An Analytical Model for Rock Cutting with a Chisel Pick of the Cutter Suction Dredger

Yiping Ouyang, Qi Yang, Xinquan Chen, Yongfu XuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new analytical model, the Crushed Zone Expansion Induced Tensile Failure (CEIT) model, to more accurately predict the cutting forces of chisel picks on cutter suction dredgers (CSDs). By incorporating the "sidewall effect" and a three-dimensional approach, the CEIT model significantly improves upon existing models, offering better predictions for rock excavation in port and waterway construction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estimating the cutting forces exerted by the chisel picks of Cutter Suction Dredgers (CSDs) on rock is crucial for efficient and safe rock excavation in port and waterway construction. However, existing analytical models often struggle to accurately predict these forces, particularly under the specific conditions of CSD operations. These conditions typically involve large cutting depths, positive rake angles, and a significant interaction between the pick and the rock on its sides, known as the "sidewall effect." Previous models, often based on 2D analyses or simplified failure mechanisms, tend to underestimate cutting forces and fail to capture the complex fracture behavior observed in real-world scenarios. This gap hinders precise equipment design, operational planning, and energy efficiency in dredging operations.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of the Crushed Zone Expansion Induced Tensile Failure (CEIT) model. This model builds upon existing theories of tensile rock breakage and cavity expansion. Key methodological aspects include:

  • Three-Dimensional Approach: Unlike many prior models that are 2D, the CEIT model considers the rock cutting process in three dimensions, which is more representative of actual pick-rock interaction.
  • Crushed Zone Concept: The model assumes that as the chisel pick penetrates the rock, a crushed zone forms at the tip. The expansion of this zone is the primary driver for initiating tensile cracks and causing rock fracture.
  • Tensile Breakage Theory: The model is fundamentally based on the idea that rock failure occurs due to tensile stresses generated by the expanding crushed zone.
  • Sidewall Effect Integration: A novel aspect of the CEIT model is its explicit consideration of the "sidewall effect." This refers to the influence of the rock on the sides of the chisel pick, which becomes significant when the cutting depth is large relative to the cutting width. This effect is incorporated through a specific term in the model's equations.
  • Moment Equilibrium: The model utilizes the principle of moment equilibrium about a specific point (B) on the rock chip to relate the forces acting on it and derive the cutting force equations.
  • Breakout Angle Approximation: To facilitate practical application, an approximate method for determining the breakout angle (a key parameter in the model) is developed using regression analysis, correlating it with the rake angle and the ratio of cutting width to cutting depth.

Datasets

The study utilizes experimental data from two sources for validation:

  • Bilgin [28]: This dataset includes rock cutting tests on anhydrite, limestone, granite, and greywacke, providing measurements of peak cutting forces under various conditions.
  • Allington [27]: This dataset provides experimental results for anhydrite and limestone.

These datasets are used to compare the predictions of the CEIT model against experimental measurements and against predictions from existing theoretical models (Evans' and Nishimatsu's).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sidewall Effect is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that the sidewall effect significantly influences cutting forces, especially when the cutting depth is large relative to the cutting width. Ignoring this effect leads to underestimation of cutting forces.
  • Parabolic Cutting Depth Relationship: The CEIT model successfully captures the observed parabolic relationship between cutting force and cutting depth in certain rock types, a phenomenon not explained by previous linear models. This is attributed to the increasing influence of the sidewall effect with greater depth.
  • Three-Dimensionality Matters: The CEIT model's 3D nature and inclusion of the sidewall effect make it a more realistic representation of rock cutting compared to 2D models.
  • Improved Predictive Accuracy: The CEIT model demonstrates superior accuracy in predicting experimental cutting forces compared to established models like Evans' and Nishimatsu's, particularly for conditions relevant to CSD operations.
  • Rake Angle Influence: The model correctly predicts the decreasing trend of cutting force with increasing rake angle, aligning with experimental observations.

Key Results

  • The CEIT model shows significantly better agreement with experimental data than Evans' and Nishimatsu's models across various rock types (anhydrite, limestone, granite, greywacke).
  • Quantitative analysis using Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) and bias indicates that the CEIT model has a lower RMSE and bias, signifying more accurate predictions. For instance, in cutting anhydrite, the CEIT model's RMSE was 4.56, compared to 7.19 for Evans' model and 9.53 for Nishimatsu's model.
  • The CEIT model accurately reproduces the linear relationship between cutting force and cutting width, and the positive intercept observed in experimental data (indicating non-zero force even at zero width), which is a direct consequence of accounting for the sidewall effect.
  • The model captures the parabolic relationship between cutting force and cutting depth when the width-to-depth ratio is small.
  • The sidewall effect coefficient (η) was quantified, showing its strong dependence on the ratio of cutting width to cutting depth and rake angle, and its independence from cutting width itself.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Brittle Fracture Regime: The CEIT model is currently developed for rock cutting under the brittle fracture regime and is not suitable for ductile fracture conditions.
  • Symmetry Assumption: The model assumes a vertical symmetry plane for the chisel pick, parallel to the cutting direction. The effects of inclination and deflection of this plane are not considered.
  • Wear Flat Simplification: The model assumes a wear flat that is small compared to the cutting depth and width. For badly worn picks, improvements are needed to account for the increased friction.
  • Unrelieved Cutting: The model is intended for unrelieved cutting conditions. Its applicability to relieved cutting conditions, where neighboring picks influence the process, requires further investigation.
  • Limited Experimental Data: While validated against available data, the authors acknowledge that the experimental results for verification are inadequate. More experimental data and simulation results are needed for further validation.
  • Relieved Cutting Conditions: Future work should focus on improving the CEIT model to make it suitable for relieved cutting conditions, which are common in practical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cutter suction dredgers are important pieces of rock excavation equipment in port and waterway construction. It is valuable but difficult to properly estimate the cutting force on the chisel pick of the cutter suction dredger. In this paper, an analytical model, called the crushed zone expansion induced tensile failure model (CEIT model), is proposed for rock cutting with a chisel pick in order to predict the peak cutting force (Fc) more accurately. First, a review of the existing models for rock cutting with a chisel pick is presented. Next, based on the tensile breakage theory, cavity expansion theory and some hypotheses, the mathematical formula of the CEIT model is obtained. Different from that in the previous models, the effect of the rock on both sides of the chisel pick on Fc, defined as the sidewall effect is considered in the CEIT model. Then, the predicted Fc by the CEIT model is compared with the predicted Fc by existing theoretical models and experimental results to check the validity of the CEIT model. The results show that the CEIT model can well capture the relationships of Fc to the cutting parameters, including cutting width, cutting depth, and rake angle, and can predict the experimental results much better than the existing models. Finally, the sidewall effect and its influence factors according to the CEIT model are discussed.
BibTeX
@article{ouyang2020analytical,
  author = {Yiping Ouyang and Qi Yang and Xinquan Chen and Yongfu Xu},
  title = {{An Analytical Model for Rock Cutting with a Chisel Pick of the Cutter Suction Dredger}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse8100806},
}

Loading related content...

Figure