An Improved Shapley Value Method for a Green Supply Chain Income Distribution Mechanism

Zhongwen Xu, Zixuan Peng, L. Yang, Xudong ChenInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of fairly distributing profits in green supply chains, particularly in resource-based industries in China. It proposes an improved Shapley value method that accounts for risk, ecological efforts, and technological levels, demonstrating that a cooperative, centralized market structure leads to higher overall profits and a more equitable distribution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional resource-based supply chains often lead to environmental degradation and resource depletion. In response, there's a growing push for "green" supply chains that prioritize low-carbon development and environmental remediation. However, a key challenge is how to incentivize participation and ensure fair profit distribution among different entities (like resource developers and processors) within these chains, especially when market demand is uncertain and environmental regulations are in place. Existing methods for income distribution, like the standard Shapley value, don't adequately capture the nuances of these green supply chains, such as the varying levels of environmental investment and associated risks. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more sophisticated income distribution mechanism.

Methods

The authors employ game theory to model the resource-based supply chain, considering both decentralized (independent decision-making) and centralized (cooperative decision-making) market scenarios. They introduce a novel, improved Shapley value method for income distribution. This improved method builds upon the traditional Shapley value by incorporating three key correction factors:

  • Risk Factor: Accounts for market fluctuations and their impact on enterprise benefits.
  • Ecological Factor: Quantifies the efforts in environmental remediation (by resource developers) and emissions reduction (by resource processors).
  • Effort Level (Technological Level): Represents other resource inputs like equipment, labor, and operational costs.

These factors are quantified and then used to adjust the traditional Shapley value, aiming for a fairer and more realistic distribution of profits that reflects each participant's contributions and risks. A numerical analysis using MATLAB simulations is conducted to validate the proposed model.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses assumed parameter values for its numerical simulations, referencing a previously published paper for some of these values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Centralized Markets Win: Cooperative, centralized decision-making in resource-based supply chains leads to higher total profits compared to decentralized models. This is because it better promotes emissions reductions and ecological remediation.
  • Beyond Marginal Contributions: The traditional Shapley value, while useful, is insufficient for green supply chains. It overlooks crucial factors like risk, ecological investment, and technological effort, which are vital for fair distribution.
  • Risk, Ecology, and Effort Matter: The improved Shapley value method, by incorporating these three factors, provides a more nuanced and realistic income distribution. This can incentivize greater participation in green initiatives.
  • Technological Level Dominates: In the studied model, the technological level (representing other resource inputs) was found to have the largest influence on income distribution, highlighting the importance of operational efficiency.
  • Ecological Remediation vs. Emissions Reduction: The study suggests that increasing ecological remediation efforts (by developers) can decrease overall profit, while increasing emissions reduction efforts (by processors) can increase it. This implies a need for targeted subsidies to encourage specific green activities.

Key Results

  • The study demonstrates that a centralized decision-making situation yields a greater total profit than a decentralized one. For instance, in one simulation, the total benefit under centralized decision-making was 88.548, compared to 76.875 under decentralized conditions.
  • The improved Shapley value method provides a different income distribution compared to the traditional method. For example, in one scenario, the improved method resulted in an income distribution vector of (25.6269, 44.5191), whereas the traditional method yielded (37.692, 32.454). The authors argue the improved method is more realistic and achieves better Pareto optimization.
  • The numerical analysis showed that increasing ecological remediation efforts (γ) decreased the total profit, while increasing emissions reduction efforts (ξ) increased the total profit. For example, changing γ from 0.5 to 0.8 resulted in a profit decrease from 94.416 to 76.866. Conversely, increasing ξ from 0.4 to 0.6 increased profit from 87.178 to 91.788.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope: The current model only considers a two-stage supply chain with a single developer and a single processor. The authors suggest that future work could explore multiple-stage supply chains.
  • Single Period Analysis: The study focuses on a single period. A prospective study spanning multiple periods would be more comprehensive for sustainable supply chain development.
  • Technological Level Influence: The significant influence of the technological level on income distribution warrants further research.
  • Subsidy Standards: The paper suggests that instead of universally mandating environmental protection efforts, differentiated subsidy standards should be applied to different enterprises within the supply chain. This is a key managerial recommendation for future implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low-carbon development and environmental remediation are key factors for green resource-based supply chains in China. With this aim in mind, by applying game theory under uncertain market demand, this paper incorporates low-carbon development and environmental remediation into a resource-based supply chain coordination model for decentralized and centralized markets. The results show that a centralized market can lead to improvement in total profit. Furthermore, based on an improved Shapley value method, a theoretical model for the centralized market income distribution mechanism is developed that incorporates three corrective risk factors, ecological investment, and technological level. Finally, a numerical analysis is conducted using a MATLAB simulation to obtain intuitive results, which, in turn, show the validity of incentive income distribution mechanisms for green supply chain development in China.
BibTeX
@article{xu2018improved,
  author = {Zhongwen Xu and Zixuan Peng and L. Yang and Xudong Chen},
  title = {{An Improved Shapley Value Method for a Green Supply Chain Income Distribution Mechanism}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph15091976},
}
Figure