An Explainable Statistical Method for Seizure Prediction Using Brain Functional Connectivity from EEG

Hao Chen, Taoyun Ji, Xiang Zhan, Xiaoxin Liu, Guojing Yu, Wen Wang, Yuwu Jiang, Xiao‐Hua ZhouComputational 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, explainable statistical method for predicting epileptic seizures using dynamic brain functional connectivity derived from EEG data. By moving beyond complex deep learning models, this approach offers improved interpretability and computational efficiency, achieving state-of-the-art performance on public datasets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Epilepsy, a chronic neurological disorder affecting millions, is characterized by unpredictable seizures that significantly impact patients' quality of life and can even be life-threatening. Accurate seizure prediction is crucial to allow patients to take preventative measures, such as administering medication, thereby reducing anxiety and preventing traumatic events. While existing methods often rely on deep learning for seizure prediction, these approaches suffer from a lack of interpretability and high computational complexity, making them difficult for clinicians to adopt. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an explainable and computationally efficient statistical method for patient-specific seizure prediction.

Methods

The proposed method is a two-stage statistical approach.

Stage 1: Dynamic Brain Functional Connectivity Estimation This stage focuses on estimating the dynamic brain functional connectivity network from scalp EEG data. The core idea is to model the brain as a complex network where different regions communicate. The authors adapt a framework for matrix-variate data, specifically focusing on estimating sparse precision matrices that represent the strength of connections between brain regions. Crucially, they assume that these connections are dynamic over time within each epoch, rather than static. This is achieved by using time-varying covariance matrices and a weighted approach to estimate the precision matrix. The resulting connectivity measures are then vectorized to form a "Network Predictor Matrix."

Stage 2: Seizure Prediction This stage utilizes a penalized and ensembled logistic regression model. To handle the high dimensionality of the network predictor matrix, a Lasso penalty is employed. A bootstrap procedure is used to ensemble multiple penalized logistic regression models, which helps to stabilize the predictions and improve robustness. The model learns to distinguish between preictal (seizure-imminent) and interictal (between seizures) states based on the derived network features. The interpretability of the method is highlighted by the fact that the weights assigned to specific brain network edges indicate their importance in distinguishing between these states.

Datasets

The study evaluated its method on two datasets:

  • CHB-MIT: A well-known public dataset containing EEG recordings from 23 children with intractable seizures.
  • FH-PKU: A private database from Peking University First Hospital, containing EEG recordings from 17 patients.

The paper notes that the CHB-MIT dataset was used for comparison with a state-of-the-art method (STS-HGCN-AL), and that their method can handle all patients' data from this dataset, unlike the STS-HGCN-AL which has stricter data requirements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interpretability Matters: The paper strongly advocates for explainable models in clinical applications like seizure prediction, contrasting their approach with opaque deep learning methods.
  • Dynamic Connectivity is Key: The assumption that brain functional connectivity changes dynamically over time, rather than being static, is crucial for capturing preictal state changes.
  • Network Features Outperform Raw EEG: The study demonstrates that features derived from brain functional connectivity networks provide significantly more predictive information than raw EEG data alone.
  • Potential for Biomarker Identification: The method's ability to assign weights to specific brain connections suggests potential for identifying "connectome biomarkers" that could be indicative of epilepsy.

Key Results

The proposed method achieved strong performance on both datasets:

  • FH-PKU Dataset: AUC of 0.963, prediction sensitivity of 93.1%, and a false discovery rate of 7.7%.
  • CHB-MIT Dataset: AUC of 0.940, prediction sensitivity of 93.0%, and a false discovery rate of 11.1%.

These results outperformed existing state-of-the-art methods, particularly the STS-HGCN-AL on the CHB-MIT dataset, where the proposed method achieved a higher AUC (0.940 vs. 0.938) and was applicable to a larger subset of patients. The study also found that using raw EEG data alone yielded poor prediction results, and combining raw data with network features did not improve performance, suggesting that raw data might introduce noise.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and propose future research directions:

  • Normal Distribution Assumption: The current model assumes raw scalp EEG data follows a normal distribution, which may not hold true in real-world scenarios. Future work will explore methods to relax this assumption.
  • Fixed Time Window: The study used a fixed time window for defining the preictal state. Recognizing patient heterogeneity, future research will focus on estimating an optimal, patient-specific time window for the preictal state.
  • Biomarker Validation: While the method can identify potential connectome biomarkers, their actual impact on epilepsy has not been rigorously tested. Future work will involve hypothesis testing to demonstrate the efficiency and accuracy of these identified biomarkers.
  • Clinical Validation: The authors suggest that their method's interpretability and efficiency make it suitable for clinical application, but further validation in clinical settings is needed.

Summary updated

Abstract

We illustrated the results of our method in seizure prediction in two datasets separately. For the FH-PKU dataset, our approach achieved an AUC value of 0.963, a prediction sensitivity of 93.1%, and a false discovery rate of 7.7%. For the CHB-MIT dataset, our approach achieved an AUC value of 0.940, a prediction sensitivity of 93.0%, and a false discovery rate of 11.1%, outperforming existing state-of-the-art methods. <i>Significance</i>. This study proposed an explainable statistical method, which can estimate the brain network using the scalp EEG method and use the net-work predictor to predict epileptic seizures. <i>Availability and Implementation</i>. R Source code is available at https://github.com/HaoChen1994/Seizure-Prediction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2022explainable,
  author = {Hao Chen and Taoyun Ji and Xiang Zhan and Xiaoxin Liu and Guojing Yu and Wen Wang and Yuwu Jiang and Xiao‐Hua Zhou},
  title = {{An Explainable Statistical Method for Seizure Prediction Using Brain Functional Connectivity from EEG}},
  booktitle = {Computational},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1155/2022/2183562},
}
Figure