An identification of models to help in the design of national strategies and policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Danielle Maia de Souza, Radhwane Boukelouha, Emma Frejinger, Catherine Morency, Normand Mousseau, Martin TrépanierTransportation 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews national strategies and modeling tools used to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in the transportation sector, particularly in Europe. It highlights the need for integrated approaches that combine "Avoid/Reduce," "Shift," and "Improve" strategies, and identifies Land Use Transportation Interaction (LUTI) models as crucial for urban-scale climate action planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The transportation sector is a major contributor to global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and with the Paris Agreement's call for decarbonization, countries are developing strategies to reduce these emissions. However, many national climate action plans (NDCs) lack specific, quantitative targets and detailed strategies for the transport sector, often focusing heavily on technological "Improve" measures rather than behavioral or systemic changes. This paper addresses the challenge of effectively designing and implementing these strategies by:

  1. Identifying and categorizing existing GHG emission reduction strategies for the transport sector, particularly the "Avoid/Reduce, Shift, and Improve" (A-S-I) framework.
  2. Reviewing the models and tools used at national and regional levels to inform policy development and scenario planning for GHG emission reductions in transport.
  3. Highlighting the role of Land Use Transportation Interaction (LUTI) models in supporting urban-scale climate change mitigation efforts, which are often overlooked in broader national strategies.

The paper aims to provide a clearer understanding of how these models and strategies can be integrated to achieve more effective and comprehensive climate action in the transportation sector.

Methods

The paper employs a comprehensive literature review and synthesis approach. The authors:

  • Categorize transport-related GHG emission reduction strategies based on the established "Avoid/Reduce, Shift, and Improve" (A-S-I) framework. This involves analyzing national and regional policy documents and academic literature to identify specific measures within each category.
  • Review and describe various modeling tools used for projecting GHG emissions and evaluating policy options in the transport sector. This includes national-scale models (e.g., PRIMES-TREMOVE, TIMES) and their underlying components, as well as a detailed compilation of Land Use Transportation Interaction (LUTI) models.
  • Analyze the characteristics of LUTI models, focusing on their structure, sub-models, geographic basis, activities included, and how they incorporate factors like household and real estate characteristics, employment, and policies. This analysis is presented in a comparative table.

The methodology is primarily descriptive and analytical, aiming to map out the landscape of strategies and modeling tools rather than introducing new computational models or empirical datasets.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on a review of existing literature, policy documents, and reports from international organizations (e.g., IEA, UNFCCC, EC).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The A-S-I framework is crucial but underutilized: While the Avoid/Reduce, Shift, and Improve (A-S-I) framework offers a comprehensive approach to transport decarbonization, many national policies disproportionately emphasize "Improve" measures (e.g., vehicle efficiency, electrification) over "Avoid/Reduce" (e.g., behavioral change, land-use planning) and "Shift" (e.g., public transport, active mobility).
  • Integrated strategies are essential: Achieving significant GHG reductions requires a synergistic combination of all three A-S-I strategies. Relying solely on technological improvements is insufficient and can lead to rebound effects.
  • LUTI models are vital for urban climate action: Land Use Transportation Interaction (LUTI) models are identified as critical tools for understanding and planning at the urban scale. They can link land-use decisions, transportation patterns, and behavioral changes to predict and mitigate GHG emissions, offering a more granular approach to climate policy.
  • Policy implementation varies greatly: The effectiveness and detail of GHG reduction policies differ significantly across countries and regions, with some providing quantitative targets and others offering more generic guidelines.
  • Modeling transparency is lacking: The paper notes that the extent to which national policies are based on specific modeling approaches, and the transparency of these models and their resulting policy decisions, is often unclear.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a detailed overview of A-S-I measures implemented or proposed in various European countries (Germany, France, Portugal, Spain, UK) and Canada.
  • It identifies and describes several key modeling tools used at the national and European levels, including PRIMES-TREMOVE, TIMES, and various LUTI models (e.g., ILUTE, IRPUD, ITLUP, LILT, MEPLAN, TRANUS, UrbanSim).
  • A comparative table (Table 1) summarizes proposed A-S-I measures for road transport in European countries and Canada, categorizing them as generic (G) or quantitative (Q).
  • Another table (Table 2) presents energy use and energy scenarios for transportation in Germany and France, illustrating projected shifts in energy types towards 2030.
  • The review highlights that while "Improve" measures are widely adopted, "Avoid/Reduce" and "Shift" measures are considered in a smaller percentage of NDCs, and often in combination.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited scope of LUTI model application: The paper notes that most LUTI models reviewed have been applied to a limited number of cities and are often calibrated for specific urban areas, suggesting a need for broader application and integration into national policy frameworks.
  • Lack of transparency in policy-model linkage: The authors point out that it is not always clear how national policies are constructed based on modeling approaches, and the transparency of these models and their outcomes could be improved.
  • Need for more integrated modeling: The paper implicitly suggests a need for more advanced transport models that can explore the full potential of interdependencies between existing policies, A-S-I measures, and their effects on GHG emissions, as well as other societal and environmental aspects.
  • Future work could focus on: Developing more integrated modeling approaches, enhancing the transparency of policy-model linkages, and promoting the application of LUTI models for more effective urban climate action planning.

Summary updated

Abstract

In response to the rapid increase in global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, 196 countries have made a legal commitment to implement a strategy to decarbonize their economies, under the Paris Agreement, particularly with respect to the transportation sector. As part of their long-term climate actions, these countries are defining various Avoid/Reduce, Shift and Improve (A-S-I) strategies, aimed at reducing or avoiding unnecessary travel, promoting and shifting to public transport and active modes, and improving energy efficiency and vehicle technology. In this paper, we take a closer look at some of the regional and national strategies and policies to reduce GHG emissions in Europe, as well as the models and methods used to assist in policy development. Keeping in mind the limited guidance on concrete avoidance/reduction and transfer strategies mentioned in the climate actions, we list some of the land use and transport interaction (LUTI) models that can be used to improve climate change control at the urban scale. The aim of this paper is to gain a better understanding of how methods and tools can assist in decision making and policy development with respect to GHG emission reduction goals in the transportation sector.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{souza2025identification,
  author = {Danielle Maia de Souza and Radhwane Boukelouha and Emma Frejinger and Catherine Morency and Normand Mousseau and Martin Trépanier},
  title = {{An identification of models to help in the design of national strategies and policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.}},
  booktitle = {Transportation},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.trpro.2024.12.094},
}
Figure