An interdisciplinary mixed-methods approach to developing antimicrobial stewardship interventions: Protocol for the Preserving Antibiotics through Safe Stewardship (PASS) Research Programme

Laura Shallcross, Fabiana Lorencatto, Christopher Fuller, Carolyn Tarrant, Jonathan West, Rosanna Traina, Catherine M. Smith, Gillian Forbes, Elise Crayton, Patrick Rockenschaub, Peter Dutey‐Magni, Emma Richardson, Ellen Fragaszy, Susan Michie, Andrew HaywardWellcome 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper outlines the "Preserving Antibiotics through Safe Stewardship" (PASS) research program, a comprehensive, interdisciplinary initiative to develop effective antimicrobial stewardship (AMS) interventions. By integrating data science, behavioral science, and user-centered design, PASS aims to understand and address the complex factors influencing antibiotic prescribing and use across various healthcare settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a growing global health crisis, driven in part by the overuse and misuse of antibiotics. While antimicrobial stewardship (AMS) programs are crucial for promoting judicious antibiotic use, their design often overlooks the critical role of behavioral and social influences. This gap leads to interventions that may be ineffective or poorly adopted. The PASS program addresses this by proposing a structured, multi-faceted approach to co-designing AMS interventions that are grounded in empirical data, behavioral theory, and the real-world experiences of healthcare professionals and the public.

Methods

The PASS program employs a mixed-methods approach structured across three work packages (WPs):

  • WP1: Identifying Patterns of Antibiotic Prescribing: This WP utilizes data science techniques, including the analysis of electronic health records (EHRs) from primary, secondary, and care-home settings, to identify prescribing patterns. It also incorporates an online survey ("Bug Watch") to understand public antibiotic-seeking behaviors.
  • WP2: Barriers and Enablers to Stewardship in Context: This WP delves into the behavioral and social aspects of antibiotic use. It involves:
  • Semi-structured interviews and ethnographic observations: To understand the contextual factors, barriers, and enablers influencing prescribing and patient behavior. These are guided by the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF).
  • Systematic reviews: To identify effective AMS interventions and the behavior change techniques (BCTs) associated with their success.
  • Design-led workshops: To explore initial intervention ideas and identify practical constraints.
  • WP3: Co-production of Interventions and Dissemination: This WP focuses on integrating findings from WP1 and WP2. It involves:
  • Data triangulation workshops: To synthesize findings across different data sources and work packages.
  • Stakeholder workshops: To co-design and refine interventions using the APEASE criteria (Affordability, Practicability, Effectiveness, Acceptability, Side-effects, Equity).
  • Development of web resources: To disseminate findings and provide practical guidance.

The overall research design is guided by the Double Diamond model, emphasizing iterative discovery, definition, development, and delivery.

Datasets

The study utilizes several datasets:

  • Electronic Health Records (EHRs): From primary care (Clinical Practice Research Datalink - CPRD), secondary care (a large teaching hospital), and care homes (from a national chain).
  • Pharmacy Records: From a national chain providing dispensing services to care homes.
  • "Bug Watch" Survey: A prospective online survey of the general population.
  • Existing systematic reviews: On AMS interventions.

No new benchmarks are introduced; rather, existing data sources are leveraged to inform the research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The critical role of behavioral and social science: The paper strongly emphasizes that effective AMS interventions must move beyond purely clinical or guideline-based approaches to deeply understand and address the behavioral and social determinants of antibiotic use.
  • Interdisciplinary synergy: The PASS program highlights the power of integrating diverse expertise (data science, behavioral science, design, ethnography) to tackle complex health challenges like AMR.
  • Context-specific interventions: Recognizing that antibiotic use varies significantly across different healthcare settings (primary care, secondary care, care homes, community pharmacy), the program aims to develop tailored interventions rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
  • User-centered co-design: The inclusion of stakeholder panels and user-centered design principles in WP3 is crucial for ensuring that interventions are not only theoretically sound but also practical, acceptable, and feasible in real-world settings.

