An Empirical Study of Situational Teaching: Agricultural Location in High School Geography

Fengtao Guo, Yushan Duan, Shanbo He, Qi Zhang, Qiangqiang Xu, Sheng MiaoSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of "One Situation to the End" (OSTE) situational teaching in high school geography, specifically for agricultural location. OSTE shows promise in fostering students' awareness of sustainable and circular development and improving higher-order thinking, though it doesn't directly enhance geographical skills.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's recent curriculum reforms emphasize developing "core competencies" in geography, including understanding the relationship between humans and the environment, and promoting sustainable development. Traditional geography teaching often presents knowledge in a fragmented, abstract manner, making it difficult for students to connect concepts to real-life situations and develop a holistic understanding of sustainable development. The paper addresses the need for more engaging and effective teaching methods that can cultivate these competencies, particularly in the context of complex topics like agricultural location, which inherently involves economic, social, and environmental considerations.

Methods

The study employed a mixed-methods approach:

  • Literature Review: A comprehensive review of existing research on situational teaching, OSTE, and geography education in China was conducted.
  • Teacher Survey: A questionnaire was distributed to 90 geography teachers in a southern Chinese city to understand the current status of situational teaching and OSTE implementation.
  • Quasi-Experiment: A quasi-experimental design was used with two parallel classes in a model high school. One class (experimental group) was taught agricultural location using the OSTE method, while the other (control group) received traditional instruction.
  • Student Questionnaire: A Likert-scale questionnaire, based on Bloom's Taxonomy, was administered to students to assess their perceptions of learning outcomes related to knowledge, higher-order thinking, willingness, and affection.
  • Pre- and Post-Tests: Standardized tests were administered before and after the intervention to measure students' academic achievement in agricultural location and circular development. Statistical analyses, including independent samples t-tests and Mann-Whitney U tests, were used to compare the groups.

Datasets

Not applicable. This study focuses on educational methods and student learning outcomes, not on training or evaluating models on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OSTE is Widely Adopted: The survey revealed that nearly all geography teachers in the studied city use some form of situational teaching, with OSTE being a prevalent method.
  • Sustainable Development Focus: OSTE appears to be particularly effective in cultivating students' awareness of sustainable and circular development, aligning with national educational goals.
  • Higher-Order Thinking Boost: Students in the OSTE group showed significant improvements in higher-order thinking skills, indicating that the method encourages deeper cognitive engagement.
  • Engagement and Systemic Knowledge: Students reported a strong preference for OSTE due to its promotion of positive emotional experiences, active learning, and the acquisition of systematic, rather than fragmented, knowledge.
  • Geographical Skills Gap: Interestingly, OSTE did not show a significant improvement in students' geographical skills, suggesting a potential area for refinement.
  • Teacher Challenges: Teachers face challenges in implementing situational teaching, including limited class hours, heavy workloads, and the difficulty of creating engaging, relevant situations.

Key Results

  • Academic Improvement: The experimental group (OSTE) showed a statistically significant improvement in post-test scores compared to the control group (traditional teaching) in agricultural location knowledge (p = 0.001).
  • Circular Development: While both groups met general geography standards, the OSTE group demonstrated a significantly better understanding of circular agriculture concepts (p = 0.000 for questions 3, 4, and 5).
  • Cognitive and Affective Goals: The OSTE method led to significantly better achievement in both knowledge-based and affective objectives compared to traditional teaching (p = 0.001, Cohen's d = 2.66).
  • Higher-Order Thinking Impact: The largest effect size was observed in higher-order thinking (Cohen's d = 2.41), indicating OSTE's strong influence in this area.
  • Student Recognition: Students most valued OSTE for fostering positive emotions, active learning, and systematic knowledge acquisition.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Situation Relevance: Many situations used by teachers were domestic and not directly related to students' lives, potentially due to the local economy's limited agricultural sector.
  • Hands-on Activities: Situational teaching often relied on case studies, with a scarcity of hands-on activities or geo-experiments.
  • Question Chain Design: There was a lack of consensus among teachers on how to effectively design question chains within OSTE.
  • Teacher Burden: Limited teaching hours and heavy workloads are significant barriers for teachers in creating OSTE materials.
  • Sample Size and Content: The study's findings are based on a specific agricultural location topic and a limited sample size.

Future research should focus on:

  • Enriching OSTE Understanding: Further teacher training and professional development are needed to deepen the understanding and application of OSTE.
  • Jointly Developed Situations: Encouraging schools to collaboratively develop teaching situations, leveraging students' existing experiences, could enhance relevance.
  • Well-Designed Question Chains: Creating more interactive and logically sequenced question chains is crucial for maximizing OSTE's impact.
  • Longer Experiments and Larger Samples: Future studies should employ longer experimental durations and larger, more diverse student populations to further validate OSTE's effectiveness across different contexts and topics.

Summary updated

Abstract

In China’s most recent round of curriculum reform, the “one situation to the end” (OSTE) situational teaching method has been successfully introduced in geography classes to improve students’ ability to solve problems in real-life situations. Taking an agricultural location course as an example, this study analyzes the implementation of situational teaching and discusses the effect of the OSTE method on the topic of sustainable development in the teaching of geography. Using a quasi-experimental design and by distributing a questionnaire to teachers in a Chinese high school, the following findings were obtained: (1) almost all teachers use some form of situational teaching, and the OSTE method has been widely used; (2) OSTE contributes to students’ awareness of sustainable and circular development, but it is not associated with an improvement in geographical skills; and (3) students are mostly interested in the promotion of higher-order thinking, a positive emotional experience, active learning, and the acquisition of systematic knowledge instead of fragmented knowledge. In short, OSTE is an efficient teaching method for geography classes, especially given how it fosters students’ sustainable development ideas. We suggest enriching the understanding of OSTE through teaching-training, jointly developed situations using students’ existing experiences, and well-designed question chains with more opportunities for interaction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2022empirical,
  author = {Fengtao Guo and Yushan Duan and Shanbo He and Qi Zhang and Qiangqiang Xu and Sheng Miao},
  title = {{An Empirical Study of Situational Teaching: Agricultural Location in High School Geography}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14148676},
}
Figure