An Evaluation of the Data-Driven Model for Bubble Maximum Diameter in Subcooled Boiling Flow Using Artificial Neural Networks

Xiaomeng Dong, Haoxian Chen, Changwei Li, Ming–Hsuan Yang, Yang Yu, Xi HuangFrontiers in Energy Research 2022 · DOI

Abstract

In subcooled boiling flow under low-pressure conditions, the bubble characteristic diameter significantly influences the surface heat transfer coefficient. Traditional mechanistic models and empirical correlations often exhibit large errors across diverse experimental conditions. This paper proposes a data-driven model using artificial neural networks (ANN) to predict the bubble maximum diameter ($D_{max}$) and investigates the impact of various experimental conditions. Established and validated using six experimental databases, the ANN model achieves a relative error of approximately 14%. Uncertainty analysis identifies pressure as a highly sensitive parameter, particularly for bubbles larger than 0.5 mm. Based on these findings, a new correlation for coefficients $C$ and $\phi$ is proposed, which improves accuracy for large bubble datasets and maintains a low relative error in independent validations.

Introduction

In nuclear reactors, specifically Pressurized Water Reactors (PWRs), subcooled boiling occurs when bubbles form at the heated surface while the bulk liquid remains below its boiling point. Predicting the bubble maximum diameter ($D_{max}$) is essential for determining the surface heat transfer coefficient and preventing the "boiling crisis"—a state where heat transfer efficiency drops sharply, risking fuel cladding damage.

Sketch map of bubble characteristic sizes: (A) maximum diameter, (B) departure diameter, and (C) lift-off diameter.

Existing mechanistic models, which rely on physical heat balances, often struggle with accuracy, showing relative errors as high as 40% across different experimental setups. This research bridges that gap by employing a data-driven approach to enhance prediction reliability.

Methodology

The study utilizes a two-layer feed-forward Artificial Neural Network (ANN) optimized with a Back-Propagation (BP) algorithm and Bayesian regularization (trainbr). This optimization method is robust for smaller, noisy datasets as it prevents overfitting by minimizing a combination of squared errors and weights.

Input Parameters and Architecture

The model incorporates two hidden layers with eight neurons each. Input parameters include both raw experimental values (pressure, heat flux, mass flux) and non-dimensional numbers (Reynolds, Prandtl, Peclet, Eotvos, and Morton numbers) to capture complex fluid dynamics.

Hybrid Approach

Beyond the ANN, the researchers used sensitivity results from the network to refine traditional physics-based models. They proposed a new correlation for the coefficients $C$ and $\phi$, which represent pressure and fluid dynamic effects, respectively, replacing them with a unified $C\phi$ term driven by Peclet ($Pe$) and Eotvos ($Eo$) numbers.

Datasets and Validation

The model was trained and validated using six independent experimental databases (Prodanovic et al., Situ et al., Brooks et al., Ahmadi et al., Okawa et al., and Xu et al.), comprising 366 data points. These datasets primarily cover low-pressure and low-velocity conditions. An additional independent dataset (Kaiho et al., 2017) served as a final verification for the new mechanistic correlation.

Key Results and Insights

  • Superior Accuracy: The ANN model achieved a relative error of 13.54%, a significant improvement over traditional models like the Ünal model, which can exceed 100% error in some cases.
  • Pressure Sensitivity: Uncertainty analysis revealed that pressure is the most sensitive parameter for predicting bubble size, especially for bubbles exceeding 0.5 mm. Pressure fluctuations alter vapor density, directly impacting bubble volume.
  • Improved Physics: The new mechanistic correlation derived from ANN insights reduced the error for large bubbles (>1 mm) from 51.39% to 33.19%.
  • Robustness: When tested against the independent Kaiho dataset, the improved model maintained a low relative error of 14.43%, demonstrating its generalizability.

Conclusion

While the ANN model provides high accuracy, its "black box" nature limits its application to the range of experimental conditions it was trained on (low pressure and velocity). Future research will focus on expanding datasets to include higher pressure and mass velocity conditions and further refining hybrid, physics-informed machine learning models to enhance transparency and safety in nuclear applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the subcooled boiling flow under low-pressure conditions, bubble characteristic diameter is of great influence on the surface heat transfer coefficient. However, large errors are still found in calculations using traditional mechanistic models or empirical correlations, especially for wide experimental condition. In this paper, we propose a widely applicable data-driven model using artificial neural networks (ANN) to predict the bubble maximum diameter and investigate the effect of experimental conditions. After a series of analyses on structural parameters and input parameters, the ANN model is established and validated based on six available experimental databases. The result shows that the relative error is around 14%. Uncertainty analysis is carried out for the four experimental conditions and two structural conditions. The results show the measuring accuracy of pressure is one of the most sensitive parameters on the prediction of bubble maximum diameter in the subcooled boiling flow under 1.0 MPa, especially for the bubble sizes larger than 0.5 mm. According to the results of uncertainty analysis, a new correlation is proposed for coefficients C and φ, which are used to express the effect of pressure and fluid dynamic. The new correlation works well for all the experimental databases, and the error for bubble datasets of large size is also modified. Furthermore, another independent validation with a low relative error to 14% is provided to prove the accuracy of the new correlation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2022evaluation,
  author = {Xiaomeng Dong and Haoxian Chen and Changwei Li and Ming–Hsuan Yang and Yang Yu and Xi Huang},
  title = {{An Evaluation of the Data-Driven Model for Bubble Maximum Diameter in Subcooled Boiling Flow Using Artificial Neural Networks}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.903464},
}
Figure