An Analytical Model for Squeeze-Film Damping of Perforated Torsional Microplates Resonators

Pu Li, Yuming Fang2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new analytical model for predicting squeeze-film damping in perforated torsional microplates, a crucial factor affecting the performance of micro-resonators. The model offers a more efficient and insightful alternative to complex finite element methods, particularly for devices with smaller to medium perforation ratios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Micro-resonators are essential components in many MEMS devices, and their performance is often limited by squeeze-film damping, which significantly impacts their quality factors (Q-factors). Perforations in microplates are a common design feature used to tune this damping. While analytical models exist for squeeze-film damping in microplates undergoing normal motion, there's a notable gap in analytical models specifically for torsional microplates, which are also widely used. Existing analytical approaches for perforated plates often rely on simplifying assumptions or are limited in scope. This paper aims to fill this gap by developing an analytical model for perforated torsional microplates, providing a more accessible tool for understanding and designing these devices.

Methods

The authors build upon the modified Reynolds equation, a standard tool for modeling fluid dynamics in micro-gaps. Their approach involves:

  • Modified Reynolds Equation: They start with a modified Reynolds equation that accounts for air compressibility and rarefaction effects, which are important at the micro-scale.
  • Double Sine Series: The pressure distribution within the air gap is approximated using a double sine series. This is a common technique for solving partial differential equations with specific boundary conditions.
  • Analytical Derivation: They derive closed-form expressions for the stiffness and damping coefficients of the squeeze-film. This is the core of their analytical approach, aiming to provide direct formulas rather than requiring numerical simulations.
  • Two Types of Torsion Plates: The model is developed for two distinct types of torsion plates: Type I (symmetric with respect to the rotation axis) and Type II (asymmetric).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on developing an analytical model and validating it against existing numerical (FEM) and experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Torsional Damping is Under-Researched: The paper highlights a significant gap in analytical modeling for torsional microplates, despite their prevalence in MEMS.
  • Analytical Models Offer Advantages: For simpler geometries, analytical models provide better physical insight and are computationally more efficient than full 3D FEM simulations, which can be time-consuming for structures with thousands of perforations.
  • Perforation Ratio is Key: The degree of perforation (represented by $l_h/l_p$) significantly influences damping. The model shows good agreement with FEM for smaller to medium perforation ratios, but discrepancies arise at higher ratios.
  • Limitations of Simplified Models: The paper acknowledges that the assumption of a continuous pressure function and the neglect of inertial effects limit the model's validity at high perforation ratios and high frequencies, respectively.

Key Results

The paper presents analytical models for both symmetric (Type I) and asymmetric (Type II) perforated torsional microplates.

  • Validation: The derived analytical models are validated against Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations and experimental data from Pandey et al. [21].
  • Agreement: The analytical model shows good agreement with FEM results for both damping and spring constants, particularly for devices with smaller and medium perforation ratios ($l_h/l_p \le 0.6$ for damping, $l_h/l_p \le 0.7$ for spring constants).
  • Discrepancy at High Perforation: A clear discrepancy is observed between the analytical model and FEM results at large perforation ratios. This is attributed to the assumption of continuous pressure and the FEM approach's limitations in capturing damping from channel mechanical resistance.
  • Experimental Comparison: The model also shows good agreement with experimental data for quality factors at higher pressures (above 0.5 Torr), but discrepancies at lower pressures are linked to the continuum assumption failing in transition/free molecular flow regimes and the contribution of intrinsic material damping.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Perforation Ratio Limit: The model's accuracy decreases significantly for large perforation ratios ($l_h/l_p > 0.6-0.7$). This is due to the assumption of continuous pressure and the FEM approach's limitations.
  • Inertial Effects: The current model neglects inertial effects, which limits its validity at higher operating frequencies.
  • Continuum Assumption: The model treats the gas as a continuum, which is not accurate at very low pressures where the Knudsen number is high (transition or free molecular flow regimes).
  • Future Work: The authors are currently working on extending the model to account for inertial effects to cover a wider frequency range. They also acknowledge the need to address the limitations at high perforation ratios and low pressures.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{li2015analytical,
  author = {Pu Li and Yuming Fang},
  title = {{An Analytical Model for Squeeze-Film Damping of Perforated Torsional Microplates Resonators}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/s150407388},
}

Loading related content...

Figure