TL;DR
This paper introduces "Disciple-LAS," a novel learning agent shell and methodology designed for rapid development of knowledge-based agents by domain experts with minimal AI expertise. It integrates knowledge representation, acquisition, learning, and problem-solving, enabling experts to teach agents tasks through cooperative problem-solving and apprenticeship learning, significantly reducing the traditional knowledge engineering bottleneck.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Developing practical, end-to-end knowledge-based agents (KBAs) has historically been a time-consuming and labor-intensive process, primarily due to the "knowledge engineering bottleneck." This involves the difficult and error-prone task of manually encoding an expert's knowledge into a system. While expert system shells offered a separation of inference engines and knowledge bases, the knowledge base itself (consisting of ontologies and rules) remained a challenge to build. Existing methods like automatic learning from data haven't fully solved this. The paper addresses the need for tools that empower domain experts to directly build and refine these agents, leveraging their expertise more efficiently and with less reliance on AI specialists.
Methods
Disciple-LAS is built around a "learning agent shell" concept, which includes a learning and knowledge acquisition engine alongside an inference engine. The core methodology involves:
- Domain Modeling: Representing the application domain using six types of knowledge elements: Objects, Features, Tasks, Task Reductions (examples), Explanations, and Rules. These are primarily modeled as frames, extending the OKBC knowledge model.
- Ontology Import: Leveraging the OKBC protocol to import existing ontologies from repositories like LOOM, facilitating knowledge reuse and reducing the need to build ontologies from scratch.
- Apprenticeship Learning: The agent learns by "teaching" from a domain expert. This involves cooperative problem-solving where the expert guides the agent, provides examples, explanations, and hints. The agent uses a combination of techniques, including inductive learning from examples and explanations, and analogical reasoning.
- Task Reduction: The problem-solving approach is based on hierarchical task reduction, where complex tasks are broken down into simpler, executable ones.
- Plausible Version Space (PVS) Rules: The agent learns rules that have both a plausible upper bound (PUB) and a plausible lower bound (PLB) condition. This allows for flexible application and refinement, where solutions might be considered "plausible" even if not fully confirmed.
- Integrated Methodology: A structured seven-step process guides the development, from problem specification and domain modeling to agent training and testing.
Datasets
The paper describes an experimental evaluation using the "workaround challenge problem" from DARPA's High Performance Knowledge Bases Program. This problem involved assessing how a military unit could reconstitute or bypass damage to infrastructure like bridges or roads. The evaluation used a set of 20 testing problems, with additional new problems introduced in later phases, including scenarios with new damage types (cratered roads) and new engineering equipment. The solutions were compared against those of a human expert.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Empowering Domain Experts: The core idea is shifting the burden of knowledge acquisition from knowledge engineers to domain experts, making KBA development more accessible.
- Synergistic Learning: Disciple-LAS integrates multiple learning strategies (inductive, explanation-based, analogical) to handle diverse learning situations and improve robustness.
- Cooperative Learning: The agent learns through a natural, interactive process with the expert, mimicking how a human apprentice learns, which is more intuitive than traditional methods.
- Ontology Reuse is Crucial but Challenging: While importing ontologies via OKBC is a key enabler, the paper acknowledges the difficulties in achieving seamless interoperability and the need for better guidance in identifying and importing relevant knowledge.
- Plausible Reasoning for Flexibility: The use of PVS rules allows the agent to operate and learn even with incomplete knowledge, making it more practical in real-world scenarios.
Key Results
The experimental evaluation with the workaround agent demonstrated significant success:
- Rapid Knowledge Acquisition: The agent's knowledge base grew at a rate of approximately 787 binary predicates per day, supporting the claim of rapid acquisition of relevant problem-solving knowledge.
- High Quality Solutions: The Disciple agent performed at the level of a human expert in terms of solution quality. In several instances, it generated more correct or complete solutions, and even new solutions not initially considered by the expert.
- High Performance: The workaround generator could produce solutions in about 0.3 seconds on a medium-power PC, indicating high performance.
- Agent Integration: The developed agent was selected by DARPA and Alphatech for further extension and integration into a larger air campaign planning system.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations and outline future research directions:
- Initial Domain Modeling: The current shell doesn't fully support the initial modeling of the domain. They plan to develop a modeling tool to assist with abstract descriptions of tasks and objects.
- Ontology Import Challenges: Importing concepts and features from existing ontologies is difficult. Future work will focus on methods to provide more guidance for identifying and importing knowledge.
- Hint Specification: The current hint specification mechanism is not powerful or intuitive enough. They aim to develop a more robust approach to hint specification.
- Analogical Reasoning Enhancement: Further research is planned to make the agent's learning methods even more knowledge-intensive, particularly through more powerful analogical reasoning techniques.
- Broader Problem Solving Approaches: While currently based on task reduction, the methodology is designed to be general and could be applied with other problem solvers in the future.
Summary updated