TL;DR
This paper evaluates China's Feed-in Tariff (FIT) policies for solar PV and wind power, finding that the "parity policy" significantly boosts economic and environmental competitiveness compared to the earlier "guiding price policy." However, the current policies are insufficient to incentivize R&D and the parity policy itself is not ideal for long-term implementation due to cost mismatches, suggesting a need for gradual decoupling from thermal power tariffs and exploring new market mechanisms.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China has heavily relied on Feed-in Tariffs (FITs) to drive the growth of its renewable energy sector, particularly solar PV and wind power. These policies aim to incentivize investment and development by guaranteeing a fixed price for electricity fed into the grid. However, as these policies evolve (from benchmark prices to guiding prices, and now to "parity" where tariffs are set to match thermal power), it's crucial to understand their actual impact. This paper addresses the need to:
- Evaluate the effectiveness of different FIT policy phases: Specifically, comparing the "guiding price policy" (pre-2021) with the current "parity policy" (post-2021) in terms of economic and environmental outcomes.
- Assess the impact on R&D and market mechanisms: Determine if FIT policies are encouraging innovation and how effectively new mechanisms like green certificates are substituting for direct government subsidies.
- Optimize future policy design: Identify potential issues with the current parity policy and propose adjustments for long-term sustainability and efficiency.
Methods
The authors employ a novel composite modeling approach, combining real options theory with cost-benefit analysis. They developed two main models:
- Evaluation Model of Implementation Effects: This model assesses the economic and environmental performance of past and current FIT policies. It uses a dynamic recursive approach to account for uncertainties and the decision-making flexibility of power generation enterprises.
- Optimization Model for Policy Design: This model aims to determine optimal feed-in tariff levels and evaluate the suitability of the current pricing mechanism for long-term use. It involves simulating the impact of different tariff levels on comprehensive benefits and identifying potential price reduction room.
Key to their approach is the construction of Net Economic Benefits and Net Environmental Benefits functions, which are then aggregated into Net Comprehensive Benefits. They also incorporate dynamic parameters to simulate factors like generation cost fluctuations and R&D investment decisions.
Datasets
The study utilizes a range of data sources:
- Policy Documents: Issued by the NDRC (National Development and Reform Commission) and NEA (National Energy Administration) regarding FIT policies.
- Economic Data:
- Bohairim Steamcoal Price Index (for thermal power generation cost calibration).
- Annual Report of China's Electricity Industry (for thermal power feed-in tariffs and generating capacity by region).
- NBS (National Bureau of Statistics) data for PV and wind power generating capacity.
- Public data on R&D investment from listed companies in PV and wind power generation.
- Industry Data:
- IRENA (International Renewable Energy Agency) data for learning rates in PV and wind power cost reduction.
- GWEC (Global Wind Energy Council) and CPIA (China Photovoltaic Industry Association) reports for industry trends and projections.
- Market Data:
- China's Green Certificate Subscription Platform data for green certificate transaction prices and volumes.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Parity Policy Wins: The current "parity policy" is significantly more effective than the previous "guiding price policy" in promoting both the economic competitiveness and environmental benefits of PV and wind power development.
- R&D Lag: Despite policy efforts, the FIT policies examined have not successfully incentivized power generation enterprises to invest more in R&D. This suggests a need for targeted support for upstream industries.
- Green Certificates Fall Short: While green certificates and CCER (Chinese Certified Emission Reduction) are intended to substitute for government subsidies, their impact on reducing overall subsidy pressure is currently limited.
- Room for Tariff Reduction: The "parity policy" tariffs are higher than what's needed to maximize overall benefits, indicating a potential for further reduction (10.306% to 22.981%) as costs continue to fall.
- Long-Term Parity Policy Risks: The parity policy, by pegging tariffs to thermal power, doesn't fully account for the unique cost dynamics of PV and wind, and risks exacerbating regional investment disparities.
Key Results
- Economic & Environmental Gains: Under the parity policy, Net Comprehensive Benefits increased by 2.524 to 3.136 times compared to the guiding price policy, across conservative, neutral, and positive scenarios.
- R&D Ineffectiveness: The study found that FIT policies "fail to effectively encourage the power generation market as a whole to invest in research and development."
- Limited Subsidy Substitution: Benefits for State Subsidies, while increasing with the parity policy, accounted for less than 0.01% of Net Environmental Benefits, highlighting the limited substitution effect of green certificates.
- CO2 Emission Reduction: The parity policy showed a 1.715 to 2.098 times increase in Benefits of Emission Reduction compared to the guiding price policy.
- Tariff Reduction Potential: The optimal weighted average feed-in tariffs for maximizing comprehensive benefits are 10.306% to 22.981% lower than current parity policy tariffs.
Limitations and Future Work
- R&D Incentives: The paper explicitly notes that FIT policies have not been effective in encouraging R&D investment. Future work should explore supporting policies to incentivize R&D in upstream industries.
- Market Mechanism Enhancement: The limited substitution effect of green certificates suggests a need for new market compensation mechanisms, such as restarting CCER nationwide, to better capture the environmental value of renewables.
- Long-Term Parity Policy Issues: The authors identify risks with the parity policy, including mismatched cost attributes and uneven regional investment. They recommend that the parity policy is only suitable as a transitional policy.
- Future Policy Direction: The paper strongly suggests that FIT tariffs for PV and wind power should progressively be disconnected from thermal power tariffs. This implies a move towards more dynamic and region-specific pricing mechanisms, potentially incorporating a "benchmark FIT + range for fluctuation" approach.
Summary updated