An Improved System Dynamics Model to Evaluate Regional Water Scarcity from a Virtual Water Perspective: A Case Study of Henan Province, China

Zhaodan Wu, Yi Zhang, Yu Long Hua, Quanliang Ye, Lixiao Xu, Shiqi WangSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an improved system dynamics model to better assess regional water scarcity (WS) by incorporating virtual water flows and a more nuanced understanding of consumption-based water footprints. The enhanced model, applied to Henan Province, China, provides a more accurate picture of water demand and offers insights into how different policy interventions (production structure, technology, trade) can mitigate WS while considering socioeconomic and environmental impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water scarcity is a critical issue globally, particularly in China, where rapid development has strained resources. Traditional methods of assessing water scarcity often rely on real water withdrawal, which can overlook crucial aspects like indirect water use embedded in supply chains and the impact of trade. Furthermore, existing models often fail to integrate the complex interplay between water scarcity and broader socioeconomic and environmental factors. This paper aims to address these limitations by developing a more comprehensive and accurate system dynamics model for evaluating regional water scarcity from a virtual water perspective, specifically focusing on Henan Province, a region facing significant water stress.

Methods

The authors propose an enhanced system dynamics model that builds upon previous work. Key improvements include:

  • Redefining Water Scarcity (WS): WS is now defined as the ratio of the consumption-based blue water footprint to water availability. This shift emphasizes local demand for goods and services and contrasts with production-based footprints that include water used for exports.
  • Integrating Tertiary Industry Dynamics: The model now incorporates economic growth, trade, and water use efficiency specifically for the tertiary industry (e.g., accommodation, food services), which are significant water consumers and often overlooked in simpler models.
  • Differentiated Regional Data: The model distinguishes between product use structures and water use coefficients for local regions, other domestic regions, and foreign countries. This allows for a more precise calculation of virtual water flows and footprints by accounting for regional variations in production and technology.
  • Holistic Performance Evaluation: Beyond just WS, the model displays the socioeconomic and environmental performance associated with different WS reduction strategies, providing a more complete picture for policymakers.

The modeling approach uses Vensim software and involves defining system boundaries, identifying key variables (stocks and flows), and developing system equations to simulate the interactions between various subsystems (social water use, economic water use, water environment, water supply, and virtual water flow).

Datasets

The study utilizes a variety of datasets for its analysis and model calibration:

  • Crop Attributes and Meteorological Data: Derived from FAO-56 and the China Meteorological Data Sharing Service Network for the period 2008-2018.
  • Input-Output (IO) Tables: Official competitive IO tables for Henan and China for years 2002, 2007, and 2012 were used to estimate annual IO tables for 2008-2011 and 2013-2018.
  • Trade Data: Import and export data for crop and animal products from Zhengzhou Customs Statistical Data.
  • Water Use Data: Henan Water Resources Bulletin provided data on primary industry water use, per capita water use, urban/rural living water use, and water supply.
  • Socioeconomic Data: Henan Statistical Yearbook supplied data on population, urbanization, industrial value added, and other economic indicators.
  • Policy Documents: Future projections for 2019-2030 were informed by provincial development plans (e.g., "13th Five-Year Plan for National Economic and Social Development of Henan Province").

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Consumption-Based Footprint is Key for Local Demand: Shifting the WS metric to a consumption-based water footprint is crucial because it directly reflects the water needed to satisfy local demand, making it a more accurate indicator of local water stress than production-based measures alone.
  • Tertiary Sector Matters: The inclusion of tertiary industry dynamics is vital, as economic growth and trade in services significantly contribute to water demand, and improvements in efficiency here can yield substantial water savings.
  • Regional Nuances in Virtual Water: Recognizing that production processes and water use coefficients vary significantly between regions (local, other domestic, foreign) is essential for accurately tracking virtual water flows and their impact on regional WS.
  • Policy Trade-offs are Real: Different policy interventions (production structure adjustment, technology upgrade, trade restructuring) have distinct impacts not only on WS but also on broader socioeconomic and environmental outcomes, highlighting the need for integrated decision-making.

