An Evaluation Agent System for Enhancing Wikipedia Management

Chun Fu Lin, Yu Chu Yeh, Yu Hsin Hung, Ray-I ChangInternational Journal of Computer Trends and Technology 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Evaluation Agent System (EAS), an intelligent system built on Web 3.0 principles, to address the growing management challenges faced by Wikipedia administrators. The EAS, particularly its Rule-Based Expert System (RBES) component, significantly improves accuracy, efficiency, and user convenience compared to traditional manual methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wikipedia's explosive growth in content and editing has created significant management hurdles for its volunteer administrators. The sheer volume of edits, potential guideline violations, and the need for real-time information processing overwhelm manual approaches. Existing Web 2.0 platforms like MediaWiki, while convenient for users, lack sophisticated tools to automatically manage these complexities, leading to time-consuming, error-prone, and inefficient administrative tasks. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an intelligent agent system that leverages Web 3.0 capabilities to enhance Wikipedia management.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is the Evaluation Agent System (EAS), built upon Web 3.0 principles. The EAS comprises three main components:

  • Testing Agent: Likely used for evaluating the system's performance.
  • Wiki Agent: Interacts with the traditional Wiki management system.
  • Rule-Based Expert System (RBES) Agent: This is the central component. It integrates hybrid Web techniques (like XML, XSL) and artificial intelligence (AI). The RBES is designed to:
  • Incorporate administrators' management guidelines and knowledge from users and experts.
  • Emphasize accuracy, efficiency, and collaborative knowledge creation.
  • Address common KMS problems like bot approvals, article disputes, and anonymous editing through automated suggestions and rule-based evaluations.
  • Utilize a logic editor and Web robot for automated tasks.
  • Support cross-platform data transfer and real-time information retrieval.

The RBES itself is built using the CLIPS (C Language Integrated Production System) tool, known for its rule-based programming capabilities and portability. The system processes administrative tasks, sets goals, acquires knowledge, and uses a logic editor to determine procedures, ultimately providing advice and detecting exceptional events.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used 29 university students as participants for experimental tasks and questionnaires.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Web 3.0 as a Solution for Web 2.0 Challenges: The paper effectively argues that Web 3.0's advancements in AI, semantic web technologies, and intelligent agents are crucial for overcoming the inherent limitations of Web 2.0 platforms like Wikipedia.
  • RBES as the Core of Intelligent Management: The RBES is highlighted as the key to intelligent Wikipedia management, capable of processing complex rules, integrating diverse knowledge sources, and providing actionable insights.
  • Addressing Specific Wikipedia Pain Points: The EAS is designed to tackle concrete issues such as bot approvals, article quality evaluation, and managing anonymous edits, demonstrating a practical application of AI.
  • User-Centric Design: The system aims to improve not only administrative efficiency but also user convenience and the overall quality of knowledge on the platform.

Key Results

The study evaluated the EAS, specifically the RBES, against the conventional manual approach using 29 university students. The findings were overwhelmingly positive:

  • Accuracy: The RBES approach achieved 100% accuracy in inference tasks, significantly outperforming the conventional approach (84%). This difference was statistically significant (p = .000).
  • Performance Efficiency: The average performance time for the RBES was a mere 1.92 seconds, compared to 332.38 seconds for the conventional approach. This represents a massive speedup and is statistically significant (p = .000).
  • Operation Convenience: Participants reported high satisfaction with the RBES's human-machine interface, rating it significantly higher than the conventional interface (mean of 4.45 on a 5-point scale, p = .000).
  • Fatigue Strength: While not explicitly quantified with numbers, the paper implies that the RBES reduces administrator fatigue due to its automated nature.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Participant Pool: The study involved only 29 university students, which may not fully represent the diverse user base and administrator experience of Wikipedia.
  • Simulated Environment: The experimental tasks were simulated, and real-world deployment might reveal different challenges.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests further investigation into the EAS's effectiveness through real-world case studies and computer simulations, implying a need for broader validation and refinement. The integration of more advanced AI techniques and a deeper exploration of cross-platform data transfer capabilities could also be future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wikipedia has recently become a popular platform for knowledge sharing and creation. However, the enormously increasing amount of editing has caused management problems with efficiency, accuracy, and convenience for Wikipedia administrators. This study, therefore, aimed to develop an intelligent agent system based on Web 3.0, the evaluation agent system (EAS), to solve these problems. The EAS is characterized by hybrid Web techniques, artificial intelligence, integration of management guidelines, retrieval of real-time information, and the transfer of cross-platform data and includes the following three systems: the testing agent, the wiki agent, and the rule-based expert system (RBES) agent. Because the RBES was central to the EAS, 29 university students were included in the study to examine the effectiveness of the RBES compared to the conventional approach to administration. The findings revealed that the RBES was better than the conventional approach in accuracy, efficiency, operation convenience, and fatigue strength.
BibTeX
@article{lin2014evaluation,
  author = {Chun Fu Lin and Yu Chu Yeh and Yu Hsin Hung and Ray-I Chang},
  title = {{An Evaluation Agent System for Enhancing Wikipedia Management}},
  journal = {International Journal of Computer Trends and Technology},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.14445/22312803/ijctt-v10p115},
}
Figure