An Evaluation of the Impact of Ecological Compensation on the Cross-Section Efficiency Using SFA and DEA: A Case Study of Xin’an River Basin

Junran Dong, Desheng WuSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates the effectiveness of ecological compensation programs in improving watershed environmental efficiency using the Xin'an River Basin as a case study. By combining Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA) and Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), the research provides a robust assessment of efficiency trends and identifies key factors influencing environmental performance, offering valuable insights for policy development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid industrial development in China has led to significant environmental degradation, particularly water pollution, which often transcends administrative boundaries. Watershed ecological compensation mechanisms have been implemented to address this issue by aligning economic development with environmental protection. However, there's a need for rigorous evaluation of these programs' effectiveness, specifically assessing their impact on watershed environmental efficiency. This paper tackles this by evaluating the environmental efficiency of the Xin'an River Basin, China's first transboundary watershed ecological compensation pilot, and identifying the factors that influence this efficiency.

Methods

The study employs a dual approach for evaluating environmental efficiency:

  • Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA): This parametric method uses econometric techniques to construct a production frontier, accounting for both statistical noise and technical inefficiency. It's used as the primary method for its ability to incorporate exogenous variables and handle statistical uncertainty.
  • Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA): This non-parametric method uses linear programming to identify efficient units based on input-output data. The study utilizes both the classic BCC model (variable returns to scale) and a super-efficiency BCC model to provide a more nuanced comparison and address potential issues with multiple efficient DMUs.

To handle the large number of input variables (21 pollutant emission factors) relative to the number of decision-making units (8 monitoring sites), Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used for dimensionality reduction, compressing the input variables into five principal components. Data was also normalized to ensure reliability and eliminate negative values.

Datasets

The study utilizes a panel dataset covering 8 monitoring sites in the Xin'an River Basin, Huangshan City, from 2011 to 2018. The data includes:

  • Output: Dissolved Oxygen (DO) as an indicator of water quality and self-purification ability.
  • Inputs: 21 pollutant emission factors (e.g., permanganate index, ammonia nitrogen, heavy metals, etc.) treated as inputs due to their negative impact on environmental efficiency. These were reduced to 5 principal components via PCA.
  • Macroeconomic Factors: GDP per capita, tertiary industry index, population density, capital investment in environmental protection, and annual precipitation were used to analyze influencing factors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SFA and DEA Complementarity: The study demonstrates that SFA and DEA, while different in approach, provide consistent results for evaluating watershed environmental efficiency, validating the chosen methodology.
  • Dynamic Efficiency Trends: Environmental efficiency in the Xin'an River Basin showed an initial upward trend, followed by fluctuations, indicating that ecological compensation is not a linear improvement process and requires ongoing monitoring and adaptation.
  • Pollutant Impact: Specific pollutants, notably total phosphorus, lead, fluoride, and selenium, were found to have a significant negative impact on environmental efficiency, highlighting the need for targeted reduction strategies.
  • Economic Development's U-Shaped Curve: The research supports the Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis, suggesting that while economic growth initially degrades the environment, it can lead to improvements beyond a certain threshold, especially with policy interventions.
  • Investment Threshold: Ecological compensation investment plays a positive role, but its effectiveness may be subject to a threshold, implying that "more is not always better" and careful management of funds is crucial.

Key Results

  • The SFA efficiency score ranged from 0.9747 (2011) to 0.999 (2016), showing an overall trend of initial improvement followed by fluctuations.
  • The reciprocal of the compensation index (RP) showed a strong correlation with SFA efficiency scores, serving as a reliable benchmark.
  • Regression analysis identified four significant pollutants (lead, total phosphorus, fluoride, selenium) negatively impacting environmental efficiency.
  • Five macro factors were analyzed, with GDP per capita, tertiary industry index, capital investment, and natural environment (precipitation) showing significant positive effects, while population density had a negative impact.
  • The study found that the ecological compensation investment fund had a positive correlation with SFA ES, but this relationship appeared to plateau or even decline beyond a certain investment level.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The authors acknowledge that for a more comprehensive understanding, future studies would benefit from more data.
  • Complexity of Factors: The study notes that the impact of influencing factors on environmental efficiency can vary under different circumstances, and more variables could be incorporated.
  • Monitoring and Policy: The paper suggests the need for continuous monitoring of payment activities and stricter assessment criteria for environmental quality.
  • Harmonious Development: Achieving a balance between ecological services and social development, and finding a "harmonious coexistence" through government leadership and legislation, is highlighted as a future challenge.
  • Further Research: Future studies are encouraged to be more precise and valuable by incorporating more data and exploring a wider range of variables and circumstances.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper aims to address the issue of evaluating watershed environmental efficiency with ecological compensation. One of the main objectives is the dynamic assessment of cross-section efficiency. The first transboundary watershed ecological compensation pilot of Xin’an river basin serves as the case study, and stochastic frontier analysis (SFA) is adopted as the main evaluation method. Furthermore, the efficiency is estimated by the data envelopment analysis (DEA) approach. The results validate that SFA can be used as an effective method on such issues by comparing it with the benchmark and the result of DEA, which proves the feasibility of our research methodology. The other purpose is to investigate the factors affecting environmental efficiency. This paper explores the relationship between environmental efficiency with 21 pollutant emission factors as well as the correlation between environmental efficiency and five macro factors of economic development, industrial structure, population density, degree of environmental protection, and natural environment. Finally, suggestions are provided for future improvement. This paper therefore presents a comprehensive reference analysis that contributes to facilitating balanced regional development and environmental conservation in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2020evaluation,
  author = {Junran Dong and Desheng Wu},
  title = {{An Evaluation of the Impact of Ecological Compensation on the Cross-Section Efficiency Using SFA and DEA: A Case Study of Xin’an River Basin}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12197966},
}
Figure