Key Results

  • Henan Faces Persistent Water Scarcity: The study projects that Henan Province will continue to experience water scarcity, with an average WS of 2.19 during 2008-2030, showing an annual increase of 1.37%.
  • Production Structure Adjustment is Most Effective for WS Reduction: Among the evaluated scenarios, adjusting the production structure to reduce reliance on high water-footprint agricultural products and related sectors showed the greatest potential for lowering WS (average WS of 2.02).
  • Technology Upgrade Offers Broad Benefits: Technology enhancement in water saving, purification, and pollution control led to the second-lowest WS (2.04) while also supporting the largest total population, GDP, and available water resources.
  • Trade Restructuring Offers Moderate Gains: Trade structure adjustment showed a smaller reduction in WS compared to production structure adjustment or technology upgrades, but it resulted in the smallest total population among the scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity for Primary Industry: The paper acknowledges the difficulty in precisely distinguishing water use for human consumption versus livestock feed for agricultural products. Future work could improve accuracy by statistically separating these flows.
  • Model Complexity vs. MRIO: While the improved model is less data-intensive than multi-regional input-output (MRIO) analysis, the authors note that MRIO could offer further distinctions in product use structures and water use coefficients across regions.
  • Focus on Blue Water: The study primarily focuses on blue water footprints. Future research could expand to include green and grey water footprints for a more holistic water footprint assessment.
  • Generalizability: While the model is presented as applicable to other regions, further validation in different geographical and economic contexts would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

An accurate and practically useful evaluation of regional water scarcity is a necessary procedure in scarcity monitoring and threat mitigation. From the perspective of virtual water, this study proposed an improved system dynamics model to evaluate regional water scarcity (WS), including a case study of Henan province, China. We enhanced the existing system dynamics model of WS evaluation from a virtual water perspective by (1) defining WS as the ratio of the consumption-based blue water footprint to water availability, in order to compare the water requirements that need to be met to satisfy the local demand of goods and services with water supply; (2) integrating the economic growth, trade, and water use efficiency in the tertiary industry (e.g., accommodation, food and beverage services) into the model, in order to improve the accuracy of WS assessment and help find more specific measures to reduce WS by factor adjustment; (3) distinguishing the product use structure matrix, as well as the sectoral direct water use coefficient, in local regions from that in other domestic regions and foreign countries, and identifying the regional use structure matrices of products from these three kinds of regions, in order to increase the calculating veracity; and (4) displaying performances of the society, economy, and environment in WS reduction, in order to offer a more comprehensive reference for practical policy decisions. The case study results show that Henan has been suffering from, and in the near future could continue to face, water scarcity, with an average of 2.19 and an annual rise of 1.37% during 2008–2030. In the scenario comparison of current development, production structure adjustment, technology upgrade, and trade structure adjustment in supply-side structural reform of Henan from 2019 to 2030, WS could be reduced by updating production structures into less production of agricultural products or other sectors with a high production-based water footprint (with the smallest average WS of 2.02 and the second smallest total population and GDP, i.e., gross domestic production), technology enhancement in water saving, purification and pollution control (with the second smallest average WS of 2.04 and the largest total population, GDP and total available water resources). Furthermore, for the agricultural products or other sectors with high domestic/international virtual water outflow (inflow), if we reduce (increase) their percentage of outflow (inflow) in the industry involved, WS will increase only more slightly than that when we keep the current development trend, with the smallest total population. Potential measures for alleviating WS should be taken comprehensively, with priorities being identified according to the socioeconomic and environmental performance. Our model can be useful for practical policymaking and valuable for relevant research worldwide.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2020improved,
  author = {Zhaodan Wu and Yi Zhang and Yu Long Hua and Quanliang Ye and Lixiao Xu and Shiqi Wang},
  title = {{An Improved System Dynamics Model to Evaluate Regional Water Scarcity from a Virtual Water Perspective: A Case Study of Henan Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12187517},
}
Figure