Abstract
In time-sensitive environments, AI agents face a critical trade-off between the depth of their deliberation and the speed of their actions. This paper investigates this "deliberation-action trade-off" using an Active Logic (AL) framework. By evaluating six distinct reasoning strategies (axiom sets) in a target search task within the AI2-THOR environment, we demonstrate that optimal performance is achieved by balancing bold decision-making with sufficient deliberation to avoid redundancy. Our findings highlight that "over-thinking" can be as detrimental as impulsivity in deadline-constrained tasks.
Introduction
Traditional AI reasoning often treats deliberation as occurring "outside" of time. However, for embodied agents in real-world scenarios, time is a finite and situated resource. Every moment spent in inference is a moment unavailable for task execution. This study utilizes Active Logic, a formalism that explicitly incorporates the passage of time into its reasoning process, to explore how different levels of inferential knowledge impact agent success in a search task with a strict deadline.
Methodology
We deployed an AL-based agent in the AI2-THOR interactive environment to perform a target search task. The agent was equipped with six different action-selection axiom sets, ranging from impulsive to highly deliberative:
- Naive (2 Steps): The boldest agent; randomly selects valid actions but often repeats moves.
- Redundancy Avoidance 2 (RA 2): Avoids immediate unvisited locations but prone to deadlocks.
- RA 2-3 & RA 2-4: Balanced approaches that identify feasible and unvisited actions. RA 2-4 adds layers to identify repeatable actions when no new locations are available.
- RA 3-4 & RA 3-5: Highly cautious strategies requiring explicit feasibility checks and contingency categorization, potentially taking up to 5 reasoning steps per action.
The experimental design involved 1,800 trials across 20 starting configurations, 15 repetitions, and 6 different movement "pace lengths."
Results and Analysis
The experimental results confirm the existence of a "Goldilocks" zone for agent deliberation. The RA 2-4 strategy emerged as the most effective, achieving a 52.7% success rate. This method provided enough caution to avoid redundant moves without the prohibitive time cost of more complex reasoning.
In contrast, the most impulsive strategy (Naive) achieved only a 24.7% success rate due to excessive redundancy. Conversely, the most cautious strategies (RA 3-4 and RA 3-5) saw performance drops to 44.2% and 42.3%, respectively. While these agents were logically rigorous and visited the fewest redundant locations, their "over-thinking" led to deadline expiration before reaching the target.
As shown in the heatmaps (Figures 1 and 2), pace length also significantly impacts performance. Agents generally performed better when taking "bigger strides," which can partially offset the cognitive overhead of deliberation. However, the fundamental ranking of the strategies remained consistent, emphasizing that best-case reasoning time—how quickly an agent can act when the environment is straightforward—is a stronger predictor of success than the depth of its worst-case deliberation.
Conclusion
This research underscores that for time-situated agents, more knowledge is not always beneficial. The time cost of deriving complex knowledge can outweigh the benefits of the resulting actions. Future work will extend this framework to multi-agent cooperative tasks and physical robotic implementations where the temporal costs of reasoning are even more critical.
Summary updated