An Empirical Analysis of Social Interaction in Online Teaching in Open Universities Based on Flipped Classroom

Xinjie Wang, Ding YuanComputational 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of the "flipped classroom" model for online teaching in open universities. By comparing a flipped classroom approach with traditional online teaching, researchers found that the flipped model significantly enhances students' cognitive processing, knowledge construction, and collaborative learning, leading to more complex knowledge networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional online education in open universities, particularly for adult learners, often struggles with fostering active engagement and deep learning. While these institutions leverage technology for distance learning, desired student behaviors like active collaboration, focused exploration, and in-depth communication are frequently absent. This leads to a deadlock in interaction sessions and hinders the overall quality of online education. The paper aims to address this by exploring how the flipped classroom model, which shifts learning from passive reception to active engagement, can improve social interaction and learning outcomes in this specific context.

Methods

The study employed an equal group experiment method to compare two teaching models: a flipped classroom approach and a conventional online teaching approach.

  • Flipped Classroom Design: This model involved a three-phase process:
  • Self-directed basic learning: Students acquire superficial knowledge through online resources (videos, texts) and complete online tests.
  • Exploratory in-depth learning: A synchronous online session (via "Tencent Meeting") where students engage in heuristic dialogue, collaborative problem-solving, and explore "why" and "how" aspects of the learning topic.
  • Reflective enhanced learning: Asynchronous forum discussions where students apply their knowledge to case studies, analyze problems, and propose solutions.
  • Conventional Online Teaching: This approach involved a more traditional sequence of learning tasks, with less emphasis on structured in-depth exploration and collaborative activities.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Content Analysis Method: Used to qualitatively analyze the depth of student-student interaction texts in forum discussions, assessing cognitive processing behaviors (e.g., memorization, comprehension, application, analysis, evaluation, creation) and knowledge construction levels (based on Gunawardena's model).
  • Social Network Analysis (SNA): Employed to measure the density and complexity of student interaction networks, visualizing the patterns of communication and collaboration. Tools like SPSS, NVivo, and UCINET were utilized.

Datasets

The study was conducted with 77 working adult students enrolled in the "Kindergarten Management" course at Beijing Open University. The students were randomly divided into an experimental group (39 students) using the flipped classroom model and a control group (38 students) using the conventional online teaching model. The data was collected from their forum discussions over a six-week period. No new datasets were introduced; existing course materials and online platforms were utilized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Passive Learning: The flipped classroom model effectively moves adult learners beyond passive information consumption towards active knowledge construction and application.
  • Structured Engagement: The three-phase approach (self-directed, exploratory, reflective) provides a scaffold for developing higher-order thinking skills, which are often underdeveloped in traditional online settings.
  • Social Interaction as a Catalyst: The emphasis on peer-to-peer interaction, discussion, and collaborative problem-solving in the flipped model is crucial for deeper learning and knowledge integration.
  • Networked Knowledge: The formation of more complex and interconnected knowledge networks in the flipped classroom group suggests a more robust and collaborative learning environment.

Key Results

  • Cognitive Processing: The experimental group (flipped classroom) showed a statistically significant higher level of cognitive processing capacity (mean 3.5385) compared to the control group (mean 2.2105), with a p-value of 0.000. This indicates students engaged more with application, analysis, and evaluation rather than just memorization and comprehension.
  • Knowledge Construction: Students in the flipped classroom group demonstrated a significantly higher level of knowledge construction (mean 3.0256) than the control group (mean 1.7059), with a p-value of 0.000. This suggests improved ability to share, discuss, and build upon each other's ideas.
  • Knowledge Network Patterns: The flipped classroom group exhibited a significantly higher network density (0.2744) and reciprocity (21.3%) compared to the control group (0.1066 and 6.59% respectively). This indicates more complex and two-way interactions, leading to more intricate knowledge networks.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Immature Model Design: The flipped classroom model is still developing, and the study's scope was limited to two weeks of course learning with a small number of forum activities. Future large-scale, long-term validation is needed.
  • Sample Representativeness: The study focused on adult students majoring in preschool education. Further research is required to determine if these findings generalize to students in other majors.
  • Teacher's Role: While the study focused on student interaction, the influence and specific role of teachers in facilitating flipped classroom interactions were not deeply explored.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Further exploring the cognitive characteristics of students in flipped classrooms, examining objectives and outcomes.
  • Investigating the influence and role of teachers in flipped classroom settings and how interactive teaching activities are conducted.
  • Examining interaction behaviors and quality among different learner types and conducting empirical studies from a social division of labor perspective.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a teaching model, flipped classroom can stimulate students' learning interests and promote students' positive social interactions. As an adult university relying on information technology to carry out online teaching, open universities need to pay attention to the online learning quality of adult students. This study attempts to apply the concept of flipped classroom to online teaching in open universities. While exploring the feasibility of the online flipped classroom teaching model, it adopts an equal group experiment method, content analysis method, and social network analysis method to compare the social interaction level difference between online teaching based on flipped classroom and conventional online teaching. The results show that online flipped classroom has a positive and significant impact on student's cognitive processing level and knowledge construction level and can promote groups to form complex knowledge network forms. This shows that network teaching based on flipped classroom can exercise students' high-order thinking ability, enhance students' cooperative consciousness and behavior, and stimulate students' subjectivity in learning. The purpose of this study is to provide references for promoting interactive behavior and quality in online teaching.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022empirical,
  author = {Xinjie Wang and Ding Yuan},
  title = {{An Empirical Analysis of Social Interaction in Online Teaching in Open Universities Based on Flipped Classroom}},
  booktitle = {Computational},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1155/2022/3089239},
}
Figure