An Analysis on Layout Patterns and their Trends in the Prizewinners of Elementary.Middle.High School Design Competitions

Jungwoo Lee, Hyungjin KimThe Journal of Korean Institute of Educational Facilities 2012 · DOI

Abstract

Since the 1990s, the generalization of design competitions in South Korea has spurred diverse architectural approaches for educational facilities. This study analyzes the layout plans and design trends of prize-winning entries in elementary, middle, and high school design competitions to establish a foundational dataset for future school design. The research categorizes building layouts into 12 types, entrance designs into 6 types, and square/plaza designs into 7 types. Analysis reveals that U-shaped (ㄷ) and E-shaped (ㅌ) layouts are most prevalent, while structural frame designs dominate entrances. Pedestrian malls frequently combine straight lines with squares, and parallel entry remains the standard for vehicle and pedestrian circulation.

Introduction: Moving Beyond the "Factory Model"

For decades, South Korean school architecture was defined by rigid "standard drawings"—linear, uniform structures designed for mass instruction rather than creative engagement. The introduction of the 7th National Curriculum in 2000 marked a paradigm shift toward "Open Education," emphasizing student autonomy and creativity. To realize these goals, the government transitioned to open design competitions. However, despite the proliferation of new designs, systematic data on winning architectural trends remained scarce. This paper bridges that gap by analyzing 60 prize-winning competition entries to identify the evolving "DNA" of modern Korean schools.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a qualitative and statistical analysis of 60 award-winning designs for elementary, middle, and high schools across South Korea, all dating from 2000 onwards. The study evaluates these designs across five primary "Layout Planning Elements":

  1. Building Layout: Geometric forms (e.g., L-shape, U-shape, E-shape).
  2. Main Entrance Design: Structural expressions (e.g., open, column-and-wall, integrated frames).
  3. Plazas and Squares: Geometric shapes and spatial positioning.
  4. Pedestrian Malls: Path linearity and integration with social nodes.
  5. Traffic Circulation: Separation or integration of pedestrian and vehicle paths.

Classification of Layout Patterns

The study identifies 12 distinct geometric patterns used in modern school layouts. These range from simple linear forms to complex combined types.

Classification of school building layout patterns including conceptual diagrams and case examples.

The data shows a clear preference for the U-shape (ㄷ-type, 15%) and E-shape (ㅌ-type, 13.3%). These configurations are highly effective in maximizing southern light exposure for classrooms while creating sheltered courtyards that facilitate student interaction—a key requirement of the "Open Education" philosophy.

The analysis reveals several critical insights into what makes a design successful in modern competitions:

  • The Entrance as a Landmark: Over 58% of winning designs utilized a "structural" entrance, often featuring a large, bold frame. This suggests that architects use the entrance as a symbolic "face" to establish a strong institutional identity.
  • Social Spaces and Pedestrian Flow: The most successful pedestrian model (46.7%) combined straight linear axes with integrated squares. This provides clear navigation while creating natural gathering points. However, nearly half of the designs (48.3%) lacked a formal dedicated square, often sacrificing these spaces for other programmatic needs.
  • Complexity and Scale: As educational requirements become more specialized in middle and high schools, layouts tend to become more "Combined" or "Complex" (11.7%) compared to the simpler forms often found in elementary schools.
A 3D rendering of a prize-winning school design illustrating complex layout and integrated outdoor spaces.
  • Safety in Circulation: "Parallel" circulation—where pedestrians and vehicles enter at the same point but follow distinct, separated paths—was the most common approach (40%), balancing site efficiency with student safety.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The shift toward U-shaped and E-shaped layouts reflects a broader move toward flexible, light-filled educational environments. While this study provides a comprehensive overview of exterior site planning and layout trends, the authors suggest that future research should focus on interior "unit classroom" layouts and post-occupancy evaluations (POE) to determine if these award-winning designs truly enhance the learning experience for students and teachers in practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

Owing to generalization of design competitions since 1990s, various design methods was tried in elementary middle high school design competitions. Therefore, to analyze design characteristics of elementary middle high school is very meaningful. In this context, this study is the most important purpose for analyzing layout plans and their trends in prizewinners of elementary middle high school design competitions and for furnishing basic datum for next school design. The result of this study is following : (1) The layout patterns of school buildings are classified into 12 types. (2) Entrance design is divided into 6 types(structure, column and wall, open, half structure, general, and mixed type). (3) Square design is grouped into 7 types. (4) Pedestrian mall is sorted out 6 types(straight lineal, curve, curve and square, straight lineal and curve, and straight lineal and curve and square type). (5) Entrance types of vehicle and pedestrian are classified into 4 types(parallel, ㅡ separation, ㄱ separation, and opposite separation type) Analysis shows that the best applying for layout patterns of school buildings is ㄷ type and ㅌ type, for entrance design is structure type, for square design is <TEX>${\square}$</TEX> type and <TEX>${\bigcirc}$</TEX> type, for pedestrian mall is straight lineal and square type, and for entrance types of vehicle and pedestrian is parallel type.
BibTeX
@article{lee2012analysis,
  author = {Jungwoo Lee and Hyungjin Kim},
  title = {{An Analysis on Layout Patterns and their Trends in the Prizewinners of Elementary.Middle.High School Design Competitions}},
  journal = {The Journal of Korean Institute of Educational Facilities},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.7859/kief.2012.19.3.003},
}
Figure