TL;DR
This paper introduces a neural encoder-decoder model for predicting causal relationships between events in stories, a task crucial for commonsense reasoning. While their best model achieved 66.2% accuracy on the COPA benchmark, falling short of the state-of-the-art, they demonstrate the significant impact of dataset characteristics, particularly the density of commonsense knowledge, and lay the groundwork for future neural approaches to this problem.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding stories requires more than just recognizing characters and plot points; it necessitates inferring the underlying causal connections between events. This "commonsense reasoning" is vital for natural language understanding. While tasks like the Story Cloze Test and the Choice of Plausible Alternatives (COPA) have been developed to evaluate this capability, existing approaches have largely relied on lexical co-occurrence statistics. The authors aim to bridge this gap by exploring the application of modern neural network architectures, specifically encoder-decoders, to the COPA task, which focuses on identifying cause-effect relationships.
Methods
The core of this research is a neural encoder-decoder model adapted for predicting causal relations. The authors experimented with two main encoder-decoder architectures:
- Feed-Forward Network (FFN): This model treats input segments as bag-of-words vectors, ignoring word order. It processes all words in parallel.
- Recurrent Neural Network (RNN): This model uses Gated Recurrent Units (GRUs) to iteratively encode the input sequence, capturing word order and sequential dependencies.
The model is trained to predict the probability that a second sequence (S2) will follow a first sequence (S1), implicitly assuming S1 is the cause and S2 is the effect. They also explored different methods for:
- Sequence Segmentation: Using either sentence boundaries or clausal boundaries (identified via dependency parsing) to define input segments.
- Temporal Window (N): Pairing segments within a certain distance (N) of each other in the story.
- Input Representations: Comparing standard bag-of-words with pre-trained word embeddings like GloVe, ConceptNet, and skip-thought vectors.
Datasets
- ROCStories Corpus: This is the primary dataset used for training and evaluation. It consists of 97,027 five-sentence narratives authored via crowdsourcing, specifically designed to minimize discourse complexity and explicate prototypical causal and temporal relations. The authors highlight its density of commonsense knowledge as a key factor.
- COPA (Choice of Plausible Alternatives): This is the benchmark dataset for evaluating causal relation prediction. It comprises 1,000 items, each with a premise and two alternatives, requiring the model to choose the more plausible cause or effect.
- Other Datasets (for broader evaluation):
- Visual Storytelling (VIST)
- CNN/DailyMail corpus
- CMU Book/Movie Plot Summaries (CMU Plots)
- BookCorpus
- Blog Stories (used in prior work)
- ClueWeb Pairs (used in prior work)
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dataset Density Matters More Than Size: The ROCStories corpus, despite being significantly smaller than web corpora used in prior work, yielded the best performance for their model. This suggests that the density of relevant commonsense knowledge is more critical than sheer data volume.
- Encoder-Decoder Architecture Shows Promise: This paper is the first to apply an encoder-decoder model to COPA, demonstrating its potential for directly modeling cause-effect sequence pairs, a novel approach compared to word-level co-occurrence.
- FFN Outperforms RNN for This Task: Surprisingly, the simpler FFN model, which ignores word order, performed better than the RNN model. This indicates that for this specific task and dataset, explicit sequential modeling might not be as crucial as capturing the overall semantic content of the segments.
- Clause Segmentation Can Be Beneficial: While the difference was marginal, clause segmentation (N=4) achieved the highest accuracy for the FFN model, suggesting that finer-grained narrative units can be more informative.
- Pre-trained Embeddings Don't Always Help: Contrary to expectations, using pre-trained word embeddings (GloVe, ConceptNet, skip-thought) did not consistently improve performance over the basic bag-of-words representation for the FFN model.
Key Results
- The best-performing model, an FFN encoder-decoder trained on the ROCStories corpus with clause segmentation and a temporal window of N=4, achieved 66.2% accuracy on the COPA test set.
- This result, while lower than the state-of-the-art of 71.2% (achieved by lexical methods on larger datasets), establishes a new reference point for neural approaches to COPA.
- When applied to other datasets, the FFN encoder-decoder's accuracy dropped significantly, with none reaching the performance of ROCStories-Full. For example, ClueWeb Pairs, despite having 100 times more data, yielded only 61.2% accuracy.
- The PMI and CausalNet approaches, when trained on ROCStories, achieved lower accuracies (62.4% and 51.8%, respectively) than the FFN encoder-decoder, highlighting the effectiveness of the neural approach on this specific dataset.
Limitations and Future Work
- Performance Gap: The authors acknowledge that their 66.2% accuracy falls short of the 71.2% state-of-the-art. They attribute this partly to the massive data advantage of existing methods.
- Dataset Dependency: The model's strong reliance on the ROCStories corpus suggests a need for methods that can generalize better to diverse narrative styles and less curated datasets.
- Implicit Causality: The CausalNet approach's poor performance on ROCStories highlights that many causal relations are conveyed implicitly, not through explicit lexical markers, which their model aims to capture.
- Distinguishing Causality from Temporal Relation: The authors note that their model treats all temporally related pairs as potentially causal, which might include non-causal relationships and thus dilute the signal. Future work could focus on automatically detecting latent linguistic features that specifically indicate causality.
- Scalability of ROCStories: While beneficial, the ROCStories corpus is a curated resource and may not scale as readily as web corpora. Future research might explore how to leverage the density of commonsense knowledge from such datasets more effectively.
Summary updated