An Extended ADOP for Performance Evaluation of Single-Frequency Single-Epoch Positioning by BDS/GPS in Asia-Pacific Region

Xin Liu, Shubi Zhang, Qiuzhao Zhang, Wei Yang2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "Extended Ambiguity Dilution of Precision" (E-ADOP) metric to simplify and improve the evaluation of single-frequency, single-epoch (SFSE) GNSS positioning. By analyzing the influence of satellite geometry and number, they demonstrate that high-elevation satellites and the BeiDou Navigation Satellite System (BDS) generally lead to better ambiguity resolution performance compared to GPS.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-precision positioning using Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) is a crucial area of research. A key challenge in single-frequency, single-epoch (SFSE) positioning is achieving reliable ambiguity resolution, which is essential for centimeter-level accuracy. Traditional metrics like Ambiguity Dilution of Precision (ADOP) are complex and can be difficult to interpret. This paper aims to address this by developing a more intuitive and analytically tractable metric (E-ADOP) to better understand and predict the performance of SFSE positioning, particularly for combined BDS/GPS systems in the Asia-Pacific region.

Methods

The core contribution is the development of the Extended ADOP (E-ADOP). This new metric is derived from the traditional ADOP but simplifies its expression by introducing the Summation-Multiplication Ratio of Weight (SMRW) and two theorems for short baselines. E-ADOP aims to provide a clearer insight into the influence of the number of satellites and their geometric configuration (specifically, the proportion of high-elevation satellites) on ambiguity resolution success. The authors then use this E-ADOP metric to analyze and compare the performance of BDS, GPS, and combined BDS/GPS systems under various conditions, including different baselines and sky conditions (clear vs. complex). Experimental data was collected and analyzed to validate the theoretical findings.

Datasets

The paper utilizes experimental data collected from:

  • Hong Kong Base Station in March 2017 for baselines of 5 km, 10 km, and 15 km.
  • Data collected in Xuzhou under complex sky conditions (multipath and urban canyon) for a 3 km² area with a 5 km baseline.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing GNSS data was used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • E-ADOP Simplifies Analysis: The new E-ADOP metric offers a more straightforward way to understand the factors influencing ambiguity resolution success compared to the traditional ADOP.
  • High-Elevation Satellites Matter: A higher proportion of high-elevation satellites significantly improves positioning reliability and ambiguity resolution success. This is because their signals are less affected by multipath and ionospheric errors.
  • BDS Outperforms GPS (in this context): In the Asia-Pacific region, BDS generally shows better ambiguity resolution performance than GPS, primarily attributed to its higher number of visible satellites and a greater proportion of high-elevation satellites.
  • SMRW is Key: The SMRW, which is directly related to the geometric configuration of satellites (especially high-elevation ones), is identified as a dominant factor in controlling ADOP, particularly when the number of satellites is constant.
  • Combined Systems Excel: BDS/GPS combined systems consistently demonstrate superior performance, achieving higher success rates and better accuracy than either single system.

Key Results

  • ADOP Decreases with More Satellites: Adding more satellites generally leads to a smaller ADOP, improving ambiguity resolution.
  • Constant Satellites, Higher Elevation = Lower ADOP: When the number of satellites is fixed, a higher proportion of high-elevation satellites leads to a smaller ADOP.
  • BDS/GPS Dominance: For 5 km, 10 km, and 15 km baselines in clear sky conditions, BDS/GPS achieved success rates consistently above 99%, while GPS often fell below 90%.
  • Baseline Length: The calculated baseline length for reliable SFSE positioning was found to be approximately 10 km for BDS, shorter than 5 km for GPS, and longer than 15 km for BDS/GPS.
  • Complex Conditions: Even in challenging urban canyon and multipath environments, BDS and BDS/GPS maintained high success rates (above 99%), significantly outperforming GPS.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Specificity: The study focuses on the Asia-Pacific region, and the conclusions regarding satellite visibility and performance might differ in other geographic locations.
  • Short Baselines: The analysis is primarily focused on short baselines (up to 15 km), where ionospheric and tropospheric errors can be largely mitigated by double-differencing. The performance on longer baselines might require different considerations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the developed E-ADOP metric can be further expanded to analyze the performance of multi-system GNSS and to guide satellite selection strategies for improved success rates, especially in complex sky conditions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2017extended,
  author = {Xin Liu and Shubi Zhang and Qiuzhao Zhang and Wei Yang},
  title = {{An Extended ADOP for Performance Evaluation of Single-Frequency Single-Epoch Positioning by BDS/GPS in Asia-Pacific Region}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17102254},
}
Figure