the transition to low-carbon energy systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, an interval probability-based inexact two-stage stochastic (IP-ITSP) model is developed for environmental pollutants control and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction management in regional energy system under uncertainties. In the IP-ITSP model, methods of interval probability, interval-parameter programming (IPP) and two-stage stochastic programming (TSP) are introduced into an integer programming framework; the developed model can tackle uncertainties described in terms of interval values and interval probability distributions. The developed model is applied to a case of planning GHG -emission mitigation in a regional electricity system, demonstrating that IP-ITSP is applicable to reflecting complexities of multi-uncertainty, and capable of addressing the problem of GHG-emission reduction. 4 scenarios corresponding to different GHG -emission mitigation levels are examined; the results indicates that the model could help decision makers identify desired GHG mitigation policies under various economic costs and environmental requirements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2013interval,
  author = {Yulei Xie and Guohe Huang and Wei Li and Ye Tang},
  title = {{An Interval Probability-based Inexact Two-stage Stochastic Model for Regional Electricity Supply and GHG Mitigation Management under Uncertainty}},
  booktitle = {Energy},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.4236/epe.2013.54b157},
}
Figure