TL;DR
This paper evaluates the effectiveness of China’s interest rate corridor (IRC) in stabilizing short-term market volatility. By applying an EGARCH-M model to over a decade of interbank rate data, the authors demonstrate that the implementation of the corridor has successfully dampened interest rate fluctuations and tightened the range of market volatility, despite external shocks like the COVID-19 pandemic.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Historically, China relied on quantitative monetary policy (managing the money supply). However, as the market economy matured, this approach became less effective. Since 2014, the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) has transitioned toward a price-based regulation model, using an interest rate corridor.
An interest rate corridor sets a "ceiling" (the Standing Lending Facility or SLF rate) and a "floor" (the legal deposit reserve ratio) to keep short-term market rates within a predictable range. The central question this paper tackles is: Has this corridor actually worked? Specifically, does it effectively reduce the "noise" and violent swings in short-term rates like the Shanghai Interbank Offered Rate (Shibor)?
Methods
The authors employ an EGARCH-M (Exponential GARCH-in-mean) model. This is a sophisticated econometric tool chosen for two specific reasons:
- Volatility Aggregation: Financial data often sees "clusters" of high or low volatility; the GARCH framework accounts for this.
- Asymmetry: Market volatility often reacts differently to "good news" versus "bad news." The "Exponential" (E) part of the model captures these asymmetric effects.
- Risk-Return Link: The "-M" (in-mean) component allows the authors to test if the level of the interest rate itself is affected by its own volatility.
The study divides the data into three distinct stages to compare the pre-corridor era (2010–2013) with the early implementation (2014–2018) and the recent "perfection" phase (2019–2021).
Datasets
The study utilizes high-frequency daily data from January 1, 2010, to April 30, 2021, sourced from Wind and the official PBOC website. The primary variables are:
- Overnight Shibor (SHR01): The benchmark for the Chinese interbank market.
- Overnight Chibor (CHR01): The China Interbank Offered Rate.
- Corridor Bounds: Data on the Overnight SLF rate (upper limit) and the legal deposit reserve ratio (lower limit).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Tightening" Effect: Before 2014, Shibor fluctuated violently (with a range of over 12 percentage points). After the corridor was introduced, this range narrowed significantly to roughly 2.6 percentage points, indicating the PBOC successfully "caged" the interest rate.
- Asymmetric Responses: The model revealed that the interbank rates are asymmetric. Volatility responds differently to past positive disturbances versus negative ones, and this relationship shifted across the three stages of the study.
- Volatility as a Driver of Rates: The "in-mean" results suggest that when interest rate volatility intensifies, the actual level of the interest rate tends to rise, highlighting the "risk premium" inherent in the interbank lending market.
- Resilience Against Shocks: While volatility increased slightly in Stage III (2019–2021), the authors attribute this to external pressures—specifically the COVID-19 pandemic and increased economic downward pressure—rather than a failure of the corridor itself.
Key Results
The quantitative findings strongly support the IRC's effectiveness:
- Mean Rate Reduction: The mean level of the overnight Shibor dropped from 2.781% in Stage I to 1.890% in Stage III.
- Standard Deviation Drop: The standard deviation (a primary measure of volatility) for Shibor plummeted from 1.243 in the pre-corridor stage to 0.565 in the most recent stage.
- Range Compression: The maximum-minimum spread of Shibor volatility fell from 3.241 in Stage I to just 0.321 in Stage III.
- Model Fit: The adjusted $R^2$ for the models exceeded 80%, indicating high explanatory power for the chosen variables.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that while the Chinese interest rate corridor is functional, it is "not perfect." * Width Issues: Compared to developed economies, China’s interest rate corridor is relatively wide (remaining around 265 basis points in recent years). A wider corridor allows for more market-driven fluctuation but provides less "tight" control than a narrower one. * Boundary Breaches: The paper notes that since June 2018, Shibor has occasionally "broken through" the limits of the corridor, suggesting that the intervention mechanisms are not yet absolute. * Future Directions: The study suggests that further research is needed to determine the "optimal width" for the Chinese market to balance market freedom with price stability.
Summary updated