An Archival Search for Very-High-Energy Counterparts to Sub-Threshold Neutron-Star Merger Candidates

C. B. Adams, I. Bartos, K. R. Corley, Szabolcs Márka, Z. Márka, Doğa Veske, M. Capasso, R. A. Ong, I. Sadeh, P. Kaaret, W. Jin, W. Benbow, R. Mukherjee, R. R. Prado, M. Lundy, S. Patel, P. Moriarty, G. Maier, A. Furniss, Ken Ragan, D. A. Williams, J. H. Buckley, L. Fortson, J. Quinn, J. Holder, C. Giuri, E. Pueschel, D. Nieto, S. O’Brien, D. Ribeiro, K. Pfrang, O. Gueta, G. M. Foote, A. J. Weinstein, S. Kumar, T. J. Williamson, D. Tak, C.e. McGrath, T. K. Kleiner, M. Pohl, P. T. Reynolds, B. Hona, D. Hanna, M. Santander, G. H. Sembroski, M. Errando, Mary Kertzman, O. Hervet, M. Nievas Rosillo, M. J. Lang, E. Roache, T. B. Humensky, R. Shang, V. V. Vassiliev, Aleksey Cherman, Abe Falcone, Jodi Christiansen, A. N. Otte, A. Gent, A. Brill, J. Ryan, K. A. Farrell, Gary Gillanders, Q. Feng, A. Archer, D. KiedaProceedings of 37th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2021) 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores a novel approach to finding elusive very-high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray counterparts to neutron-star merger candidates. By analyzing archival data from the VERITAS telescope, researchers searched for VHE signals coincident with "sub-threshold" gravitational wave events from LIGO/Virgo, which are promising but not definitively detected. This method opens up a new avenue for multimessenger astronomy, leveraging previously overlooked data to potentially uncover new astrophysical phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The detection of gravitational waves (GWs) from the binary neutron star (BNS) merger GW170817, followed by its electromagnetic counterpart, revolutionized multimessenger astrophysics. This event highlighted the importance of observing these cataclysmic events across multiple cosmic messengers. However, GW detectors like LIGO and Virgo often flag "sub-threshold" candidates – events that show some signal but don't meet the strict statistical significance for a definitive detection. These sub-threshold candidates are still scientifically interesting and could be associated with real astrophysical events. The challenge is that by the time these GW candidates are identified, traditional follow-up observations with VHE gamma-ray telescopes (like VERITAS, H.E.S.S., and MAGIC) might have missed any transient emission due to the time delay. This paper addresses the gap of not being able to effectively search for VHE counterparts to these potentially valuable sub-threshold GW events using existing archival data.

Methods

The core of this study is an archival search algorithm designed to identify coincident observations between sub-threshold BNS merger candidates and archival data from the VERITAS VHE gamma-ray telescope array. The algorithm was developed to:

  • Identify Sub-threshold GW Candidates: The study utilized a catalog of 103 sub-threshold BNS merger candidates identified during Advanced LIGO's first observing run (O1). These candidates had a false-alarm rate of less than one per day.
  • Spatial and Temporal Coincidence: For each sub-threshold GW candidate, the algorithm searched for VERITAS observations that met two criteria:
  • Spatial Coincidence: The VERITAS observation's field of view had to overlap with the 90% credible region of the GW candidate's localization.
  • Temporal Coincidence: The VERITAS observation had to occur within a specific time window around the GW event's coalescence time (specifically, between -10 and +104 seconds).
  • VHE Data Analysis: For each identified coincident observation, the researchers analyzed the VERITAS data to search for statistically significant excesses of VHE gamma rays.
  • Upper Limit Calculation: In the absence of significant excesses, the study calculated 99% confidence bounded upper limits on the integral flux of VHE gamma rays from the sky regions covered by the VERITAS observations.

This approach leverages existing data and a well-defined search strategy to maximize the scientific return from past observations.

Datasets

  • Gravitational Wave Data: The study used a catalog of 103 sub-threshold binary neutron star (BNS) merger candidates from the first observing run (O1) of the Advanced LIGO detector. These candidates were publicly released and had a false-alarm rate of less than one per day.
  • VHE Gamma-Ray Data: Archival data from the VERITAS (Very Energetic Imaging Telescope Array System) VHE gamma-ray telescope array was used. VERITAS is located at the Fred Lawrence Whipple Observatory in southern Arizona, USA.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sub-threshold GWs as a Rich Source of Multimessenger Targets: The paper strongly advocates for the scientific value of sub-threshold GW candidates. While not meeting the stringent criteria for definitive detection, they represent a statistically significant population that could harbor real astrophysical events.
  • Archival Data as a Powerful Tool: This work demonstrates that valuable scientific discoveries can be made by re-analyzing existing archival data from VHE telescopes. This "free" data can be used to probe events that were not initially targeted for follow-up.
  • The Promise of Coincidence: The core idea is that even if a GW signal is weak, a coincident VHE gamma-ray signal, when combined, could provide the necessary statistical significance for a joint detection. This is particularly true for events that might be missed by individual observatories.
  • Complementary Sky Coverage: The paper highlights how different VHE observatories (VERITAS, H.E.S.S., MAGIC) have complementary sky coverage, increasing the chances of a coincident observation for a given GW event.
  • Future Potential with CTA: The advent of the Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is expected to significantly enhance this type of search due to its larger field of view and improved pointing capabilities.

