An integrative model of motor unit activity during sustained submaximal contractions

Jakob Lund Dideriksen, Dario Farina, Martin Bækgaard, Roger M. EnokaJournal of Applied Physiology 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an expanded computational model of motor unit activity that simulates the complex adjustments occurring during sustained, fatiguing muscle contractions. By incorporating a metabolite model and a proportional-integral-derivative (PID) control algorithm, the model successfully replicates experimental data on time to task failure and motor unit firing patterns, offering a powerful tool for understanding muscle fatigue.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sustained muscle contractions, like those involved in everyday activities or athletic performance, are inherently limited by fatigue. Understanding the physiological mechanisms underlying this fatigue is crucial for fields ranging from sports science and rehabilitation to ergonomics and neuroscience. While previous models (like Fuglevand et al.'s) have been excellent for simulating brief, non-fatiguing contractions, they lacked the ability to capture the dynamic changes in motor unit behavior that occur as muscles fatigue. Specifically, the interplay between metabolite accumulation, changes in motor unit firing rates, and the central nervous system's control strategies during prolonged effort remained poorly understood and difficult to model. This paper aims to bridge that gap by creating an "integrative" model that accounts for these fatigue-induced adjustments.

Methods

The core of this work is an extension of the Fuglevand et al. (2000) motor unit model. The key innovations are:

  • Metabolite Model: A compartment model was introduced to simulate the accumulation and transport of metabolites within and between intracellular and extracellular spaces of motor units. This model is driven by motor unit activity (action potential firing) and influences motor unit behavior through simulated afferent feedback.
  • PID Control Algorithm: To maintain a prescribed target force during simulated fatiguing contractions, a Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controller was implemented. This algorithm continuously estimates the necessary "descending drive" (excitation) to the motoneuron pool, accounting for the time-varying parameters of the fatigued muscle.
  • Time-Varying Parameters: Crucially, parameters like motor unit twitch force, recruitment threshold, discharge rate, and discharge variability were made time-dependent, reflecting the physiological changes that occur during fatigue. These changes were largely driven by the metabolite model.

The model was designed to run at 1,000 Hz and was validated against existing literature data and experimental recordings from the first dorsal interosseus (FDI) muscle.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it relies on and compares its simulation results against:

  • Published Literature: Data from numerous previous studies on motor unit behavior, muscle fatigue, and force production during sustained contractions (e.g., Fuglevand et al., Burke et al., Carpentier et al., Garland et al.).
  • Experimentally Recorded Data: The authors conducted their own experiments on eight healthy male subjects performing sustained isometric contractions of the FDI muscle at 30%, 50%, and 70% MVC force until task failure. This data was used for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Metabolites as a Central Driver: The model highlights how the accumulation of metabolites, even when simplified into a single "compound parameter," can act as a primary driver for many fatigue-induced changes in motor unit activity and muscle force.
  • PID Control's Role in Force Steadiness: The PID controller, while a simplification of complex central nervous system (CNS) control, demonstrates how adjustments in its parameters (particularly the derivative gain) can mimic the observed increase in force variability during fatigue. This suggests that impaired CNS control, potentially linked to metabolite accumulation, plays a significant role in reduced force steadiness.
  • Interplay of Central and Peripheral Fatigue: The model implicitly captures the interaction between central (e.g., changes in descending drive) and peripheral (e.g., metabolite effects on motoneurons and muscle fibers) fatigue mechanisms. While reducing descending drive had a minor impact on time to task failure, the metabolite model's influence on motor unit firing and force production was substantial.
  • Predictive Power Beyond Tuning: The model's ability to predict phenomena like the characteristic changes in interspike interval distributions (skewness and kurtosis) and recruitment threshold shifts, without explicit tuning for these specific outcomes, lends significant credibility to its underlying physiological assumptions.

Key Results

  • Time to Task Failure: The model accurately replicated the inverse relationship between target force and time to task failure, consistent with experimental data across a range of forces (20-70% MVC).
  • Motor Unit Discharge Rate: The model successfully simulated the differential changes in discharge rates: a decline for low-threshold units and an increase for high-threshold units during sustained contractions.
  • Force Variability: The model reproduced the increase in the coefficient of variation for force during fatiguing contractions, particularly at lower target forces.
  • Interspike Interval Distributions: The model generated characteristic changes in skewness and kurtosis of interspike intervals, reflecting the increased variability and altered temporal patterns of motor unit firing during fatigue.
  • Recruitment Threshold Shifts: The model predicted shifts in recruitment thresholds after fatiguing contractions, aligning with experimental observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Metabolite Model: The use of a single "compound metabolite" is a simplification. The authors acknowledge the need for more detailed models incorporating specific metabolites and their complex interactions.
  • PID Controller as a Black Box: The PID controller is a functional representation of CNS control, not a mechanistic one. The precise physiological underpinnings of how the CNS adjusts descending drive during fatigue remain an area for further investigation.
  • Limited Experimental Data for Validation: While the model was validated against existing literature and a specific experiment, more extensive and diverse experimental data are needed to fully validate its predictions across a wider range of conditions.
  • Muscle-Specific Parameters: The model was parameterized for the FDI muscle. Adapting it to other muscles would require adjusting parameters related to motor unit pool size, fiber type distribution, and blood flow occlusion thresholds.

Future work could focus on refining the metabolite model, exploring more sophisticated control algorithms, and conducting experiments specifically designed to test the model's predictions, particularly regarding the role of central versus peripheral factors in force control decline.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of the study was to expand a model of motor unit recruitment and rate coding (30) to simulate the adjustments that occur during a fatiguing contraction. The major new components of the model were the introduction of time-varying parameters for motor unit twitch force, recruitment, discharge rate, and discharge variability, and a control algorithm that estimates the net excitation needed by the motoneuron pool to maintain a prescribed target force. The fatigue-induced changes in motor unit activity in the expanded model are a function of changes in the metabolite concentrations that were computed with a compartment model of the intra- and extracellular spaces. The model was validated by comparing the simulation results with data available from the literature and experimentally recorded in the present study during isometric contractions of the first dorsal interosseus muscle. The output of the model was able to replicate a number of experimental findings, including the time to task failure for a range of target forces, the changes in motor unit discharge rates, the skewness and kurtosis of the interspike interval distributions, discharge variability, and the discharge characteristics of newly recruited motor units. The model output provides an integrative perspective of the adjustments during fatiguing contractions that are difficult to measure experimentally.
BibTeX
@article{dideriksen2010integrative,
  author = {Jakob Lund Dideriksen and Dario Farina and Martin Bækgaard and Roger M. Enoka},
  title = {{An integrative model of motor unit activity during sustained submaximal contractions}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physiology},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1152/japplphysiol.01017.2009},
}
Figure