An Evaluation of Approaches to Train Embeddings for Logical Inference (Student Abstract)

Yasir White, Jevon Lipsey, Jeff HeflinAAAI 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the inefficiency of traditional logic-based reasoning by proposing a novel method to train embedding models for logical statements. By focusing on learning "harder" examples and generating more diverse training data, their approach significantly reduces the search space required for inference, making logical reasoning more scalable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional logic-based inference systems, like backward chaining, can become incredibly slow and inefficient when dealing with large knowledge bases. This is because they often explore a vast number of potential reasoning paths, many of which are unproductive. While previous work has focused on improving the "scoring" of these paths or the "guided reasoner" itself, this paper argues that the core issue might lie in how the logical statements themselves are represented. They aim to improve the embedding model that translates logical statements into numerical vectors, hoping that better embeddings will lead to more efficient and accurate logical inference.

Methods

The authors build upon a neurosymbolic approach that combines a neural embedding model with a guided reasoner. Their core innovation lies in how they train the embedding model. Instead of relying on simple random generation of positive and negative examples for training, they introduce two key improvements:

  1. Enriched Data Generation: They increase the likelihood of generating "outlier" atoms (logical facts) that have significant semantics but might not appear frequently in random sampling. They also define specific "mutations" to generate more diverse and optimal training data, ensuring that variables are consistently substituted across an atom.
  2. Hard Sample Mining: They implement a two-step training process where, periodically, the model is retrained using only the training samples that resulted in the highest loss. This forces the model to focus on and learn from the most challenging logical relationships.

These improved embeddings are then used by a guided reasoner, which leverages a scoring model to direct the backward-chaining process.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly name standard benchmark datasets. Instead, they generate their own synthetic datasets for evaluation. They create sets of knowledge bases (KBs) with 250 and 375 statements, respectively, and for each size, they generate 5 synthetic KBs. They train their model on 100k triplets for the 250-statement KBs and 200k triplets for the 375-statement KBs. For evaluation, they generate 100 unique queries per KB, resulting in 500 queries for each KB size.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Representation Matters: The paper strongly suggests that the quality of the embedding model for logical statements is a critical bottleneck for efficient logical inference, even more so than just improving the scoring or guiding mechanisms.
  • "Hard" Examples Drive Learning: Focusing training on the most difficult logical relationships (those with the highest loss) is crucial for building a robust embedding model that can handle complex queries.
  • Controlled Data Generation is Key: Simply generating random logical statements for training is insufficient. Carefully crafting diverse and semantically rich training data, including "outlier" cases, leads to better model performance.
  • Scalability Potential: While currently limited to Datalog (a simpler form of logic), the underlying principles of improving embeddings have the potential to scale to more expressive first-order logic languages.

Key Results

The paper reports significant improvements in the efficiency of logical inference. Their "New Embeddings" approach, when compared to a standard backward-chaining reasoner and a previous unification approach, drastically reduces the number of nodes explored during query answering.

  • For a KB size of 250 statements, their method explored an average of 90.4 nodes, compared to 17,204.0 for the standard reasoner and 224.0 for the previous unification method.
  • For a KB size of 375 statements, their method explored an average of 33,280.0 nodes, compared to 167,297.8 for the standard reasoner and 207,489.7 for the previous unification method.

These results show improvements ranging from a 5x to 188x reduction in nodes explored compared to baselines without learning, and a 2x to 6x improvement over their prior embedding approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Expressivity: The current work is restricted to Datalog, which is function-free Horn logic. The authors acknowledge that extending these ideas to more expressive first-order languages is a significant future direction.
  • Synthetic Data: The evaluation relies on synthetic knowledge bases and queries. Future work should focus on testing these improvements on larger and more realistic knowledge bases to demonstrate their impact on real-world inference performance.
  • Further Optimization: While the results are promising, there's always room for further optimization of the embedding model and the guided reasoning process.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{white2025evaluation,
  author = {Yasir White and Jevon Lipsey and Jeff Heflin},
  title = {{An Evaluation of Approaches to Train Embeddings for Logical Inference (Student Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v39i28.35313},
}
Figure