Key Results

  • The algorithm identified 11 sets of archival VERITAS observations that were spatially and temporally coincident with 7 sub-threshold BNS merger candidates from LIGO's O1 run.
  • No statistically significant VHE gamma-ray excesses (above 5σ pre-trial significance) were found in the analyzed VERITAS data.
  • The study calculated 99% confidence bounded upper limits on the integral flux of VHE gamma rays for the observed sky regions.
  • The estimated astrophysical probability of observing a true astrophysical merger with exact spatial coincidence in the search time window was calculated to be a low 0.04%. This low probability is attributed to the limited number of GW events and the specific search criteria.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Probability of True Coincidence: The authors acknowledge that the probability of a true astrophysical merger being observed by VERITAS with exact spatial coincidence within the search time window was low (0.04%) for the O1 data. This is a limitation inherent in searching for rare events with limited data.
  • Sub-threshold Nature of GW Candidates: The primary limitation is the sub-threshold nature of the GW candidates themselves, meaning they are not definitively confirmed events.
  • Future Work:
    • Broader Participation: The authors emphasize that as statistics improve with broader participation from more observatories and more GW observing runs, the probability of finding coincident signals will increase.
  • Real-time Alerts: The paper suggests that sub-threshold events could be incorporated into real-time alert systems, allowing for marginal adjustments to observing schedules to favor regions with higher probability of coincident VHE observations.
  • New Observing Runs: Future observing runs from LIGO/Virgo and other GW detectors will provide more sub-threshold candidates, expanding the dataset for archival searches.
  • CTA Era: The development of the Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is highlighted as a significant future prospect, offering improved capabilities for VHE observations and potentially enabling a factor of 5-16 improvement in search efficiency.
  • Divergent Pointing Strategy: CTA's potential for a divergent pointing strategy could further enhance the search for VHE counterparts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent discovery of electromagnetic signals in coincidence with gravitational waves from neutron-star mergers has solidified the importance of multimessenger campaigns for studying the most energetic astrophysical events. Pioneering multimessenger observatories, such as the LIGO/Virgo gravitational wave detectors and the IceCube neutrino observatory, record many candidate signals that fall short of the detection significance threshold. These sub-threshold event candidates are promising targets for multimessenger studies, as the information provided by these candidates may, when combined with time-coincident gamma-ray observations, lead to significant detections. In this contribution, I describe our use of sub-threshold binary neutron star merger candidates identified in Advanced LIGO’s first observing run (O1) to search for transient events in very-high-energy gamma rays using archival observations from the VERITAS imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescope array. I describe the promise of this technique for future joint sub-threshold searches.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adams2021archival,
  author = {C. B. Adams and I. Bartos and K. R. Corley and Szabolcs Márka and Z. Márka and Doğa Veske and M. Capasso and R. A. Ong and I. Sadeh and P. Kaaret and W. Jin and W. Benbow and R. Mukherjee and R. R. Prado and M. Lundy and S. Patel and P. Moriarty and G. Maier and A. Furniss and Ken Ragan and D. A. Williams and J. H. Buckley and L. Fortson and J. Quinn and J. Holder and C. Giuri and E. Pueschel and D. Nieto and S. O’Brien and D. Ribeiro and K. Pfrang and O. Gueta and G. M. Foote and A. J. Weinstein and S. Kumar and T. J. Williamson and D. Tak and C.E. McGrath and T. K. Kleiner and M. Pohl and P. T. Reynolds and B. Hona and D. Hanna and M. Santander and G. H. Sembroski and Sonal Ramesh Patel and M. Errando and Mary Kertzman and O. Hervet and M. Nievas Rosillo and M. J. Lang and E. Roache and T. B. Humensky and R. Shang and V. V. Vassiliev and Aleksey Cherman and Abe Falcone and Jodi Christiansen and A. N. Otte and A. Gent and A. Brill and J. Ryan and K. A. Farrell and Gary Gillanders and Q. Feng and A. Archer and D. Kieda},
  title = {{An Archival Search for Very-High-Energy Counterparts to Sub-Threshold Neutron-Star Merger Candidates}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of 37th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2021)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.22323/1.395.0948},
}
Figure