An approach to differentiating biological from chemical sulfide oxidation on corroded concrete sewer surfaces

Huang Xin, Yifang Yin, Zhiqiang Zuo, Tao Shi, Thomas Kuen, Zhiguo Yuan, Min ZhengbioRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel kinetic modeling approach to differentiate between chemical and biological oxidation of hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) on corroded concrete sewer surfaces. This distinction is crucial for developing more effective and targeted corrosion control strategies, as the relative contributions of these two pathways vary significantly with H₂S concentration and the degree of concrete corrosion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sewer systems worldwide are under constant threat from hydrogen sulfide (H₂S)-induced corrosion, which significantly shortens their lifespan and incurs substantial repair costs. H₂S, a common byproduct of wastewater decomposition, can be oxidized into sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄) through two primary mechanisms: direct chemical oxidation and biological oxidation mediated by microorganisms. While both processes contribute to concrete degradation, their relative importance and how they change with environmental conditions (like H₂S concentration and concrete acidity) have been difficult to disentangle. This lack of clear differentiation hinders the development of precise and cost-effective strategies for managing sewer corrosion, as current methods often address both pathways indiscriminately.

Methods

The researchers developed a kinetic model that integrates both chemical and biological H₂S oxidation processes. The model uses the Sulfide Uptake Rate (SUR), a measure of H₂S consumption on the concrete surface, as the primary data input.

  • Chemical Oxidation: Modeled using a first-order kinetic equation, implying its rate is directly proportional to the H₂S concentration. This was validated using sterile (virgin) concrete coupons and an acrylic board.
  • Biological Oxidation: Modeled using the Monod equation, a standard approach for describing microbial growth and substrate consumption kinetics, acknowledging that biological activity is dependent on H₂S as a nutrient source.
  • Integrated Model: The total SUR is represented as the sum of the chemical and biological oxidation rates. This integrated model was then calibrated and validated using experimental data from naturally corroded concrete coupons of varying ages and pH levels.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data generated from:

  • Virgin Concrete Coupons (VC): Used as a control to isolate chemical oxidation.
  • Acrylic Board: Also used to represent a non-biological surface for chemical oxidation studies.
  • Corroded Concrete Coupons: Three coupons with different "culture times" (3, 9, and 32 months) in a simulated sewer corrosion environment, representing varying degrees of corrosion and surface pH.
  • Pilot Sewer Pipe Study Data: External data was used for further validation of the developed model.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study generated and analyzed its own experimental data to validate its proposed model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chemical Oxidation is Not Always Secondary: While biological oxidation is often emphasized, this study highlights that chemical oxidation can become dominant, especially in heavily corroded concrete and at higher H₂S concentrations.
  • pH as a Key Indicator: The degree of concrete corrosion, reflected by a lower surface pH, significantly accelerates both chemical and biological H₂S oxidation rates.
  • Synergistic Control Needed: The findings strongly suggest that effective sewer corrosion management requires strategies that address both chemical and biological pathways, rather than focusing on just one.
  • H₂S Threshold for Chemical Dominance: A critical insight is that chemical oxidation can predominate when H₂S concentrations exceed approximately 300 ppm.

Key Results

  • The developed kinetic model accurately described both chemical and biological H₂S oxidation processes across a range of H₂S concentrations and corrosion states.
  • Chemical oxidation rate constant (Kchem) significantly increased with the progression of sewer corrosion (pH decreasing from 7.1 to 1.9). For instance, Kchem values for samples 1, 2, and 3 were 0.09, 0.41, and 0.64 mg-S·m⁻²·h⁻¹·ppm⁻¹, respectively.
  • Maximum biological SUR (Vmax) also substantially increased with corrosion, rising from 24 to 262 mg-S·m⁻²·h⁻¹ from the least to most corroded samples.
  • The substrate half-saturation constant (Km) for biological oxidation was estimated to be between 16.9 and 25.4 ppm, indicating that biological activity is sensitive to H₂S levels around this concentration.
  • At low H₂S concentrations (< 100 ppm), biological oxidation generally predominated. However, at higher concentrations (> 300 ppm), chemical oxidation became more significant, potentially even dominating the total sulfide uptake.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Complexity: While the model effectively differentiates the two pathways, the paper acknowledges the need for further validation across a wider range of sewer conditions and materials.
  • Microbial Community Dynamics: The study observed correlations between pH and microbial community shifts (e.g., acidophilic SOB), but a deeper understanding of how specific microbial consortia influence the biological oxidation rates under varying conditions would be beneficial.
  • Real-World Application: The authors suggest that the developed model can serve as a valuable tool for future corrosion studies and provide insights for more tailored sewer corrosion management practices, implying that further work is needed to translate these findings into practical engineering solutions.
  • Extremely High H₂S Concentrations: The paper notes that the kinetic discrepancy for chemical sulfide oxidation needs careful consideration at extremely high H₂S concentrations, suggesting this as an area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Hydrogen sulfide (H 2 S)-induced sewer corrosion largely impacts the longevity of infrastructure worldwide. The corrosion incorporates two pathways, i.e., chemical and biological oxidation of H 2 S to sulfuric acid; however, their rates are difficult to differentiate on corroded sewer pipelines, limiting understanding and application of effective strategies for corrosion control. Here, this study develops and reports a kinetic approach to determining rates of chemical and biological sulfide oxidation. By measuring the total sulfide uptake rate of sewer corrosion concretes, extensive experimental data was obtained for calibration and validation of the proposed kinetic model. The modelling results fit with measured data indicating that both chemical and biological sulfide oxidation can be well-described by the developed model. Model predictions revealed that along with sewer corrosion (i.e., pH decrease), chemical sulfide oxidation rate was significantly accelerated, along with an increase in biological rate. This result suggests that the chemical sulfide oxidation process should not be overlooked for seriously corroded concretes, and synergistic strategies to suppress both biological and chemical rates are required. Specifically, the chemical process can predominate sulfide oxidation with a gas-H 2 S concentration higher than 300 ppm. The work provides a useful tool for future corrosion studies and also valuable insights for sewer corrosion management practices. Synopsis This study reports a kinetic approach to determining chemical and biological H 2 S oxidation rates of sewer concretes. Graphic abstract
BibTeX
@misc{xin2025approach,
  author = {Huang Xin and Yifang Yin and Zhiqiang Zuo and Tao Shi and Thomas Kuen and Zhiguo Yuan and Min Zheng},
  title = {{An approach to differentiating biological from chemical sulfide oxidation on corroded concrete sewer surfaces}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.05.13.653906},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure