Abstract
This paper presents an approach to regular grammar inference that operates both incrementally and interactively. By utilizing a version space search strategy over a lattice of Finite State Automata (FSA), the algorithm identifies a target grammar through membership queries to a teacher. Unlike traditional methods that require a structurally complete set of examples at the outset, this algorithm updates its hypothesis space as new data arrives, ensuring provable convergence to the target language even when starting with incomplete information.
Introduction
Grammar inference is the process of discovering the underlying rules of a language based on a set of example strings. In the context of regular grammars, this task involves constructing a Finite State Automaton (FSA) that accepts all "legal" strings (positive examples) and rejects "illegal" ones (negative examples). Historically, many algorithms for this task relied on the structural completeness assumption, which assumes that the initial set of positive examples is "perfect"—meaning every production rule in the hidden grammar is used at least once to generate the provided examples.
In real-world scenarios, data is rarely this tidy. We often receive examples one by one, and we need a learner that can refine its understanding over time. Parekh and Honavar address the challenge of building a learner that is both incremental (handles new data as it arrives) and interactive (asks questions to resolve ambiguity), relaxing the rigid requirements of batch processing and initial completeness.
Methodology
The authors utilize a "version space" approach to navigate the search space of possible grammars, combining state-merging techniques with active learning.
1. The Lattice of Grammars
The algorithm starts with a set of positive examples ($S^+$) and builds a Maximal Canonical Automaton (MCA)—a very specific FSA that accepts only those exact strings. By merging states within this MCA, the learner creates more general grammars. This hierarchy of specific-to-general grammars forms a "lattice," representing the search space of all possible FSAs that could explain the data.
2. Version Space Search
The search space is bounded by two sets: $S$ (the most specific hypotheses) and $G$ (the most general hypotheses). The goal is to prune this space until $S$ and $G$ converge on a single hypothesis. This framework allows the learner to maintain a concise representation of an otherwise exponentially sized search space.
3. Membership Queries
To prune the space efficiently, the learner identifies the shortest string that exists in the "symmetric difference" between the languages of $S$ and $G$ (i.e., a string that one FSA accepts but the other rejects). It then asks a "teacher" if that string belongs to the target language. The teacher's "yes/no" response allows the learner to eliminate large swaths of incorrect hypotheses. These are referred to as "safe queries" because they focus on the simplest points of disagreement.
4. Incrementality
Unlike batch algorithms, this method relaxes the structural completeness requirement. If the teacher provides a new positive example that doesn't fit the current lattice, the learner incrementally updates the lattice to incorporate the new data. In traditional version space learning, the hypothesis space is usually fixed; here, the "base" of the lattice (the MCA) can grow, allowing the learner to adapt to a broader language than it initially envisioned.
Key Insights and Theoretical Results
The most significant contribution of this work is the dynamic nature of the hypothesis space. By allowing the MCA to grow, the algorithm can handle evolving datasets. The authors identify the necessary and sufficient conditions under which the algorithm is guaranteed to converge to the correct target FSA. Specifically, the resulting FSA is provably equivalent to the target FSA once the set of positive examples becomes structurally complete, even if that completeness is only achieved over multiple incremental steps.
Furthermore, the version space approach makes the inference process computationally more manageable than exhaustive search, providing a theoretical safety net for the incremental approach in practical applications.
Conclusion and Future Work
While the paper establishes a strong theoretical framework, the authors acknowledge several areas for further development. Future work includes the development of better heuristics to generate "informative" queries that can speed up the learning process. Additionally, while the algorithm is theoretically sound, empirical estimates of the expected-case time and space complexity remain a priority.
Finally, the authors suggest extending this incremental/interactive framework to more complex structures, such as regular tree grammars and attributed grammars, which are used in more sophisticated pattern recognition and natural language processing tasks.
Summary updated