An Equivalent Damping Numerical Prediction Method for the Ring Damper Used in Gears under Axial Vibration

Shuai Wang, Xiaolei Wang, Yanrong Wang, Hang YeSymmetry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel numerical method to predict the damping effect of ring dampers in gears under axial vibration. By modeling friction-induced damping as an equivalent structural damping, the method significantly reduces computation time and allows for efficient analysis of how ring damper parameters influence vibration reduction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aircraft gas turbine engines rely on lightweight, thin-walled gears that are susceptible to high vibration loads, especially during resonance. While ring dampers are effective passive devices for mitigating these vibrations through friction energy dissipation, accurately predicting their performance, particularly under axial vibration (which is more critical for thin-walled gears), is challenging. Existing methods often involve complex nonlinear analyses that are computationally expensive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an efficient numerical prediction method for ring damper performance under axial vibration.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of an "equivalent damping numerical prediction method." The authors start by formulating the vibration equation of a gear-ring damper system, incorporating nonlinear friction forces as equivalent damping and stiffness terms. They then utilize a modal superposition approach to simplify the system's equations of motion.

A key innovation is the modeling of friction energy dissipation using a "flat plate-slider system" as a fundamental unit. This model captures the viscous-sliding behavior of the damper interface. The authors analyze the motion states (viscous, sliding, and full sliding) and derive equations for energy dissipation based on parameters like normalized frictional force and amplitude. This friction energy dissipation model is then extended to the context of axial vibration in a gear-ring damper system. The method allows for the prediction of equivalent damping ratios and the analysis of how parameters like ring damper mass and friction coefficient affect damping performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and numerical simulations based on material properties and gear geometry.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Axial Vibration is Critical: Thin-walled gears are more prone to resonance failure under axial vibration due to their lower axial stiffness compared to radial stiffness.
  • Friction is the Key: The primary mechanism for vibration reduction by ring dampers is friction energy dissipation at the interface between the gear and the damper.
  • Equivalent Damping Simplification: Modeling nonlinear friction as an equivalent linear damping term significantly simplifies the analysis and reduces computational cost, making it practical for design optimization.
  • Viscous-Sliding Dynamics: The interaction between the gear and the ring damper can exhibit complex viscous-sliding behavior, which is crucial to capture for accurate damping prediction.
  • Optimal Parameters Exist: There are optimal values for the ring damper's mass and friction coefficient that maximize energy dissipation and thus damping effectiveness.

Key Results

  • The proposed equivalent damping method significantly shortens calculation time compared to traditional nonlinear forced response analysis.
  • The friction coefficient and mass of the ring damper have a substantial influence on damping performance.
  • For axial vibration, the ring damper's mass is positively correlated with the equivalent damping ratio, especially when the damper mass is much smaller than the gear mass.
  • An optimal normalized frictional force (around 0.45) exists for maximizing energy dissipation in the flat plate-slider model.
  • The optimal amplitude for maximizing equivalent damping in the ring damper-gear model under axial vibration is approximately 2.74 times the critical amplitude.
  • The critical vibration load for the ring damper to engage is essential; below this load, the damper is stuck and provides no damping.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The paper acknowledges that the ring damper mass is generally much smaller than the gear mass, and the effect of the ring damper on the gear's resonant frequency is negligible. This simplification might limit applicability in scenarios where these assumptions are not met.
  • Material Properties: The study uses typical material properties for steel. The influence of different materials or temperature variations on damping performance is not explored.
  • Experimental Validation: While the paper presents numerical results, direct experimental validation of the proposed method is not detailed.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the influence of ring damper structural parameters and the application of this method to more complex gear systems. Exploring the impact of manufacturing tolerances and wear on damping performance could also be valuable future directions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{wang2019equivalent,
  author = {Shuai Wang and Xiaolei Wang and Yanrong Wang and Hang Ye},
  title = {{An Equivalent Damping Numerical Prediction Method for the Ring Damper Used in Gears under Axial Vibration}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/sym11121469},
}

Loading related content...

Figure