TL;DR
This paper presents an accessible, open-source logic analyzer built on low-cost FPGAs for long-term, precise jitter measurements. It overcomes the limitations of commercial devices by offering a bufferless, real-time data acquisition system that can continuously monitor signals for days, making it ideal for demanding scientific and industrial applications.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Many scientific and industrial applications, particularly in real-time communication, require continuous, long-term monitoring of signals to analyze phenomena like worst-case jitter. Existing commercial logic analyzers are often expensive, have limited channels, and are designed for short-duration hardware debugging, making them unsuitable for extended data acquisition. They typically rely on a "capture-then-transmit" model, which can lead to missed data during transmission, especially with limited bandwidth. This paper addresses the need for an affordable, flexible, and robust solution for long-term jitter analysis that can capture data continuously without data loss.
Methods
The core of the proposed solution is a custom FPGA design that avoids traditional buffering. Instead, it processes input signals in real-time and transmits them directly over Ethernet to a personal computer. This bufferless approach, combined with an open-source toolchain, significantly simplifies the design and debugging process.
The system comprises several key FPGA Intellectual Property (IP) cores:
ws_trigger_ch: Detects edges on a master channel to establish a time source and defines measurement windows.ws_log_ch: Timestamps edges of all input signals using the time source fromws_trigger_ch.ws_log_max: Evaluates jitter by calculating the difference between edge timestamps of input and reference channels. It also dynamically adjusts the data exchange rate, sending data at a higher rate only when jitter exceeds a defined threshold, thus optimizing data volume.udp_send: Generates User Datagram Protocol (UDP) frames for transmitting data over Ethernet.rmii_send_byte/rmii_send_byte_v2: Implement the Reduced Media Interface (RMII) for Ethernet communication.
The data captured by the FPGA is then processed on a PC using a combination of Wireshark for capturing network traffic and Octave (or MATLAB/Python) for data analysis and visualization. This separation of concerns enhances robustness and allows for independent modification of capturing and processing tools.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it utilizes a sample dataset named logdump.txt for demonstrating the parsing and analysis of captured experimental data. This dataset is generated from the experimental setup described in the validation section.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bufferless Real-time Processing: The most significant insight is the elimination of data buffers in the FPGA. This drastically simplifies the design, reduces debugging time, and makes the system inherently more robust against data loss during long-term measurements, as buffer overflow is no longer a concern.
- Dynamic Data Exchange Rate: The
ws_log_maxIP core's ability to dynamically adjust the data transmission rate based on jitter levels is a clever optimization. It ensures that only relevant "points of interest" (where jitter is high) are transmitted at a higher frequency, significantly reducing the overall data volume for long experiments. - Open-Source Ecosystem: The reliance on open-source tools (FPGA toolchain, Wireshark, Octave) makes the solution highly accessible and customizable. This empowers researchers to adapt and extend the design without vendor lock-in or expensive licensing.
- Modularity and Customization: The design is built from modular IP cores, allowing users to easily scale the number of channels or adapt the functionality for applications beyond jitter analysis.
Key Results
The proposed logic analyzer achieved a precision of ±10 ns for edge timestamping when clocked at 100 MHz, which is comparable to industrial solutions. Experimental validation showed that the differences between the logic analyzer's measurements and those from a high-end digital oscilloscope were within ±20 ns, aligning with the theoretical error limits. The system demonstrated its capability for long-term monitoring, with the potential to record data for days. The cost of the hardware is also significantly lower than commercial alternatives, ranging from $61.5 to $265 USD.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Initial Channels: The reference design is provided for 4 channels, but the paper notes that increasing the number of channels is straightforward by modifying the top module and adding more
ws_log_chandws_log_maxinstances. - Signal Type Compatibility: The current design assumes 3.3V LVCMOS digital signals. Other signal types might require additional hardware or synthesis tool configurations.
- Ethernet Speed Negotiation: While the design supports 100 Mbps Ethernet, achieving this speed might require careful configuration of the Ethernet PHY's MODE pins, especially when using different FPGA kits.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that the modular IP core structure makes it easy to adapt the design for custom application-specific FPGA equipment and for educational purposes, demonstrating modern communication protocols without proprietary IP cores. The flexibility of the design also allows for easy porting to different FPGA architectures.
Summary updated