Key Results

As this is a protocol paper, it outlines the planned methodology rather than presenting final results. However, the expected outputs include:

  • Detailed characterization of antibiotic prescribing patterns and infection outcomes across various healthcare settings.
  • Identification of key barriers and enablers to appropriate antibiotic prescribing and patient antibiotic-seeking behaviors.
  • Development of evidence-based, theoretically informed, and co-designed AMS intervention bundles.
  • Creation of web-based resources to support stakeholders in understanding and implementing AMS strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity: Reviewers noted the inherent complexity of the interdisciplinary, multi-method approach, suggesting a flow diagram could improve clarity.
  • Integration of findings: One reviewer highlighted a need for more clarity on how findings from diverse methods within WP3 will be synthesized and integrated.
  • Pragmatic approach: The paper suggests a pragmatic approach to behavioral specificity may be employed, which could benefit from further explanation.
  • Future Work: The program aims to pilot and trial the developed interventions, working towards their implementation in routine clinical practice. The website developed will serve as a resource for researchers and practitioners, supporting the selection and design of future AMS interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Behaviour change is key to combating antimicrobial resistance. Antimicrobial stewardship (AMS) programmes promote and monitor judicious antibiotic use, but there is little consideration of behavioural and social influences when designing interventions. We outline a programme of research which aims to co-design AMS interventions across healthcare settings, by integrating data-science, evidence- synthesis, behavioural-science and user-centred design. The project includes three work-packages (WP): <b>WP1 (</b>Identifying patterns of prescribing): analysis of electronic health-records to identify prescribing patterns in care-homes, primary-care, and secondary-care. An online survey will investigate consulting/antibiotic-seeking behaviours in members of the public. <b>WP2</b> (Barriers and enablers to prescribing in practice): Semi-structured interviews and observations of practice to identify barriers/enablers to prescribing, influences on antibiotic-seeking behaviour and the social/contextual factors underpinning prescribing. Systematic reviews of AMS interventions to identify the components of existing interventions associated with effectiveness. Design workshops to identify constraints influencing the form of the intervention. Interviews conducted with healthcare-professionals in community pharmacies, care-homes, primary-, and secondary-care and with members of the public. Topic guides and analysis based on the Theoretical Domains Framework. Observations conducted in care-homes, primary and secondary-care with analysis drawing on grounded theory. Systematic reviews of interventions in each setting will be conducted, and interventions described using the Behaviour Change Technique taxonomy v1. Design workshops in care-homes, primary-, and secondary care. <b>WP3</b> (Co-production of interventions and dissemination). Findings will be integrated to identify opportunities for interventions, and assess whether existing interventions target influences on antibiotic use. Stakeholder panels will be assembled to co-design and refine interventions in each setting, applying the Affordability, Practicability, Effectiveness, Acceptability, Side-effects and Equity (APEASE) criteria to prioritise candidate interventions. Outputs will inform development of new AMS interventions and/or optimisation of existing interventions. We will also develop web-resources for stakeholders providing analyses of antibiotic prescribing patterns, prescribing behaviours, and evidence reviews.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shallcross2020interdisciplinary,
  author = {Laura Shallcross and Fabiana Lorencatto and Christopher Fuller and Carolyn Tarrant and Jonathan West and Rosanna Traina and Catherine M. Smith and Gillian Forbes and Elise Crayton and Patrick Rockenschaub and Peter Dutey‐Magni and Emma Richardson and Ellen Fragaszy and Susan Michie and Andrew Hayward},
  title = {{An interdisciplinary mixed-methods approach to developing antimicrobial stewardship interventions: Protocol for the Preserving Antibiotics through Safe Stewardship (PASS) Research Programme}},
  booktitle = {Wellcome},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.12688/wellcomeopenres.15554.1},
}
Figure