An Autoregressive Approach to Nonparametric Hierarchical Dependent Modeling

Zhihua Zhang, Dakan Wang, Edward Y. ChangAISTATS 2012 · OpenReview

Abstract

We propose a conditional autoregression framework for a collection of random probability measures. Under this framework, we devise a conditional autoregressive Dirichlet process (DP) that we call $\omega$DDP. This model allows for sharing information across related datasets through a single parameter $\omega$ that controls the degree of dependence. We provide an efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm based on a conditional Pólya urn scheme, demonstrating superior performance in multivariate regression tasks.

Introduction

In Bayesian nonparametrics, the Dirichlet Process (DP) is a fundamental tool for modeling unknown distributions and clustering data. However, standard DP models typically assume that data originates from a single source. In many real-world applications, researchers encounter data from multiple related "studies"—such as clinical trials conducted across different hospitals or multivariate regression tasks with multiple correlated outputs.

The core challenge in these scenarios is modeling the dependency between studies. Treating them as independent ignores the opportunity to "borrow strength" from shared information, while treating them as identical ignores the unique characteristics of each study. Dependent DPs (DDPs) were developed to bridge this gap, but existing versions often struggle with a trade-off: they are either computationally demanding, requiring complex stick-breaking representations, or they rely on approximations that forfeit theoretical guarantees.

The $\omega$DDP Framework

The authors propose a conditional autoregressive framework for a collection of random probability measures. In this setup, the distribution for a specific study $j$ is defined as a weighted combination of its own unique "innovation" and the distributions of other studies. The primary contribution is the one-parameter dependent DP ($\omega$DDP).

Key Features

  • The $\omega$ Parameter: A single parameter, $\omega$, governs the strength of dependence. As $\omega \to \infty$, the studies approach independence; as $\omega \to 0$, they become identical. This provides a simple yet powerful mechanism for tuning the model's flexibility.
  • Dual Representations: The authors prove that $\omega$DDP has two equivalent forms. One resembles the classic stick-breaking representation, and the other leads to a conditional Pólya urn scheme. The latter is particularly valuable for developing tractable inference algorithms.
  • Computational Efficiency: By mapping the model to a Pólya urn scheme, the authors develop an efficient MCMC algorithm. Unlike spatial DPs that require inverting large $n \times n$ matrices, this approach remains efficient for large-scale datasets by utilizing the Sherman-Morrison-Woodbury formula to handle updates.
Graphical representations of the proposed $\omega$DDP (a) compared to independent (b) and single (c) DP models.

Experimental Evaluation

The $\omega$DDP was evaluated on four diverse real-world datasets for multivariate-response regression: Chemometrics (22-dim), Biscuit (700-dim), Forest Fire (7-dim), and Robot Arm (12-dim). These datasets vary significantly in dimensionality and the number of response variables, providing a robust testbed for the model's generalizability.

Key Results

The $\omega$DDP consistently outperformed baseline models, including independent DPs (iDPs), spatial DPs (sDP), and dpReg, across almost all metrics.

  • Biscuit Data: In this high-dimensional setting, the $\omega$DDP achieved an average predictive squared error of 0.1789, significantly lower than the iDPs (0.2611) and sDP (0.2377). Notably, hierarchical models like dpReg often struggle with such high input dimensions, whereas $\omega$DDP remains robust.
  • Chemometrics Data: The model achieved the lowest average error (0.0095) among all tested methods, demonstrating its precision in lower-dimensional but complex chemical modeling tasks.
  • Forest Fire & Robot Arm: The model maintained its lead, showing that the autoregressive coupling is a robust way to handle dependencies across different types of physical and environmental data.
Predictive Squared Errors for the Biscuit Data, highlighting $\omega$DDP's superior average performance.

Discussion and Future Work

The $\omega$DDP's autoregressive structure naturally formalizes the concept of "borrowing strength" across studies. It allows the model to transfer statistical power from well-sampled studies to those with sparse data. By showing that their autoregressive form is equivalent to a Pólya urn scheme, the authors bypass the need for the truncations typically required in stick-breaking DDPs, preserving the "countably infinite" nature of the DP while keeping the mathematics tractable.

Future research directions include:

  1. Adaptive $\omega$: While the model is relatively insensitive to the exact value of $\omega$, learning it adaptively from the data could further improve performance.
  2. Input-Dependent Weights: Making the weights linking studies dependent on input features ($x$) to allow for even more flexible local dependencies.
  3. Classification Extension: Extending the framework to Bayesian multicategory classification by introducing auxiliary variables.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a conditional autoregression framework for a collection of random probability measures. Under this framework, we devise a conditional autoregressive Dirichlet process (DP) that we call o...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2012autoregressive,
  author = {Zhihua Zhang and Dakan Wang and Edward Y. Chang},
  title = {{An Autoregressive Approach to Nonparametric Hierarchical Dependent Modeling}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Ml6GByPLpPW},
}
Figure