An Examination of Electronic Cigarette Content on Social Media: Analysis of E-Cigarette Flavor Content on Reddit

Lei Wang, Yongcheng Zhan, Qiudan Li, Daniel Zeng, Scott J. Leischow, Janet OkamotoInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study dives into Reddit discussions to understand e-cigarette flavor preferences, revealing that fruit flavors are the most popular, especially strawberry and vanilla, which are frequently mixed. The findings highlight Reddit's potential as a data source for tracking emerging trends and informing public health policy regarding e-cigarette marketing and use.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The e-cigarette market is rapidly expanding, and understanding consumer preferences, particularly regarding flavors, is crucial for public health and regulatory bodies. While flavors are known to be a key driver of e-cigarette appeal, especially for new users, there's a significant gap in systematically analyzing how these flavors are discussed and utilized by consumers. Traditional research methods are limited in capturing the dynamic and user-generated nature of consumer opinions. This paper addresses this by exploring Reddit, a massive social media platform, as a rich source of data to understand e-cigarette flavor trends, characteristics, and user behavior, which can inform regulatory decisions.

Methods

The researchers employed a data mining approach, collecting posts from Reddit related to e-cigarettes and flavors between January 2011 and June 2015. They identified relevant subreddits and used keyword searches and ranking strategies to gather a substantial dataset. The data underwent manual classification and analysis.

  • Data Collection: Posts were collected from 10 popular e-cigarette-related subreddits using keywords like "e-cigarette," "flavor," and "e-juice."
  • Data Cleaning: Posts containing noise (e.g., "apple watch" instead of apple flavor) were filtered out.
  • Flavor Classification: Two reviewers manually classified approximately 2200 posts, identifying 29 distinct flavors categorized into eight main groups: fruit, cream, tobacco, menthol, beverages, sweet, seasonings, and nuts. A kappa coefficient of 0.73 indicated substantial agreement between reviewers.
  • Popularity Analysis: The frequency of flavor mentions in posts was counted to determine popularity.
  • Mixing Analysis: Posts discussing mixed flavors were identified and analyzed to determine popular two- and three-flavor combinations.
  • Brand Analysis: Top e-liquid brands mentioned in posts were identified.
  • Temporal Trend Analysis: The number of posts discussing flavor categories over time was analyzed to identify trends.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 493,994 posts collected from Reddit between January 1, 2011, and June 30, 2015. After filtering, 27,638 unique e-cigarette flavor-related posts and 7,376 brand-related posts were used for analysis. The total frequency of flavor mentions across all posts was 45,130, with an average of 1.63 flavors per post.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reddit as a Data Goldmine: This study pioneers the use of Reddit for e-cigarette flavor research, demonstrating its potential for capturing authentic user-generated content and emerging trends, which is often more difficult to analyze than data from other platforms like Twitter.
  • Fruit Reigns Supreme: Fruit flavors are overwhelmingly the most popular category, aligning with previous research, suggesting their broad appeal due to their mild, sweet, and natural taste profiles.
  • The Art of Mixing: E-cigarette users actively engage in mixing flavors to create unique experiences. Fruit and cream categories are most frequently used in these blends, with strawberry and vanilla being the most popular individual flavors for mixing.
  • Rapid Market Growth Reflected Online: The sharp increase in discussions about e-cigarette flavors since 2014 mirrors the rapid growth and expansion of the e-cigarette market, indicating that social media platforms are key venues for consumer engagement and information sharing.
  • Brands on the Radar: Specific brands like Mt. Baker Vapor and Hangen are highly discussed, suggesting their popularity and effective marketing or product quality, making Reddit a valuable platform for both established and emerging brands.

Key Results

  • Most Popular Flavor Category: Fruit (15,720 posts), followed by Cream (10,289 posts) and Tobacco (7,475 posts). Nuts and Seasonings were least mentioned.
  • Most Popular Single Flavors: Strawberry (3,657 posts), Vanilla (3,036 posts), and Custard (2,664 posts).
  • Most Popular Mixed Flavors:
    • Two-flavor: Custard + Vanilla (259 posts), Strawberry + Vanilla (202 posts).
  • Three-flavor: Custard + Vanilla + Strawberry (99 posts), Strawberry + Vanilla + Banana (70 posts).
  • Temporal Trends: Discussion volume for all flavor categories increased significantly starting in 2014, with the fruit category showing the sharpest rise.
  • Top Brands: Mt. Baker Vapor (2,910 posts) and Hangen (662 posts) were the most discussed brands.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Keyword Limitations: The study acknowledges missing potentially valuable data by not including "vape" or "vaping" as initial keywords, though these terms were found to be widely used in the collected posts.
  • Limited Scope: Only major flavors were categorized, excluding less frequent ones like apple vinegar or absinthe, which might be relevant for specific populations (e.g., youth).
  • No Sentiment Analysis: The study focused on the prevalence of flavors, not the sentiment (positive/negative) of posts, meaning "hate strawberry" and "love strawberry" contributed equally to popularity.
  • No User Demographics: Age and gender information for Reddit users were unavailable, limiting the ability to define patterns related to e-cigarette adoption.
  • Posts vs. Comments: Posts and comments were treated similarly, omitting analysis of user interactions and network structures.

Future Work:

  • Health Risks of Flavors: Further research is needed to examine the potential health risks associated with specific flavor constituents, especially those used in mixing, as no medical testing is currently mandated.
  • Flavor Mixing Toxicology: Toxicological experiments are recommended to understand the potential health effects of new compounds created by mixing flavors.
  • Sentiment and Meaning Analysis: In-depth analysis of post sentiments could reveal more nuanced user preferences and perceptions of flavors.
  • Nicotine Strength Interaction: Investigating how different nicotine concentrations impact flavor perception and user experience is crucial.
  • Broader Social Media Analysis: Comparing Reddit data with other social media platforms is needed for a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Expanded Keyword Set: Future research should include a broader range of keywords to capture more comprehensive data.
  • Specific Population Analysis: Further analysis of less common flavors could reveal their use by specific demographics, such as youth.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, the emerging electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) marketplace has shown great development prospects all over the world. Reddit, one of the most popular forums in the world, has a very large user group and thus great influence. This study aims to gain a systematic understanding of e-cigarette flavors based on data collected from Reddit. Flavor popularity, mixing, characteristics, trends, and brands are analyzed. Fruit flavors were mentioned the most (n = 15,720) among all the posts and were among the most popular flavors (n = 2902) used in mixed blends. Strawberry and vanilla flavors were the most popular for e-juice mixing. The number of posts discussing e-cigarette flavors has increased sharply since 2014. Mt. Baker Vapor and Hangen were the most popular brands discussed among users. Information posted on Reddit about e-cigarette flavors reflected consumers' interest in a variety of flavors. Our findings suggest that Reddit could be used for data mining and analysis of e-cigarette-related content. Understanding how e-cigarette consumers' view and utilize flavors within their vaping experience and how producers and marketers use social media to promote flavors and sell products could provide valuable information for regulatory decision-makers.
BibTeX
@article{wang2015examination,
  author = {Lei Wang and Yongcheng Zhan and Qiudan Li and Daniel Zeng and Scott J. Leischow and Janet Okamoto},
  title = {{An Examination of Electronic Cigarette Content on Social Media: Analysis of E-Cigarette Flavor Content on Reddit}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph121114916},
}
Figure