An analytical analysis of CDT coupled to dimer-like matter

Max R. Atkin, Stefan ZohrenPhysics 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first analytical solution for a model of "dimers" interacting with Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT) in two dimensions. By developing a novel tree bijection technique, the authors show that this dimer-matter coupling leads to a phase transition and modifies the critical exponents of CDT, moving it beyond the pure gravity universality class.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT) is a promising approach to defining a quantum path integral for gravity by summing over discrete spacetime geometries. While pure CDT has been studied extensively, analytically investigating the behavior of matter coupled to CDT has been a significant challenge. Previous attempts either resulted in models that didn't escape the pure CDT universality class or were effectively one-dimensional. This paper tackles the problem of analytically understanding how a specific type of "dimer" matter influences the geometry of CDT, aiming to find a way to study matter-coupled CDT beyond numerical simulations and to understand if such couplings can alter the fundamental properties of spacetime geometry.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in a novel analytical technique: a tree bijection. This method, inspired by previous work on related models, establishes a one-to-one correspondence between configurations of CDT with dimers and labelled trees.

  1. CDT to Rooted Planar Trees: The authors first adapt a known bijection that maps CDT graphs to rooted planar trees. This involves a specific procedure of "flattening" the CDT and then systematically constructing the tree by following links between spacelike slices.
  2. Incorporating Dimers via Labelling: The key innovation is extending this bijection to account for the "restricted dimer" configurations. Instead of just mapping the triangulation structure, the vertices in the tree are labelled to represent the presence and type of dimers in the corresponding CDT configuration.
  3. Handling Non-Local Interactions: A crucial challenge arises because interactions between dimers in CDT can become "non-local" in the tree representation. The paper introduces a clever mapping between different types of labelled trees to effectively handle these non-local constraints, allowing for the counting of valid dimer configurations.
  4. Generating Functions and Critical Exponents: Using these labelled trees and their associated counting rules, the authors construct generating functions. The properties of these generating functions, particularly their radius of convergence, are then used to determine critical exponents, specifically the string susceptibility ($\gamma$) and the exponent $\sigma$.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical modeling and analytical calculations, not on empirical data or simulation datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Analytical Tractability of Matter-Coupled CDT: The paper demonstrates that it's possible to analytically solve for matter coupled to CDT, a significant step beyond previous limitations.
  • Dimers Induce a Phase Transition: The introduction of dimers, particularly at a negative critical fugacity, leads to a phase transition in the model. This transition is characterized by a change in the critical exponent associated with the geometry.
  • Moving Beyond Pure CDT Universality: The calculated critical exponents ($\gamma$ and $\sigma$) differ from those of pure CDT. This is a crucial finding, indicating that the dimer matter fundamentally alters the nature of the emergent spacetime geometry.
  • Connection to DT Exponents: Surprisingly, the exponent $\sigma$ found in this CDT model matches the value found in similar dimer models coupled to Dynamical Triangulations (DT), despite CDT and DT having distinct properties.
  • The Role of Inter-Slice Interactions: The ability to include dimers that span across different spacelike slices (not just within a slice) is identified as the fundamental reason for the model's departure from pure gravity and the emergence of long-range correlations.

Key Results

  • The paper analytically computes the string susceptibility ($\gamma$) and the critical exponent $\sigma$ for a restricted dimer model coupled to 2D CDT.
  • They find a negative critical value for the dimer fugacity at which a phase transition occurs.
  • The calculated critical exponents are:
  • $\gamma_{modified} = 1/3$
    • $\sigma = 1/2$
  • These values indicate that the model is outside the universality class of pure CDT.
  • The exponent $\sigma = 1/2$ matches the value found for dimers in DT.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Restricted Dimer Model: The current work focuses on a "restricted" dimer model, which excludes dimers in regions of high curvature. The authors acknowledge that this is a simplification.
  • Full Dimer Model: They argue that even when considering the "full" dimer model (including all configurations), the critical exponents are unlikely to revert to their flat-space values, suggesting the restricted model captures the essential physics. However, an explicit analytical solution for the full model is not presented.
  • Continuum Limit Interpretation: While they identify critical exponents, fully characterizing the continuum theory associated with this multicritical point remains an area for further investigation, especially given the absence of a direct KPZ-like formula for CDT.
  • Generalization to Other Matter: The tree bijection technique could potentially be extended to other types of matter coupled to CDT, which would be a natural next step.
  • Higher Dimensions: Extending these analytical techniques to higher-dimensional CDT models would be a significant challenge but highly valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a model of restricted dimers coupled to two-dimensional Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT), where the dimer configurations are restricted in the sense that they do not include dimers in regions of high curvature. It is shown how the model can be solved analytically using bijections with decorated trees. At a negative critical value for the dimer fugacity the model undergoes a phase transition at which the critical exponent associated to the geometry changes. This represents the first account of an analytical study of a matter model with two-dimensional interactions coupled to CDT.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{atkin2012analytical,
  author = {Max R. Atkin and Stefan Zohren},
  title = {{An analytical analysis of CDT coupled to dimer-like matter}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2012.05.017},
}
Figure