An Ecological Compensation Model for Liuxi River Basin Based on Emission Rights

Bole Pan, Haoxuan Tan, Bojun Mao, Yixian Shen, Zhuoyuan Lu, Yongzhang Pan, Wei ZuoJournal of Management and Sustainability 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Establishing fair ecological compensation standards is critical for balancing environmental protection with sustainable economic development. This study proposes a quantitative model for the Liuxi River Basin in Guangzhou, China, by framing wastewater emission rights as a proxy for development rights. By analyzing 13 years of economic and environmental data, we determined that the upstream Conghua District is owed approximately 33.821 billion CNY (as of 2017) for the industrial development sacrificed to maintain regional water quality.

The "Ecological Trap" in River Basins

In many river basins, an inherent conflict exists between upstream and downstream regions. Upstream areas, often referred to as "water towers," are frequently restricted from heavy industrial development to protect water quality for more populous, wealthier downstream cities. This creates an "ecological trap": the upstream region remains underdeveloped while the downstream region enjoys environmental benefits without direct cost.

While the concept of ecological compensation aims to rectify this imbalance, existing models often lack a standardized calculation method. This research treats emission rights as a tangible economic asset. If an upstream region emits less than its "fair share" based on its economic level, it has effectively "sold" its right to develop to the environment, necessitating payment from downstream beneficiaries.

Study Area: The Liuxi River Basin

The Liuxi River is a vital water source for Guangzhou. The basin encompasses several districts with varying levels of development, including the upstream Conghua District and downstream areas like Huadu and the main Guangzhou city center.

Map of the Liuxi River Basin showing sampling points, wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), and administrative districts.

Methodology

The researchers developed a four-step modeling approach using data from the Guangzhou Statistical Information Network (1995, 2000, and 2005–2015):

  1. Regression Analysis: Using SPSS, they analyzed the functional relationship between GDP per capita ($Gr$) and wastewater discharge per capita ($Pr$).
  2. Model Selection: Eight models were tested. A linear model provided the best fit (Adjusted $R^2 = 0.763$), resulting in the equation: $Pr = 0.000478 \times Gr + 127.81$.
  3. Theoretical vs. Actual Emissions: The model calculates how much wastewater a region should typically discharge given its GDP. The difference between this theoretical amount and the actual (lower) recorded amount defines the lost emission rights.
  4. Pricing and Calculation: Using the Recovery Cost Method, a price of 477.53 Yuan per ton was applied (based on regional pollution control costs). Total compensation ($Mec$) is the product of lost emission rights and this unit price.
Scatter plot illustrating the relationship between GDP per capita and the volume of wastewater discharged per capita in Guangzhou.

Key Insights: Pollution as a Proxy for Development

The core innovation of this model is the philosophical stance that the right to pollute is synonymous with the right to develop. By restricting pollution, a region provides a service with a measurable opportunity cost.

The data also reflects the Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) theory. As GDP per capita approached 120,000 Yuan, wastewater discharge began to stabilize, suggesting that higher wealth levels eventually lead to a decoupling of economic growth from environmental degradation through better technology and increased awareness.

Results: Quantifying the Sacrifice

In 2017, the actual wastewater discharge in the upstream Conghua District was only 45.343 tons per capita. However, the model predicted a "theoretical" discharge of 158.42 tons based on its economic status. This gap of 113.077 tons per capita represents the scale of the district's environmental contribution.

For the year 2017, the total calculated ecological compensation for Conghua District was 33.821 billion Chinese Yuan. This figure represents a staggering 84.5% of Conghua's total GDP for that year, highlighting the massive economic potential "donated" to downstream regions under current conditions.

Limitations and Future Directions

While providing a robust framework, the study notes several limitations:

  • Metric Granularity: The model uses wastewater volume rather than pollutant concentration, which affects actual treatment costs.
  • Pricing Subjectivity: The unit price for emission rights was derived from a 2013 regional study; a local, active market for these rights would provide more accurate pricing.
  • Data Availability: Publicly available district-specific pollutant data is limited, requiring some generalized assumptions across the basin.

Future research should aim to refine pricing mechanisms and incorporate diverse water quality indicators beyond simple discharge volume to improve the model's precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

Researches on standards of ecological compensation will raise awareness of protecting the ecological environment in the basin and maintain the economy’s and society’s sustainable development. This paper constructed an ecological compensation model on the Liuxi River Basin in Guangzhou, China. Data and statistics were acquired from the statistical yearbook in Guangzhou Statistical Information Network, including the total GDP, total wastewater discharge amount and total population of Guangzhou for 13 years (1995, 2000, 2005–2015). Then, SPSS was used to fit the scatter plot of volume of wastewater discharged per capita and GDP per capita, and the most accurate regression equation was selected. Most importantly, an ecological compensation model was constructed based on emission rights and it was then used to calculate the annual eco-compensation fee for Conghua, where the river’s upper part is located. The results showed that the amount of ecological compensation in 2017 was 33.821 billion Chinese Yuan, which should be used to compensate Conghua for the emission rights it had given up for protecting water quality of the Liuxi River. This study provided an effective reference to the government’s decision on continuous improvement of the “Guangzhou Ecological Compensation Plan for Liuxi River Basin”.
BibTeX
@article{pan2019ecological,
  author = {Bole Pan and Haoxuan Tan and Bojun Mao and Yixian Shen and Zhuoyuan Lu and Yongzhang Pan and Wei Zuo},
  title = {{An Ecological Compensation Model for Liuxi River Basin Based on Emission Rights}},
  journal = {Journal of Management and Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5539/jms.v9n2p128},
}
Figure