An Improved Indicator System for Evaluating the Progress of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) Sub-Target 9.1 in County Level

Jiacheng Xu, Jianjun Bai, Jun ChenSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the limitations of existing global Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) indicators for assessing transportation infrastructure at the county level in China. The authors propose and validate an improved indicator system that better captures local realities, including urban populations and detailed road network characteristics, offering a more nuanced evaluation of SDG sub-target 9.1.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) provide a global framework for progress, but their indicators, often designed for national-level analysis, can struggle to accurately reflect conditions at finer administrative scales like counties. Specifically, SDG sub-target 9.1, which aims to develop quality, reliable, sustainable, and resilient infrastructure, relies on indicators 9.1.1 (rural access index) and 9.1.2 (passenger and freight volumes). The authors identify several critical issues when applying these indicators at the county level in China:

  • Country-Oriented Design: The indicators are not well-suited for uneven development within a country, leading to unrepresentative results at sub-national levels.
  • Localization Problems: The "rural access index" (9.1.1) is heavily reliant on urban-rural boundary data, which is often unavailable or unclear in rapidly urbanizing areas like Chinese counties. It also fails to account for "urban poor" populations living in areas that are neither strictly urban nor rural.
  • Limited Scope: Indicator 9.1.1 primarily measures access to roads but neglects road quality, connectivity, and the actual ability to enter a road. Indicator 9.1.2 focuses on economic activity but doesn't fully capture the impact on people's well-being.
  • Data Challenges: Obtaining accurate urban-rural boundary data for indicator 9.1.1 is difficult, and alternative data sources may introduce errors at the county level.

Methods

The researchers developed an improved indicator system by modifying SDG indicator 9.1.1 and introducing three new indicators. The core of their methodology involved:

  1. Modifying the Rural Access Index (RAI): The original RAI (indicator 9.1.1) was adapted to include both urban and rural populations, removing the dependence on urban-rural boundary data. This ensures that vulnerable urban populations are considered.
  2. Introducing New Indicators:
    • Road Density (RD): Measures the quantity and spatial distribution of roads.
  3. Accessibility (Average Travel Time - ATM): Assesses road connectivity and quality by calculating the average travel time between points, reflecting how easily residents can reach destinations.
  4. Total Postal Business (TPB): Acts as a proxy for the impact of transportation infrastructure on economic development and people's livelihoods, complementing the passenger and freight volume data.
  5. Case Study Application: The proposed system was applied to Deqing County in China to evaluate its effectiveness and compare it with the original SDG indicators.
  6. Data Analysis: The study involved calculating and analyzing the results from both the original and improved indicator systems, using spatial analysis and statistical comparisons.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets for Deqing County:

  • Road Data: Vector data from the Deqing County Transportation Management Department, including road levels.
  • Population Data: Calculated based on surface coverage data from the Deqing County Geographic Information Center and census data from the Deqing County Statistics Bureau, distributed into 30m grids.
  • Passenger and Freight Volumes: Obtained from the Deqing County Statistical Yearbook.
  • Total Postal Business: Obtained from the Deqing County Statistical Yearbook.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on adapting existing data for county-level analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Urban Poor" Matter: The traditional rural-centric approach to access indicators misses significant segments of the population in rapidly urbanizing areas, particularly those in "urban villages."
  • Beyond "Having a Road": Simply having an all-season road within a certain distance isn't enough. The connectivity and quality of that road (measured by travel time) are crucial for actual utility and economic impact.
  • Data Availability is Key: The reliance on hard-to-obtain urban-rural boundary data is a major hurdle for applying SDG indicators at sub-national levels. The proposed RAI modification directly addresses this.
  • Holistic Evaluation: Combining infrastructure quantity (road density), quality/connectivity (ATM), and economic/social impact (PFV + TPB) provides a much richer picture than individual indicators.

Key Results

  • Improved RAI: The modified RAI successfully accounted for urban populations and eliminated the need for urban-rural boundary data, making it more applicable to county-level assessments.
  • Detailed Infrastructure Insights: Road density and accessibility (ATM) revealed spatial imbalances and connectivity issues within Deqing County, particularly in mountainous areas like Moganshan Town, which were masked by the original 9.1.1 indicator (which showed 100% rural access).
  • Balanced Assessment: The improved system provided a more comprehensive view by integrating infrastructure characteristics with their impact on economic development and people's well-being, addressing limitations of the original indicators. For instance, while passenger and freight volumes showed a decline, the improved system, by considering total postal business, suggested a positive impact on livelihoods, offering a more nuanced interpretation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • "Isolated Roads" Dilemma: The paper discusses the challenge of how to treat "isolated roads" (roads not connected to the main network). While they opted for stricter criteria by removing them for the improved RAI, they note that in areas with slow economic development, even isolated roads might offer some benefit. Determining the optimal approach for handling such roads requires further consideration.
  • PFV Data Incompleteness: The study highlights that passenger and freight volume (PFV) data in Chinese counties can be incomplete due to how vehicles are registered (e.g., vehicles registered in neighboring cities might not be counted). This suggests that relying solely on PFV for economic impact assessment can be misleading.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their improved indicator system offers a valuable reference for researchers evaluating SDG progress at county levels, particularly in rapidly urbanizing low- and middle-income countries. They also point out that the problems identified with the SDG indicators might also exist at the national level, warranting further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to assess the progress of the SDG sub-target 9.1 at the county level, the SDG indicator 9.1.1 (rural access index) and 9.1.2 (passenger and freight volumes) were implemented in Deqing County, China to explore the fitness-for-purpose of these indicators for county level evaluations. It is found that the country-oriented indicator system has some localization problems and cannot fully reflect the connotation of the SDG sub-target 9.1 when used in the county level. An improved indicator system was built by modifying the SDG indicator 9.1.1 and adding three more indicators (namely the road density, accessibility, and total postal business). The analysis of the calculation process and results showed that the improved indicator system can solve the problems arising from the original SDG indicator when applied in the county level. The modified resident access index can eliminate the dependence of the original indicator 9.1.1 calculations on urban-rural boundary data, and takes into account the urban vulnerable groups such as urban villages residents. While the road density and accessibility can be used to measure the quantity, quality, and connectivity of the road and the reality of the residents to obtain the road, which enables the indicators to reflect the necessary details of the level of the transportation infrastructure construction. The total postal business can help the SDG indicator 9.1.2 reflect the relationship between the transportation infrastructure construction and the development of the economic and people’s livelihood.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2019improved,
  author = {Jiacheng Xu and Jianjun Bai and Jun Chen},
  title = {{An Improved Indicator System for Evaluating the Progress of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) Sub-Target 9.1 in County Level}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11174783},
}
Figure